The purpose of this study is to seek for a posibility of establishing a Buddhistic psychology and a Buddhistic psychotherapy as a clinical socialwork practice by comparing the transpersonal psychology and Yogacara Buddhism, which is a psychological sy...
The purpose of this study is to seek for a posibility of establishing a Buddhistic psychology and a Buddhistic psychotherapy as a clinical socialwork practice by comparing the transpersonal psychology and Yogacara Buddhism, which is a psychological system of human mind. For the purpose, the transprsonal psychology will be reviewed at the angle of the structure of consciousness, the stages of growth and the method of growth.. Transpersonal psychology accepts and includes the wisdom of eastern religion and psychological factors of the eastern religion into the area of psychology. It takes each of the existing psychologies and eastern religion like Buddhism as a partial truth which focuses on own specific aspect of wide demension of human nature and it thinks they can be synthesized under a spectrum of consciousness. Yogacara Buddhism was reviewed by the structure of consciousness, stages of growth, and method of ascetic prctices. Finally transpersonal psychology and Yogacara Buddhism are cpmpared and evaluated to achieve the purpose of this study.
Transeprsonal psychology and Yogacara point out the same ultimate state and ultimate reality, which is non-dual mind. Wilber wrote that only the non-dual mind (Mind) is reality and it is timeless and limitless. The phenomina created by the dualistic process is illusory and not real. The Mind could be reached by non-dual mode of knowing and the ultimate state is not reasoned out by speculation but from experience. And the Mind can be proved by experience. Yogacara is established on the given premisis of dual world, subject and object, caused by dualism, which is egnorance on the truth. The ultiamte state of Yogacara is Nirvana and wisdom, which is non-dual world of reality. The consciousness and vijnapti are the same concept and the non-dual mode of knowing can be taken as a similar thing as transforamtion from vijnapti to wisdom.
The process of evolution of consciousness in Wilber's theory is explained simply and clearly by dualism-resprssion-projection and it focuses on the psychological aspects, which is the narrowing process of self consciousness. Yogacara explains the development of vijnanas by two principles, one is hetuparinama which is the genesis of vijnanas from the 8th vijinana and the other is phalaparinama which is the seperation of seer and seen in each of 8 vijnanas. In this process, Yogacara includes the genesis of the physical world from the eighth vijnana.
The spectrum of consciousness consisits of vertical and linear levels of consciousness and a man may be on all the levels but mostly on a certain narrow part of the spectrum. The the vijnanas of Yogacara are less vertical and rather horizental, though there is the diference in the degree of depth. The vijnanas in Yogacara are rather circular than linear, the five perceptions (from the first to fifth vijnanas), the 6th vijnana, the 7th vijnana and the 8 vijnana arises spontaneously and interacts by the consciousness-in-activity's (pravrtti vijnana) leaving impression and menifestation of seeds.
The principles of growth in Wilbers' theory are explained by deep structures and surface structures, differentiation and identification, and translation and transforamtion. The transforamtion from a lower structure to a higher structure will take place when the translation in the surface structure doesn't work anymore. Then one will differentiate himself from the lower structure and identify himself to the higher structure. This is transcendence and is development. In all the stages of growth, from the womb to the ultimate state where no further needs to grow exist, this process takes places repeatedly.
Yogacara explains the growth by the terms of vija(seed), leaving impression and transformation of the basis of existence (asraya-paravrtti). Vija is a limiting principle of a man's whole life because a man's life is defined by vija. In this point of view, vija can be interpreted as deep structure. Differentiation and identification seems to have same analogic meaning as resolution(pranidhana). But resolution and vija are not set for the principles of each level of growth but used for a whole life. Translation is equivalent as leaving impression and transformation is as transforamtion of basis. Leaving impression is a gradual accumulation of impression, which eventually can change the habit and attitude but gradually. Transforamtion of basis is a step change of basis of existence, which transcend from lower level to higher level and is very similar as transformation in Wilber's theory. In this way, the principles of change and growth are basically the same in Wilber's theory and Yogacara but with some difference in details.
Transpersonal psychotherapy aims at the further growth from the noraml personality to the ultimate state by transcendence but still pay attention on the daily problems of adaptation. The principles of psychotherapy set the induction and experience of condensed psychic energy and disidentification - transcending to the ultimate state as the basic process of treatment and growth. Transpersonal psychotherapy takes the principles of transpersonal psychology as a context of the therapy and put efforts to verify the principles by scientific methodology.
Yogacara focuses on the ascetic practices and doesn't pay much attention on the person in everyday life. It is looking at how to remove the root of all the sufferings and resolve the suffering fundamentally but not to adapt to the daily life. This makes it difficult for general application to the common life, even though it has deeper and wider understanding on human nature and offers well proved and detailed solutions by the exepriences of the followers in the long history.
Buddhism including Yogacara is becoming a source of the wisdom to breakthrough the limitation of mechanistic world view and develop holistic view of the world. Buddhism is being recognized as an abundant source of psychology and psychotherapy. It also is considered as a system of psychotherapy.
Transpersonal psychology made an important moment of connecting the psychology and Buddhism including Yogacara by setting its ground with the Buddhistic core principles like the nondual Mind as the reality of the world, ignorance as the initial cause of the dualism, menifested phenomina by the dualism is illusory world and consciousness as the tool to see the world like vijnapti.
Enlightening all the living being which is altruistic point of view of salvation and is one of major two ascetic practices of Yogacara Buddhism indicates an important point to the transpersonal psychotherapy. It is an altruistic principle which takes all living things as himself with compassion and lead them to the truth. As far as transpersonal psychology is heading for the non-dual Mind, there must be a therapy to cope with the seperation between subject and object, or Me and others and that is the practice of enlightening all the living being.
To bring the benefit of Buddhism to the modern everyday life, the Buddhistic psychology and psychotherapy should be established by the methodology of modern science. To do this, the psychological factors of Yogacara are needed to be defined and classified first from the abundant resources of Buddhism. And then define basic concepts and develop verifiable theories as a science. It doesn't mean that Yogacara is not enough as a system of theory or thought but it contains so deep understanding on human nature and covers wide range of aspects of human being. But to make wider use of this valuable heritage for the welfare of human being in the area of psychology and psychotherapy, it is required to approach through the scientific methods.