Pareto－Improving Tax Harmonization in Indirect Taxes：A Survey

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

With the growing integration of markets for goods and capital within the EC and thereby making the tax base both mobile and highly elastic, the harmonization of indirect taxation (VAT and excise taxes) has become a central issue in the discussion of tax policy in the EC. From the tax reform point of view, it is practical to present recommendations for ‘directions’ of small and implementable tax changes that provide strict welfare gains for one (potential Pareto improvement) or all (actual Pareto improvement) countries.
In this survey, we attempt to survey Pareto－improving tax harmonization in the EC perspective. We define tax harmonization by the ‘movement of initially divergent domestic tax rates across countries towards a common or average tax rate which is harmonized by agreements between countries so as to remove trade distortion induced by tax differentials and to share collective gain’. Given that distortions arising from tax differentials exist in each country and starting from initial non－harmonized tax rates between countries, can a movement towards the average common tax rate proposed by EC Commission achieve Pareto improving? According to the relevant literature, a move towards a weighted average of pre－existing different commodity taxes may generate a potential Pareto improvement.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Keen, Michael, "Welfare Effects of Commodity Tax harmonization" 33 : 107-114, 1987

2 Hatta, T., "Welfare Effects of Changing Commodity Tax Rates toward Uniformity" 29 : 99-112, 1986

3 Whalley, J., "Uniform Domestic Tax Rates, Trade Distortions and Economic Integration" 11 : 213-221, 1979

4 Abe, K., "The Welfare Effects of International Tax Harmonization" 40 (40): 203-221, 1989

5 Keen, Michael, "The Welfare Economics of Tax Coordination in the EC：A Survey" 14 : 15-36, 1993

6 Lopez－Garcia, M., "The Origin Principle and the Welfare Gains from Indirect Tax Harmonization" 3 : 83-93, 1996

7 Cnossen, S., "The Case for Tax Diversity in the European Community" 34 : 471-479, 1990

8 Lucas, Vander, "Tax harmonization and the Origin Principle" 71 : 111-115, 2001

9 Sinn, H－W, "Tax harmonization and Tax Competition in Europe" 34 : 489-504, 1990

10 Kopits. G., "Tax Harmonization in the European Community：Policy Issue and Analysis, Occasional Paper 94, IMF"

11 Haufler, A., "Tax Coordination with Different Preferences for Public Goods：Conflict or Harmony of Interest?" 3 : 5-28, 1996

12 Cnossen, S., "Tax Coordination in the European Community" Kluwer 1987

13 Smith, S., "Subsidiarity and the Coordination of Indirect Taxes in the EC" 9 : 67-94, 1992

14 Fernandez, R., "Resistance to Reform：Status Quo Bias in the Presence of Individual－Specific Uncertainty" 84 : 1146-1155, 1991

15 Lahiri, S., "Public Good Provision and the Welfare Effects of Indirect Tax Harmonization" 67 : 253-267, 1998

16 Keen, Michael, "Pareto－Improving Indirect Tax harmonization" 33 : 1-12, 1989

17 Rose,M, "Optimal Tax Perspective on Tax Coordination ; Tax Coordination in the European Community" Kluwer 1987

18 Lopez－Garcia, M., "On Welfare and Revenue Effects of Indirect Tax Harmonization" 60 : 185-193, 1998

19 Turunen－Red, A.H., "Multilateral Reforms of Domestic Taxes" 42 : 160-186, 1990

20 Lee, C., "M. Pearson and S. Smith, "Fiscal harmonization：An Analysis of the Commission's Proposal , IFS Report Series 28"

21 Kanbur, R., "Jeux Sans Frontieres：Tax Competition and Tax Coordination When Countries Differ in Size" 83 : 877-892, 1993

22 Frenkel, J. A., "International Taxation in an Integrated World" MIT Press 1991

23 Razin, A., "International Tax Competition and Gains from Tax harmonization" 37 : 69-76, 1991

24 Berglas, E., "Harmonization of Commodity Taxes" 16 : 377-387, 1981

25 Perraudin, W.R.M., "European Fiscal Harmonization and the French Economy" 38 (38): 399-440, 1991

26 Delipalla, S., "Commodity Tax harmonization and Public Goods" 63 : 447-466, 1997

27 Lockwood, B., "Can International Commodity Tax harmonization be Pareto－Improving When Governments Supply Public Goods?" 43 : 387-408, 1997

28 Gordon, R.H., "An Optimal Taxation Approach to Fiscal Federalism" 98 (98): 567-586, 1983