부동산 공시방법의 역사에 관한 비교법적 고찰 = Comparative Review on History of Publicity of Immovable Property Transfer

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Publicity of legal transactions purporting to transfer interests in immovable property took a primitive form in close-knit communities. At a time when neighbors knew each other, publicity of land conveyances was given by highly ceremonial performances that took place on the land itself. Symbolic acts such as the handing over of a turf or a twig, accompanied by an oral declaration before a group of neighbors, were deemed sufficient safeguards not only to the purchaser or transferee but also to third parties in general. Public recordation of interests in land was not a feature of Roman law, although there is historical evidence pointing to the existence during the pre-Christian era of an incipient system of land recordation developed in Roman provincial territories which were subject to Greek Law. Within the orbit of the Civil Law, a basic comparison may be drawn between the Germanic influenced legal systems on the one land, in which recordation is a requirement to create or constitute a right in rem(hence the label of "constitutive" recordation systems), and French inspired legal systems on the other, in which the act of recordation merely declares the existence of a right that has already been created by the will of the parties (hence the label of "declarative" recordation systems). This distinction is not generally used as a basis of comparison within the orbit of the Common Law, where the differences among recording systems rest by and large on the models provided by the Torrens and post-1925 English recordation systems on the one hand (referred to as "title registration"), and eclectic methods of public recordation coupled with title insurance that prevail in the United States (referred to as "recordation of deeds"), on the other hand.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이은희, "영국의 부동산등기절차" 충북대학교 법학연구소 19 (19): 2008

2 김상용, "부동산 등기제도와 저당제도 발전의 상호관계" 법원사 (3) : 2000

3 박홍래, "미국재산법" 전남대학교 출판부 2004

4 홍봉주, "미국의 부동산 등기제도" 한국토지법학회 25 (25): 31-54, 2009

5 김상용, "미국부동산법률" 삼지원 1986

6 가정준, "미국법상 부동산 소유권 변동과정에 대한 법적 고찰" 한국민사법학회 (31) : 139-175, 2006

7 서을오, "물권행위론에 관한 학설사적 연구" 세창출판사 2008

8 김증한, "물권법 제9판" 박영사 1997

9 곽윤직, "물권법 제7판" 박영사 2002

10 현승종, "로마법Ⅰ" 박영사 1996

11 박수곤, "物權行爲 槪念에 대한 小考 － 프랑스법적 시각에서의 검토 －" 한국민사법학회 43 (43): 171-200, 2008

12 McCormack, John L., "Torrens and Recording: Land Title Assurance in the Computer Age" 18 : 1992

13 Taubenshlang, "The Law of Greco-Roman Egypt in the Light of the Papyri 332 B.C.- 640 A.D" 1944

14 "Real Proterty Commision, Second Report" 1830

15 Szypszak, Charles, "Public Registration and Private Solution: An Evolving American Real Estate Conveyance Regime" 24 : 2003

16 Bostick, C. Dent, "Land Title Registration: An English Solution to an Americ an Problem" 63 : 1988

17 Maitland, "English Law and Renaissance" Camgrige 1901