정암 이현익의 사단칠정론 = Yi Hyun-Ik`s Theory of Four Beginnings and Seven Feelings

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This research focuses on the theory of Four Beginnings and Seven Feelings performed by Yi Hyun-Ik. Yi belonged to Rakhak(洛學) in Yulgok school in the Joseon Dynasty in the 18th century. Yi``s view on this issue can be recapitulated as two claims: (i) Yulgok was entirely right as regards to the relations between Four Beginnings and Seven Fellings, and (ii) nevertheless, Toegye``s view on this issue, if examined closely to understand what it was originally meant, is not incompatible with Yulgok``s theory. This reveals the basic attitudes of Yi``s philosophy, which compromises the two great philosophers`` views. At the same time, Yi provides criticisms on their views. He attempted to reach comprehensive understanding of the Theory of Four Beginnings and Seven Feelings, while pointing out the problems one may face taking Toegye or Yulgok``s view tendentiously. In sum, Yi``s view on Four Beginnings and Seven Feelings is the result of accommodating both Toegye``s and Yulgok``s philosophies, and, at the same time, of critically examining their views. The historical significance of Yi``s view lies in the fact that it clarifies the complex issues raised by the theory of Four Beginnings and Seven Feelings within his own line of thinking, as opposed to merely following previous discourses.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 문석윤, "호락논쟁 형성과 전개" 동과서 2006

2 전재동, "정암正菴 이현익李顯益의 『논어論語』 해석 연구 ― 자료 소개와 ｢논어설論語說｣ 분석을 중심으로" 한국국학진흥원 (18) : 329-361, 2011

3 문석윤, "농암農巖 김창협金昌協의 사단칠정설四端七情說에 대하여― ｢사단칠정설四端七情說｣을 중심으로" 한국국학진흥원 (23) : 149-186, 2013

4 "退溪集" 민족문화추진회

5 "農巖集" 민족문화추진회

6 이상익, "農巖 金昌協 學脈의 退栗折衷論과 그 의의" (사)율곡학회 23 : 125-166, 2011

7 "正菴集" 민족문화추진회

8 "栗谷全書" 민족문화추진회

9 김태년, "17~18세기 율곡학파의 사단칠정론" 한국동양철학회 (28) : 31-63, 2007