변혁적 리더 대 진성 리더 = 변혁적 리더십의 재조명

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In recent years, we are facing with a serious problem of the market-capitalist system caused by immorality and unethical practice of leaders who have led capitalism. This research analyzes the effectiveness of authentic leadership which has emerged recently as one of the most interesting fields in leadership studies. It selects South Korea as the empirical case study. Researchers on authentic leadership have pointed out the limitation of traditional leadership theories which only concentrating on the skill and style of leaders. They also insist that authentic leaders can make a greater contribution to both long-term and short-term performance than any other types of leaders. In this research, we define authentic leadership as ``a very basic, genuine element and a root construct of positive leadership.`` Authentic leaders are sincere to themselves and exhibit behavior positively and transform or develop associates into leaders themselves. An authentic leader mainly shows two kinds of character which are self-awareness and self-regulation. Selfawareness is the starting point of authentic leadership and it means that leaders know mission, visions, identity, emotions, motives, and values of leader themselves and their organizations. And authentic leaders also need to be fully aware of themselves. Self-regulation is a kind of self-control mechanism where authentic leaders try to reduce discrepancies between the actual-self and ideal-self. Self-regulation of authentic leadership helps the leader to endure the external influence and pressure. To verify the effect of authentic leadership, authors compare the effects of transformational leadership on team effectiveness. Although the primary purpose of this study is to test persuasiveness of the authentic leadership theory, we also try to analyze the effect of transformational leadership at the same time as it is well known for its universality in leadership studies. The results show that both leaderships have a positive effect on change-related performance(team performance and teaminnovativeness) and order-related performance (organizational commitment) and have a negative effect on perceived organizational politics. However, if the authentic leadership is controlled, the effect of transformational leadership on order-related performance(organizational commitment and perceived organizational politics) disappears. The effects of authentic leadership on team performance, whereas, team innovativeness, organizational commitment, and perceived organizational politics are all still significant. In conclusion, authors found the possibilities of authentic leadership in Korean firms and argue that various type of leaderships without authenticity could be just skills, gesture, and style of leaders. Even though transformational leadership has a strong effect on changerelated performance, we suggest that it is necessary to distinguish ``pseudo`` transformational leadership from ``authentic`` transformational leadership and their effect on team effectiveness. We also discussed the managerial implications of our claims.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 윤정구, "한국에서 진정성 리더십 연구방향" 2 : 3-26, 2011

2 윤정구, "진정성이란 무엇인가" 한언 2012

3 윤정구, "진성 리더십(Authentic Leadership)" 19-28, 2011

4 송상호, "조직행동론 개인, 팀, 조직" 한경사 323-335, 2007

5 신제구, "조직구성원의 집단주의 성향이성광에미치는영향 : 집단결과기대감과조 직몰입의 매개효과를 중심으로" 23 : 139-155, 1999

6 조윤형, "조직구성원의 가치성향과 갈등상황에 따른 갈등처리방식의 차이에 관한 연구" 한국경영학회 33 (33): 4-4, 2004

7 조윤형, "조직구성원들의 가치성향이 조직시민행동에 미치는 영향 - 조직신뢰의 매개효과 -" 한국인적자원관리학회 17 (17): 403-430, 2010

8 양인덕, "조직공정성과 조직시민행동의 관계에서 개인주의-집단주의 성향의 조절효과" 한국인적자원관리학회 17 (17): 305-324, 2010

9 임준철, "부하에 의해 인지된 상사의 변혁 적 및 거래적 리더십이 부하의 혁 신성향에 미치는 영향 : 자기권능감(Self-Efficacy)의 매개역할을 중심으로" 7 : 1-42, 1999

10 정명호, "변혁적 리더십의 두 얼굴 : 누구를 위한 변혁인가" 103 : 17-19, 2012

11 윤정구, "리더십 이론의 동양적 회귀인가: 진성 리더십에 대하여, In 리더십 에세이 제 29호" 2011

12 윤찬성, "노동조합 지도부의 집단주의 가치관이 파업성향에 미치는 영향에 관한 연구" 한국인사관리학회 32 (32): 23-53, 2008

13 장하준, "그들이 말하지 않는 23가지" 부키 2010

14 Yule, G. U., "Why do we sometimes get nonsense correlations between time series? A study in sampling and the nature of time series" (89) : 1-64, 1926

15 Zhou, J., "When job dissatisfaction leads to creativity : Encouraging the expression of voice" 44 : 682-696, 2001

16 Shamir, B., "What's your story? A life-stories approach to authentic leadership development" 16 : 395-417, 2005

17 Avolio, B. J., "Unlocking the mask : A look at the process by which authentic leaders impact follower attitudes and behaviors" 15 : 801-823, 2004

18 Gardner, W. L., "Unleashing individual potential : Performance gains through positive organizational behavior and authentic leadership" 33 : 270-281, 2004

19 Hinds, P. J., "Understanding conflict in geographically distributed teams : The moderating effects of shared identity, shared context, and spontaneous communication" 16 (16): 290-307, 2005

20 Anderson, T. D., "Transforming leadership: Equipping yourself and coaching others to build the leadership organization (2nd ed.)" St. Lucie Press 1998

21 Shin, S. J., "Transformational leadership, conservation, and creativity : Evidence from Korea" 46 : 703-714, 2003

22 Bass, B. M., "Transformational leadership(2nd ed. )" Lawrence Erlbaum Associates 2006

23 Eisenbach, R., "Transformational leadership in the context of organizational change" 12 : 80-90, 1999

24 Dionne, S., "Transformational leadership and team performance" 17 : 177-193, 2004

25 Mayes, B. T., "Toward a definition of organizational politics" 2 : 672-678, 1977

26 Martin, N. H., "Thinking ahead : Power tactics" 34 : 25-36, 1956

27 Habermas, J., "The theory of communicative action, Volume 2: The critique of functionalist reasoning" Polity 1987

28 Kaplan, R. S., "The strategy focussed organisation" HBS Press 2000

29 Fernando, M., "The spiritual dimension in leadership at Dilmah Tea" 30 (30): 522-539, 2009

30 McLean, B., "The smartest guys in the room : The amazing rise and scandalous fall of Enron" Portfolio 2003

31 Jung, D. I., "The role of transformational leadership in enhancing organizational innovation : Hypotheses and some preliminary findings" 14 : 525-544, 2003

32 Bailey, S. S., "The relationship between leadership styles of high school principals and school climate perceived by teachers" West Virginia University 1988

33 Peterson, S., "The positive impact and development of hopeful leaders" 24 : 26-31, 2003

34 Voronov. M, "The myth of individualism-collectivism : A critical review" 142 : 461-480, 2002

35 Raelin, J., "The myth of charismatic leaders" 57 : 46-54, 2003

36 Shamir, R. J., "The motivational effects of charismatic leadership : A self-concept based theory" 4 : 577-594, 1993

37 Bass, B. M., "The future of leadership in learning organizations" 7 : 18-40, 2000

38 Howell, J. M., "The ethics of charismatic leadership : submission or liberation?" 6 : 43-54, 1992

39 Conger, J. A., "The empowerment process : Integrating theory and practice" 13 : 471-82, 1988

40 Maxwell, J. C., "The difference maker: Making your attitude your greatest asset" Thomas Nelson Business 2006

41 Cobbold, I., "The development of the Balanced Scorecard as a strategic management tool" 2002

42 Khurana, R., "The curse of the superstar CEO" 80 : 60-66, 2002

43 Sankowsky, D., "The charismatic leader as narcissist : Understanding the abuse of power" 23 : 57-71, 1995

44 Simons, T., "Task conflict and relationship conflict in top management teams : The pivotal role of intragroup trust" 85 (85): 102-111, 2000

45 Beyer, J., "Taming and promoting charisma to change organizations" 10 : 307-330, 1999

46 Barbuto, J. E., "Taking the charisma out of transformational leadership" 12 : 689-697, 1997

47 Rohm, H., "Sustaining new directions" 3 : 1-8, 2004

48 Brown, M. E., "Socialized charismatic leadership, values congruence, and deviance in work groups" 91 : 954-962, 2006

49 Spreitzer, G. M., "Social structural characteristics of psychological empowerment" 39 : 483-504, 1996

50 Stajkovic, A. D., "Social cognitive theory and self-efficacy : Going beyond traditional motivational and behavioral approaches" (Spring) : 62-74, 1998

51 Brace, N, "SPSS for psychologists(4th ed.)" Palgrave Macmillan 2009

52 Ferris, G. R., "Reactions of diverse groups to politics in the workplace" 22 : 23-44, 1996

53 Avolio, B. J., "Re-examining the components of transformational and transactional leadership using the Multifactor Leadership Questionnaire" 72 : 441-462, 1999

54 Fu, P. P., "Pursuit of whose happiness? Executive leaders’ transformational behaviors and personal values" 55 : 222-254, 2010

55 Nunnally, J. C., "Psychometric theory(3rd ed.)" McGraw Hill 1994

56 Walumbwa, F., "Psychological processes linking authentic leadership to follower behaviors" 21 : 901-914, 2010

57 Spreitzer, G. M., "Psychological empower ment in the work place : Construct definition, measurement, and validation" 38 : 1442-1465, 1995

58 Barling, J., "Pseudo-transformational leadership : Towards the development and test of a model" 81 : 851-861, 2008

59 White, L. P., "Professional ethics and practice in organizational development: A systematic analysis of issues, alternatives, and approaches" Praeger 1986

60 Price M. E., "Pro-community altruism and social status in a Shuar village" 14 : 191-208, 2003

61 Frost, P. J., "Power, politics, and influence, In Handbook of organizational communication" Sage Publications 503-548, 1987

62 Mintzberg, H., "Power in and around organizations" Prentice Hall 1983

63 Ferris, G. R., "Politics in organizations, In Impression Management in the Organization" Erlbaum 143-170, 1989

64 House, R. J., "Personality and charismatic leadership" 3 : 81-108, 1992

65 Olve N., "Performance drivers: A practical guide to using the Balanced Scorecard" Wiley 1999

66 Kacmar, K. M., "Perceptions of organizational politics scale(POPS) : development and construct validation" 51 : 193-205, 1991

67 Ferris, G. R., "Perceptions of organizational politics" 18 : 93-116, 1992

68 Damanpour, F., "Organizational innovation-A meta analysis of effects of determinants and moderators" 34 : 555-590, 1991

69 O'Reilly, C., "Organizational commitment and psychological attachment : The effects of compliance, identification, and internalization on prosocial behavior" 71 : 492-499, 1986

70 Bartko, J. J., "On various intraclass correlation reliability coefficients" 83 (83): 762-765, 1976

71 Bennis, W., "On becoming a leader" Addison-Wesley 1989

72 De Vries, R., "Need for leadership as a moderator of the relationships between leadership and individual outcomes" 13 : 121-138, 2002

73 Hair, J. F. Jr., "Multivariate Data Analysis. 6th ed" Pearson-Prentice Hall 2006

74 Bass, B. M., "MLQ Multifactor leadership questionnaire" Mind Garden 1995

75 Breit, W., "Lives of the laureates: Eighteen Nobel Economists (4th ed.)" MIT Press 334-336, 2009

76 House, R. J., "Leadership: Some empirical generalizations and new research directions, In Research in organizational behavior" JAI Press 341-423, 1979

77 Parry, K. W., "Leadership, culture and performance : the case of the New Zealand public sector" 4 : 376-99, 2003

78 Northouse, P. G., "Leadership theory and practice(2ne ed.)" Sage Publications Inc 2001

79 Ram, P., "Leadership styles and perceived organizational politics as predictors of work related outcomes" 15 : 40-55, 2010

80 Vigoda-Gadot, E., "Leadership style, organizational politics, and employees' performance : An empirical examination of two competing models" 36 : 661-683, 2007

81 Bryman, A., "Leadership in organizations, In Handbook of organizational studies" Sage 276-292, 1996

82 Yukl, G. A., "Leadership in organizations(5th ed.)" Prentice Hall 2002

83 Yukl, G. A., "Leadership in organizations" Prentice-Hall 1998

84 Bass, B. M., "Leadership and performance" Free Press 1985

85 Burns, J. M., "Leadership" Harper and Row 1978

86 Jöreskog, K. G., "LISREL 8 : Structural equation modeling with the SIMPLIS command language" Scientific Software International INC 1993

87 Patterson, F., "Innovation potential predictor" Oxford Psychologists Press 1999

88 Goncalo, J. A., "Individualismcollectivism and group creativity" 100 : 96-109, 2006

89 Avolio, B. J., "Individual consideration viewed at multiple levels of analysis : A multi-framework for examining the diffusion of transformational leadership" 6 : 188-218, 1995

90 Popper, M., "Hypnotic leadership: Leaders, followers and the loss of self" Praeger 2001

91 McCall, M. W. Jr., "High flyers : Developing the next generation of leaders" Harvard Business School 1998

92 Collins, J., "Good to Great" Harper Collins Publishers 2001

93 Bass, B. M., "Full range leadership development: Manual for the multifactor leadership questionnaire" Mindgarden 1997

94 Avolio, B. J., "Full leadership development: Building the vital forces in organization" Sage Publications 1999

95 Judge, T. A., "Five-factor model of personality and transformational leadership" 85 : 751-765, 2000

96 Pillai, R., "Fairness perceptions and trust as mediators for transformational and transactional leadership : A two-sample study" 25 : 897-933, 1999

97 Pelled, L. H., "Exploring the black box : An analysis of work group diversity, conflict, and performance" 44 : 1-28, 1999

98 Bass, B. M., "Ethics, character, and authentic transformational leadership behavior" 10 : 181-217, 1999

99 Kanungo, R. N., "Ethical dimensions in leadership" Sage 1996

100 Jensen, S., "Entrepreneurs as authentic leaders : impact on employees' attitudes" 27 : 646-666, 2006

101 Jehn, K. A., "Enhancing effectiveness : An investigation of advantages and disadvantages of value based intragroup conflict" 5 : 223-238, 1994

102 Vogt, F. J., "Empowerment in organizations: How to spark exceptional performance" University Associates, Inc 1990

103 Gardner, W. L., "Emotional labour and leadership : A threat to authenticity?" 20 : 466-482, 2009

104 Schaubroeck, J., "Embracing transformational leadership : Team values and the impact of leader behavior on team performance" 92 : 1020-1030, 2007

105 Avolio, B. J., "Eleadership : Implications for theory, research and practice" 11 : 615-668, 2000

106 Lowe, K. B., "Effectiveness correlates of transformational and transactional leadership : A meta-analytic review of the MLQ literature" 7 : 385-425, 1996

107 George, B., "Discovering your authentic leadership" 85 : 129-138, 2007

108 Kirkbride, P., "Developing trans formational leaders : The Full-Range leadership model in action" 38 (38): 23-32, 2006

109 McGregor, D., "Developing thinking; Developing learning" Open University Press 2006

110 Ancona, D. G., "Demography and design : Predictors of new product team performance" 3 (3): 321-341, 1992

111 Amabile, T. M., "Creativity in context. Boulder" Westview 1996

112 Shamir, B., "Correlates of charismatic leader behaviour in military units : Subordinates’ attitudes, unit characteristics, and superiors’appraisals of leader performance" 41 : 387-409, 1998

113 Thomas, K. W., "Cognitive elements of empowerment : An interpretive model of intrinsic motivation" 15 : 666-681, 1990

114 O'Connor, J., "Charismatic leaders and destructiveness : An historiometric study" 6 : 529-555, 1995

115 Conger, J., "Charismatic and transformational leadership in organizations : An insider's perspective on these developing streams of research" 10 : 145-179, 1999

116 Pearl, J., "Causality: Models, reasoning and inference" Cambridge University Press 2000

117 Kaletsky, A., "Capitalism 4. 0 : The birth of a new economy in the aftermath of crisis" Public Affairs 2010

118 Gardner, W. L, Avolio, B., "Can you see the real me?"A self-based model of authentic leader and follower development" 16 : 343-372, 2005

119 Avolio, B. J., "Authentic leadership: Theory-building for veritable sustained performance" Gallup Leadership Institute, University of Nebraska 2004

120 George, W., "Authentic leadership: Rediscovering the secrets to creating lasting Value" Jossey-Bass 2003

121 Luthans, F., "Authentic leadership development, In Positive organizational scholarship" Berrett-Koehler 241-258, 2003

122 Avolio, B. J., "Authentic leadership development : Getting to the root of positive forms of leadership" 16 : 315-338, 2005

123 Yammarino, F., "Authentic leadership and positive organizational behavior : A meso, multi-level perspective" 19 : 693-707, 2008

124 Walumbwa, F., "Authentic leadership : Development and validation of a theory-based measure" 34 : 89-126, 2008

125 Cashman, K., "Authentic leadership" 6 : 1-3, 1997

126 Seligman, M. E. P., "Authentic happiness: Using the new positive psychology to realize your potential for lasting fulfillment" Free Press 2002

127 Yukl, G. A., "An evaluation of conceptual weaknesses in transformational and charismatic leadership theories" 10 : 285-305, 1999

128 Angle, H. L., "An empirical assessment of organizational commitment and organizational effectiveness" 26 : 1-14, 1981

129 Meyer, J. P., "Affective, continuance, and normative commitment to the organization : A meta-analysis of antecedents, correlates, and consequences" 61 : 20-52, 2002

130 Allen, N. J., "Affective, continuance and normative commitment to the organization : An examination of construct validity" 49 : 252-276, 1996

131 Zhu, W., "A theoretical consideration of the effect of transformational leadership on follower and group ethics" 22 : 801-817, 2011

132 Folger, R., "A due process metaphor for performance appraisal, In Research in Organizational Behavior" JAI Press 129-177, 1992

133 Rohm, H., "A balancing act" 2 : 1-8, 2004

134 House, R. J., "A 1976 theory of charismatic leadership, In Leadership: The cutting edge" Carbondale : Southern Illinois University 189-207, 1977

135 "21st century leader"