공법상 당사자소송으로서의 행정입법청구소송 = Litigation over Claiming Administrative Rule-making

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Today substantive equalizaion by benefit distribution of administration is the important role of a state. In case a person cannot receive benefit owing to the rule-making forbearance of administrative authorities entrusted with benefit distribution through it by legislators, it accords with as well democracy principle because of meeting legislators` intent will as social rule of law and equality one that he must be able to claim it against administrative authorities. Accordingly, litigation over claiming administrative rule-making should be permitted and it is desirable not the Constitutional Court but the Judiciary to have jurisdiction over it, considering our public law litigation system, perspective of comparative law and nature of adminisitrative rule- making. The best form of the litigaion is party litigation in public law claiming confirmation of rule-making obligation against administrative authorities.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 박정훈, "행정입법 부작위에 대한 행정소송 - 독일법과 우리법의 비교, 특히 처분 개념을 중심으로 -, In 판례실무연구 Ⅵ" 박영사 2003

2 김연태, "행정법 Ⅰ(제14판)" 법문사 2010

3 배영길, "행정규칙에 관한 연구 : 비교법적 실증적 분석을 중심으로" 부산대학교 1992

4 박균성, "프랑스에서의 행정입법부작위에 대한 법적 구제, In 판례실무연구 Ⅵ" 박영사 2003

5 "영국법, 사법연수원"

6 Chales E. Freedeman, "양승두 옮김, 프랑스 행정법 서설; 프랑스 국사원의 구조와 기능" 연세대학교 출판부 1981

7 이광윤, "명령과 행정행위에 관한 비교법적 고찰, In 현대행정과 공법이론 : 남하 서원우교수 화갑기념 논문집" 1991

8 이승훈, "공법소송체계와 행정소송의 기능 ― 체계이론과 정치철학적 관점에서 一" 한국공법학회 39 (39): 475-498, 2011

9 안철상, "공법상 당사자소송의 본질과 유형에 관한 일고찰" 29 : 1998

10 Friedhelm Hufen, "Verwaltungsprozeßrecht" C. H. Beck 2003

11 Wolf-Rüdiger Schenke, "Rechtsschutz gegen das Unterlassen von Rechtsnormen" VerwA 1991

12 Thomas Würtenberger, "Die Normerlaßklage als funktionsgerechte Fortbildung verwaltungsprozessualen Rechtsschutzes" 1980

13 Helge Sodan, "Der Anspruch Rechtsetzung und seine prozesssuale Durchsetzbarkeit" 2000

14 Gerhard Robbers, "Anspruch auf Normerlaß - OVG Koblenz" 1998

15 William Wade, "Administrative Law" Oxford 2004

16 Alfred Aman, "Administrative Law" West 1998