Comparisons of fabric care performances between conventional and high‑efficiency washers and dryers

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

High-efficiency (HE) washers use 35–50% less water and about 50% less energy per load than conventional washers. However, there has been a consistent debate as to whether HE washers perform better or worse in garment care than conventional washers. Consumers need research-based information that would help them make informed decisions concerning the purchase of a clothes washer. The purpose of this study was to compare fabric hand, appearance retention (strain removal, color change, and fabric smoothness), and dimension stability (dimensional change and skewness change) after the specimens were repeatedly washed and dried for up to 20 cycles in three combinations of washer and dryer used: (a) conventional washer and dryer, (b) HE washer and conventional dryer, and (c) HE washer and dryer. The results showed that the specimens washed in the HE washer had better fabric hand and were smoother (fewer wrinkles) than those washed in the conventional washer. Conventional and HE washers performed similarly in color change, dimensional change, and skewness change. In regard to dryer, all results except those for stain removal showed no significant differences between the specimens dried in the conventional dryer and those dried in the HE dryer. In stain removal, when a softener was not used, the conventional dryer removed more stains from the specimens than the HE dryer. However, when a softener was used, the stains on the specimens dried in the conventional dryer were more difficult to remove than those on the specimens dried in the HE dryer.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Consumer Reports, "Washers get pricier, but there are still relative bargains"

2 Morris, M, "The history of the clothes dryer" Hunker 2017

3 Wroclawski, D, "The great washer debate: Are front-loaders really better? USA Today"

4 Simpson, B. G, "The effect of silicone softeners on resin treated cottons" 28 (28): 170-179, 1958

5 Wilson, P, "The effect of repeated use of fabric softeners on absorbency, whiteness, and hand of terry towels" 291-, 1987

6 Fergusson, S. M, "The effect of laundry detergents and residual alkali on the light fastness of reactive dyes on 100% cotton" RMIT University 2008

7 Hustvedt, G, "The adoption of sustainable laundry technologies by US consumers" 37 (37): 291-298, 2013

8 Merkel, R. S, "Textile product serviceability" Macmillan 1991

9 Statistia, "Sales of the leading liquid laundry detergent brands of the United States in 2016"

10 United States Energy Information Administration, "Residential energy consumption survey [CE3.1 End-use consumption totals and averages, US homes]"

11 McCowan, B, "Residential electric clothes dryer baseline study" Energy & Resource Solutions 2015

12 Statista, "Percentage of Canadian homes with a clothes dryer from 1998 to 2009"

13 Building, G, "New generation of horizontal-axis washing machines on the way" Brattleboro 1997

14 Martin, E, "Measured performance of heat pump clothes dryers" Florida Solar Energy Center 2016

15 Tomlinson, J, "Measured impacts of high-efficiency domestic clothes washers in a community" 10 : 63-74, 1998

16 Vogt, V, "Is it better to replace my washing machine or repair it?" HowStuffWorks 2015

17 Chiweshe, A, "Influence of household fabric softeners and laundry enzymes on pilling and breaking strength" 32 (32): 41-47, 2000

18 Williams, J. A, "How to choose cationics for fabric softeners" 59 (59): 28-32, 1982

19 Consumer Reports, "How much energy does an Energy Star dryer save"

20 Hamm, T, "How long will it take an energy-efficient washer/dryer to pay for itself" The Christian Science Monitor 2011

21 McCarthy, J. P, "Household fabric softeners : the chemistry and characteristics of cationic softeners" 65 (65): 33-, 1989

22 Healthy House Institute, "HE washing machines" North Charleston 2010

23 Ankeny, M, "Evaluation of various laundering platforms on color retention and surface appearance of 100% cotton knit fabric" 14 (14): 34-41, 2014

24 Klausing, S. L, "Evaluating dimensional change in home laundry" 12 (12): 51-56, 2012

25 Hill, C, "Environmental impacts of detergent" Livestrong 2015

26 Stawreberg, L, "Energy efficiency improvements of tumble dryers" Karlstad University 2011

27 Electric Power Research Institute, "Energy efficiency fact sheet—appliances" Palo Alto 2010

28 Pakula, C, "Electricity and water consumption for laundry washing by washing machine worldwide" 3 (3): 365-382, 2010

29 Chen-Yu, J, "Effects of household fabric softeners on thermal comfort of cotton and polyester fabrics after repeated launderings" 37 (37): 535-549, 2009

30 Chen-Yu, J, "Effects of household fabric softeners on flammability of cotton and polyester fabrics" 9 (9): 43-47, 2008

31 United States Environmental Protection Agency, Energy Star, "ENERGY STAR final version 8.0 clothes washers cover memo"

32 United States Environmental Protection Agency, Energy Start, "ENERGY STAR clothes dryers launch letter"

33 Meyers, S, "Do heat pump clothes dryers make sense for the US market" 9 : 240-251, 2010

34 Shehan, C. L, "Deconstructing laundry : gendered technologies and the reluctant redesign of household labor" 11 (11): 39-54, 2006

35 Schlag, M. T, "Comparison of the effects of a top-loading and a front-loading washing machine on cotton fabric" 30-39, 2010

36 Chowdhary, U, "Comparing three brands of cotton T-shirts" 4 (4): 22-33, 2017

37 Evergreen Economics, "Characterization of the super-efficient dryer market" Portland 2016

38 Consumer Reports, "Best fabric softeners"

39 United States Energy Information Administration, "Annual energy outlook 2016 with projection to 2040"

40 Bansal, P, "Advances in household appliances—a review" 31 (31): 3748-3760, 2011

41 American Association on Textile Chemists and Colorists (AATCC)., "AATCC technical manual" AATCC 2012