The Combined Effects of Alcohol Consumption and Smoking on Cancer Risk by Exposure Level: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Background: Alcohol consumption is a major risk factor for cancer, and when combined with smoking, the risk increases. Nevertheless, few studies have comprehensively evaluated the combined effects of alcohol consumption and smoking on the risk of various cancer types.
Therefore, to assess these effects, we conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis.
Methods: We performed a systematic search of five literature databases, focusing on cohort and case-control studies. Considering exposure levels, we quantified the combined effects of alcohol consumption and smoking on cancer risk and assessed multiplicative interaction effects.
Results: Of 4,452 studies identified, 24 (4 cohort studies and 20 case-control studies) were included in the meta-analysis. We detected interaction effect of light alcohol and moderate smoking on head and neck cancer risk (relative risk [RR], 4.26; 95% confidence interval [CI], 2.50–7.26; I 2 = 65%). A synergistic interaction was observed in heavy alcohol and heavy smoking group (RR, 35.24; 95% CI, 23.17–53.58; I 2 = 69%). In more detailed cancer types, the interaction effect of heavy alcohol and heavy smoking was noticeable on oral (RR, 36.42; 95% CI, 24.62–53.87; I 2 = 46%) and laryngeal (RR, 38.75; 95% CI, 19.25–78.01; I 2 = 69%) cancer risk.
Conclusion: Our study provided a comprehensive summary of the combined effects of alcohol consumption and smoking on cancers. As their consumption increased, the synergy effect became more pronounced, and the synergy effect was evident especially for head and neck cancer. These findings provide additional evidence for the combined effect of alcohol and smoking in alcohol guidelines for cancer prevention.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 International Agency for Research on Cancer, "World Cancer Report 2014" International Agency for Research on Cancer 2014

2 Taylor B, "When risk factors combine : the interaction between alcohol and smoking for aerodigestive cancer, coronary heart disease, and traffic and fire injury" 31 (31): 1522-1535, 2006

3 Government of Canada, "Tobacco use statistics, terminology"

4 Kuper H, "Tobacco smoking, alcohol consumption and their interaction in the causation of hepatocellular carcinoma" 85 (85): 498-502, 2000

5 Talamini R, "Tobacco smoking, alcohol consumption and pancreatic cancer risk : a case-control study in Italy" 46 (46): 370-376, 2010

6 IARC Working Group on the Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risks to Humans, "Tobacco smoking" 38 : 1-395, 1986

7 Hayes RB, "Tobacco and alcohol use and oral cancer in Puerto Rico" 10 (10): 27-33, 1999

8 Sewram V, "Tobacco and alcohol as risk factors for oesophageal cancer in a high incidence area in South Africa" 41 : 113-121, 2016

9 Prabhu A, "The synergistic effects of alcohol and tobacco consumption on the risk of esophageal squamous cell carcinoma : a meta-analysis" 109 (109): 822-827, 2014

10 Mello FW, "The synergistic effect of tobacco and alcohol consumption on oral squamous cell carcinoma : a systematic review and meta-analysis" 23 (23): 2849-2859, 2019

11 Castellsagué X, "The role of type of tobacco and type of alcoholic beverage in oral carcinogenesis" 108 (108): 741-749, 2004

12 Saracci R, "The interactions of tobacco smoking and other agents in cancer etiology" 9 (9): 175-193, 1987

13 GBD 2019 Cancer Risk Factors Collaborators, "The global burden of cancer attributable to risk factors, 2010-19 : a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2019" 400 (400): 563-591, 2022

14 De Stefani E, "The effect of smoking and drinking in oral and pharyngeal cancers : a case-control study in Uruguay" 246 (246): 282-289, 2007

15 Pustejovsky JE, "Testing for funnel plot asymmetry of standardized mean differences" 10 (10): 57-71, 2019

16 Kim SY, "Testing a tool for assessing the risk of bias for nonrandomized studies showed moderate reliability and promising validity" 66 (66): 408-414, 2013

17 Zambon P, "Smoking, type of alcoholic beverage and squamous-cell oesophageal cancer in northern Italy" 86 (86): 144-149, 2000

18 Lissowska J, "Smoking, alcohol, diet, dentition and sexual practices in the epidemiology of oral cancer in Poland" 12 (12): 25-33, 2003

19 Sung NY, "Smoking, alcohol and gastric cancer risk in Korean men : the National Health Insurance Corporation Study" 97 (97): 700-704, 2007

20 Wu M, "Smoking and alcohol drinking increased the risk of esophageal cancer among Chinese men but not women in a high-risk population" 22 (22): 649-657, 2011

21 Andre K, "Role of alcohol and tobacco in the aetiology of head and neck cancer : a case-control study in the Doubs region of France" 31B (31B): 301-309, 1995

22 Oze I, "Revisit of an unanswered question by pooled analysis of eight cohort studies in Japan : does cigarette smoking and alcohol drinking have interaction for the risk of esophageal cancer?" 8 (8): 6414-6425, 2019

23 Zang EA, "Reevaluation of the confounding effect of cigarette smoking on the relationship between alcohol use and lung cancer risk, with larynx cancer used as a positive control" 32 (32): 359-370, 2001

24 Sterne JA, "Recommendations for examining and interpreting funnel plot asymmetry in meta-analyses of randomised controlled trials" 343 : d4002-, 2011

25 Wight AJ, "Possible mechanisms by which alcohol may influence the development of oral cancer--a review" 34 (34): 441-447, 1998

26 Partanen TJ, "Pancreas cancer, tobacco smoking and consumption of alcoholic beverages : a case-control study" 116 (116): 27-32, 1997

27 Geissbühler M, "Most published meta-regression analyses based on aggregate data suffer from methodological pitfalls : a meta-epidemiological study" 21 (21): 123-, 2021

28 최윤정 ; 명승권 ; 이지호, "Light alcohol drinking and risk of cancer : a meta-analysis of cohort studies" 50 (50): 474-487, 2018

29 Yaegashi Y, "Joint effects of smoking and alcohol drinking on esophageal cancer mortality in Japanese men : findings from the Japan collaborative cohort study" 15 (15): 1023-1029, 2014

30 Flanders WD, "Interaction of alcohol and tobacco in laryngeal cancer" 115 (115): 371-379, 1982

31 Hashibe M, "Interaction between tobacco and alcohol use and the risk of head and neck cancer : pooled analysis in the International Head and Neck Cancer Epidemiology Consortium" 18 (18): 541-550, 2009

32 Ardies CM, "Induction of 4-(methylnitrosamino)-1-(3-pyridyl)-1-butanone(NNK)activation in rat lung microsomes by chronic ethanol consumption and repeated running exercise" 103 (103): 209-218, 1996

33 Husten CG, "How should we define light or intermittent smoking? Does it matter?" 11 (11): 111-121, 2009

34 Rumgay H, "Global burden of cancer in 2020 attributable to alcohol consumption : a population-based study" 22 (22): 1071-1080, 2021

35 GBD 2019 Risk Factors Collaborators, "Global burden of 87 risk factors in 204 countries and territories, 1990-2019 : a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2019" 396 (396): 1223-1249, 2020

36 Squier CA, "Enhanced penetration of nitrosonornicotine across oral mucosa in the presence of ethanol" 15 (15): 276-279, 1986

37 Zeka A, "Effects of alcohol and tobacco on aerodigestive cancer risks : a meta-regression analysis" 14 (14): 897-906, 2003

38 Falk RT, "Effect of smoking and alcohol consumption on laryngeal cancer risk in coastal Texas" 49 (49): 4024-4029, 1989

39 Olsen J, "Effect of combined alcohol and tobacco exposure on risk of cancer of the hypopharynx" 39 (39): 304-307, 1985

40 Hashibe M, "Contribution of tobacco and alcohol to the high rates of squamous cell carcinoma of the supraglottis and glottis in Central Europe" 165 (165): 814-820, 2007

41 Franceschi S, "Comparison of the effect of smoking and alcohol drinking between oral and pharyngeal cancer" 83 (83): 1-4, 1999

42 Motschman CA, "Combined smoking and alcohol cues : effects on craving, drug-seeking, and consumption" 45 (45): 1864-1876, 2021

43 Talamini R, "Combined effect of tobacco and alcohol on laryngeal cancer risk : a case-control study" 13 (13): 957-964, 2002

44 Higgins JP, "Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions. Version 5.1.0"

45 Deeks JJ, "Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions. Version 6.4 (Updated August 2023)" Cochrane 2023

46 Tsong WH, "Cigarettes and alcohol in relation to colorectal cancer : the Singapore Chinese Health Study" 96 (96): 821-827, 2007

47 Garnett C, "Characterising smoking and smoking cessation attempts by risk of alcohol dependence : a representative, cross-sectional study of adults in England between 2014-2021" 18 : 100418-, 2022

48 Bundgaard T, "Case-control study of squamous cell cancer of the oral cavity in Denmark" 6 (6): 57-67, 1995

49 Pelucchi C, "Cancer risk associated with alcohol and tobacco use : focus on upper aero-digestive tract and liver" 29 (29): 193-198, 2006

50 Union for International Cancer Control, "Cancer and alcohol"

51 Cooke A, "Beyond PICO : the SPIDER tool for qualitative evidence synthesis" 22 (22): 1435-1443, 2012

52 IARC Working Group on the Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risks to Humans, "Alcohol drinking" 44 : 1-378, 1988

53 Maasland DH, "Alcohol consumption, cigarette smoking and the risk of subtypes of head-neck cancer : results from the Netherlands Cohort Study" 14 (14): 187-, 2014

54 Patra J, "Alcohol consumption and the risk of morbidity and mortality for different stroke types--a systematic review and meta-analysis" 10 (10): 258-, 2010

55 Bagnardi V, "Alcohol consumption and site-specific cancer risk : a comprehensive dose-response meta-analysis" 112 (112): 580-593, 2015

56 IARC Working Group on the Evaluation of Carcinogenic Risks to Humans, "Alcohol consumption and ethyl carbamate" 96 : 3-1383, 2010

57 City of Hope Cancer Treatment Centers, "Alcohol and cancer risk"

58 Winstanley MH, "Alcohol and cancer : a position statement from Cancer Council Australia" 194 (194): 479-482, 2011

59 World Health Organization(WHO), "Alcohol and Cancer in the WHO European Region : An Appeal for Better Prevention" WHO 2020

60 VanderWeele TJ, "A tutorial on interaction" 3 (3): 33-72, 2014

61 Guénel P, "A study of the interaction of alcohol drinking and tobacco smoking among French cases of laryngeal cancer" 42 (42): 350-354, 1988

62 Duval S, "A nonparametric"trim and fill"method of accounting for publication bias in meta-analysis" 95 : 89-98, 2000

63 Korea Disease Control and Prevention Agency, "2022 KDCA report on harmful effects of tobacco: an overview of tobacco use and its effects on health"

64 National Cancer Center, "10 Action codes of cancer prevention"