자연의 권리 = Nature`s Rights

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Christopher D. Stone teaches law at University of Southern California in Los Angeles. The publication of Should Trees Have Standing? in 1972 was an important influence on the development of the field of environmental ethics. Stone is author of Earth and Other Ethics. Stone proposes giving legal rights to natural objects. While such an extension of rights may seem unthinkable, he points out that such extensions have always seemed unthinkable before they occurred, and that there are currently a number of inanimate legal persons, such as railroads and corporations. Stone summarizes what it means for something to have legal standing and how natural objects currently do not possess legal standing. He proposes an extension of the legal guardianship model for legal incompetents, and explains some of the advantages of such a strategy. Can an animal or a plant raise a lawsuit to a court? Environmental law is the regulation that was established in order to protect the public interest, that is the profit of mankind, the Earth, an ecosystem, etc. However, the current lawsuit system is the system that was prepared in order to protect personal profit. Therefore, I think that an existing lawsuit system cannot contribute to the realization for the purpose that environmental law aims at. So I insist that an existing lawsuit system should be revised in order to realize the purpose of an environmental law effectively. This paper is composed as follows. 1. Introduction 2. Historical Development of the Theory of Nature`s Rights 3. Case Study on Nature`s Right Litigation in Several States 4. The Possibility of Nature`s Right Litigation 5. Conclusion

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이상돈, "환경정책기본법" 아세아문화사 1985

2 홍성방, "환경보호의 법적 문제" 서강대학교 출판부 1999

3 강재규, "자연을 위한 환경법인가"

4 강재규, "자연보호소송"

5 강재규, "자연과 인간의 공생을 위한 환경사상" 지산 2001

6 강재규, "생태주의 환경법" 세종출판사 2002

7 허범, "법정에 선 나무들" 아르케 2003

8 강재규, "미국환경법과 법원" 세종출판사 1998

9 천병태, "미국행정법" 부산대학교출판부 1992

10 알도 레오폴드, "모래땅의 사계" 도서출판 푸른 숲 1999

11 森島明譯, "野生のうたが聞こえる" 森林書房

12 志村富壽, "運命の風景-日光があぶない" 日本經濟評論社 1983

13 鬼頭秀一, "自然保護を問いなおす" ちくま新書 1996

14 ?山武道, "自然保護の訴訟"

15 ?山武道, "環境行政判例の總合的硏究"

16 芝池義一, "環境法의 性格" 한국지방자치연구소 1 (1): 1991

17 山村恒年, "環境法入門" 昭和堂 44-, 1999

18 山村恒年, "環境保護の法と政策" 信山社 1996

19 關根孝道, "日米“種の保存法”の比較法的考察"

20 山田隆夫, "奄美自然の權利訴訟の提起するもの" 49 (49): 1998

21 阿部泰隆, "國土開發と環境保全" 日本評論社 1989

22 山村恒年, "公害ㆍ環境判例百選" 有斐閣 1994

23 硏究會, "公害ㆍ環境判例の軌跡と展望"

24 北村喜宣, "公害ㆍ環境の行政判例-戰後の步みと展望"

25 芝池義一, "公共事業と行政訴訟 - 處分性と原告適格"

26 岡島成行, "アメリカの自然保護運動"

27 籠橋隆明, "“自然の權利” 訴訟と市民の權利"

28 Cass R. Sunstein, "What’s Standing After Lujan? of Citizen Suits, “Injuries,” and Article Ⅲ, 91 Mich. L. Rev."

29 R. F. Nash, "The Rights of Nature : A History of Environmental Ethics"

30 Roderick F. Nash, "The Rights of Nature" The University of Wisconsin Press 1989

31 Carolyn Merchant, "Radical Ecology : The Search for a Livable World" 이후 2001

32 John Passmore, "Man’s Responsibility for Nature"

33 John Passmore, "Man’s Responsibility for Nature"

34 Harold J. Krent, "Ethan G. Shenkman, Of Citizen Suits Sunstein, 91 Michi. L. Rev. 1773, 1793-1823"

35 J. R. DesJardins, "Environmental Ethics : An Introduction to Environmental Philosophy" 자작나무 1999

36 . S. Shrader-Frechette, "Environmental Ethics" The Boxwood Press 1991

37 Zygmunt J. B. Plater, "Enviromental Law and Policy : a Coursebook on Nature, Law, and Society"

38 홍준형, "'자연의 권리’ 소송은 가능한가?"