모욕죄의 위헌성과 친고죄 조항의 폐지에 대한 정책적 고찰 = The Unconstitutionality of Insult Laws and Cyber-Insult Laws

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In 2008, the Korean government and the ruling party proposed a bill to enhance the crime of insult in two ways: (1) enhance the punishment to up to 2 years of imprisonment and (2) eliminate the requirement that the victim file an accusation thereby allow the police and prosecutor to prosecute insulting comments even if the supposed victim does not come forward first. In this article, the author argues that the existing criminal law of insult is unconstitutional and falls miserably off the international human rights standards, and that any attempt to enhance it should therefore be aborted. Insult is punishment on expression of one`s opinions and feelings on account of an insulting feeling that it causes on others. However, opinions and feelings are valuable part of speech which should be constitutionally protected. Narrowing the scope of insult to `bad language` does not relieve its unconstitutionality because it is not the text of the expression that causes the stress on the hearer but the context in which the expression was made. Major elements of this context are the relative social status of the speaker and hearer, and the hearer`s sense of self-worth, which in no way can be a constitutionally acceptable basis for punishing the speaker who does not have any control over those elements. The author notices that general insult law exists only in Germany, Japan, Korea, and Taiwan and the insult-against-the-head-of-state laws are retained only by authoritarian regimes who are continuously pressured by international bodies to abolish them. The author proposes instead adoption of hate crime laws, which most developed countries adopted instead of enhancing the already unconstitutional law of insult.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 R. v. Zundel, 2 : 731-, 1992

2 박경신, "사진으로 보는 저작권 초상권 상표권 기타등등"

3 양동철, "사이버폭력에 대한 입법방향 연구" 법조협회 55 (55): 134-173, 2006

4 박대령, "사이버모욕죄에 대한 심리학적 접근" (37) : 2009

5 김정진, "사이버모욕죄, 입법의 의도가 의심된다" 2009

6 박혜진, "사이버모욕죄 도입에 대한 비판적 검토" 안암법학회 (28) : 315-348, 2009

7 금태섭, "사이버 모욕죄의 법리상 문제점" 2009

8 "사이버 모욕죄 관련조사"

9 "문재완 2008년 11월 13일 법무부 법조언론인클럽 토론회 발표문"

10 박경신, "명예훼손 형사처벌 폐지해야"

11 조수진, "국회 내 사이버 모욕죄 도입 논의에 대한 비판적 검토" 2009

12 Marilyn J. Greene, "It's A Crime: How Insult Laws Stifle Press Freedom"

13 James H. Ottaway, Jr, "Insult Laws: An Insult to Freedom"

14 James Q. Whitman, "Enforcing Civility and Respect: Three Societies" 109 : 1279-, 2002

15 "Defamation and ‘Insult’ : Writers React, A report from International PEN’s Writers in Prison Committee: Insult Laws in the European Union"