정당한 보상을 위한 개발이익 배제에 관한 비판적 고찰

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The Constitution guarantees property rights of the people in Article 23. And while allowing the right to accept property according to the public s needs, compensation for it should be made by law, but only fair compensation should be made. It is natural that acceptance of property rights under the pretext of public necessity should give
legitimate compensation for the deprivation of property rights, as it is not voluntary with the landowners.
It is natural that acceptance of property rights under the pretext of public necessity should give legitimate compensation for the deprivation of property rights, as it is not voluntary with the landowners. For this purpose, the law stipulates the principle of compensation in calculating the compensation amount, and one of its principles is the
principle of excluding development benefits. In addition, the law has several provisions to exclude the benefits of development.
In addition, in the case of case precedent and academic circles, the development benefits created by the increase in the value of land due to the implementation of public projects are those of the characteristics that should ultimately be attributable to all people. Under these logic to exclude the benefit from development from the public interest, development benefits, including the amount of land price increase, can not be compensated from fair compensation, and are infringing upon the compensation made by the landowners. This phenomenon is likely to be unconstitutional about the fair compensation prescribed in the Constitution, and it poses a number of problems. While the
principle of excluding the development benefits from compensation for loss is maintained in theory and precedent, is it legitimate compensation to exclude the benefits from development based on the principle of fair compensation under the Constitution?

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김철수, "헌법학신론" 박영사 687-690, 2014

2 성낙인, "헌법학" 법문사 685-686, 2014

3 선병채, "토지보상평가에 있어 개발이익 배제" 139-, 2008

4 류해웅, "토지보상에 있어서 개발이익 배제에 관한 법제적 고찰" 한국부동산연구원 17 (17): 115-136, 2007

5 김영조, "토지보상액산정에 있어서 개발이익배제의 원칙에 관한 검토" 9 : 243-,

6 류하백, "정당보상에 있어 개발이익배제논리의 위헌성에 관한 고찰" 한국부동산연구원 18 (18): 125-152, 2008

7 김승종, "영국의 개발이익 환수제도에 관한 연구"

8 김유향, "기본강의 헌법" (주) 월비스 649-, 2018

9 전극수, "공익사업에서의 영업손실보상에 관한 연구" 한국토지공법학회 81 : 23-43, 2018

10 박평준, "공용수용에 대한 손실보상" 51-, 2004

11 박성규, "공용수용(公用收用)의 정당보상에 관한 연구" 한국전문경영인학회 10 (10): 107-127, 2007

12 임윤수, "개발이익환수제도에 관한 연구" 한국법학회 (21) : 1-20, 2006

13 조병구, "개발이익 배제 원칙에 대한 소고" 한국법경제학회 9 (9): 193-222, 2012

14 小高 剛, "用地買收と補償" 有斐閣 99-, 2003

15 Wyman, Miriam Katrina, "The Measure of Just Compensation" 41 : 239-287, 2007

16 Macpherson, "The Life and Times of Liberal Dmocracy" Oxford University, press 9-10, 1977

17 Julian Conrad Juergensmeyer, "Land Use Planning and Control Law" West Group 64-, 1988