일본에서 민주주의의 형성과 변천 = Development of Democracy in Japan : From Pre-war “Minponshugi” to Post-war “Minshushugi”

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This essay traces the conceptualization and development of democracy in modern Japan by focusing on the institutionalization of party politics from the pre-war period to the post-war period. In the pre-war period, "party governments" in which the head of the majority party in the diet became the prime minister were institutionalized in the 1920s. It was during this time that ideas and practices of "democracy" were widely discussed in Japanese
society. One of the leading intellectuals who set the ground for national debates on "democracy" in terms of "minponshugi" was Yoshino Sakuzo. By analyzing Yoshino"s ideas on "democracy" within the context of changing state-society relations, this essay delineates possibilities and limits of "minponshugi" in the institutionalization of party politics. In the post-war period, the rebuilding of democracy by party politics was complicated by "anpo" struggles of the 1960s and the rapid economic development. The focus of the post-war development of democracy will be the formation and transformation of "citizens" in Japanese society.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• 머리말
• 1. 전전(戰前) 민본주의 : “사회의 발견”과 “따라잡기 민주주의”
• 2. 전후(戰後) 민주주의 : “개발민주주의”와 시민사회의 형성
• 맺음말
• 참고문헌
• 〈Abstract〉

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 한정선, "타이쇼민본주의 재평가 ―요시노 사쿠조와 신자유주의를 중심으로―" 동양사학회 (87) : 221-249, 2004

2 개번 매코맥, "일본, 허울뿐인 풍요" 창작과 비평사 1998

3 나카노 도시오, "오쓰카 히사오와 마루야마 마사오 : 일본의 총력전 체제와 전후 민주주의 사상" 삼인 2005

4 한정선, "대중문화의 표상과 일본 보수주의 : 만화 시마과장 과 현대일본의 샐러리맨 보수주의, In 전후 일본의 보수와 표상" 울대학교 출판문화원 2010

5 成田龍一, "近現代日本史と歴史学" 中央公論新社 2012

6 神島二郞, "現代日本の精神構造, In 戰後日本の精神史" 岩波書店 1988

7 高木郁朗, "無産政党の思想：社会民衆党, 日本労農党, 新旧労農党の運動思想, In 日本社會思想史 3: 昭和の反體制思想" 芳賀書店 1968

8 松尾尊兌, "民本主義と帝國主義" みすず書房 1998

9 朝日新聞社, "朝日新聞社史 2" 朝日新聞社 1991

10 宮地正人, "日露戰爭後政治史の硏究" 東京大學出版社 1973

11 三谷太一郞, "日本政党政治の形成 : 原敬の政治指導の展開" 東京大學出版會 1967

12 한상일, "日本戰後政治의 變動 : 占領統治에서 새 體制의 모색까지" 법문당 1997

13 鶴見俊輔, "日本の百年" 筑摩書房 1964

14 飯田泰三, "日本の国家思想 下" 靑木書店 1980

15 鹿野正直, "大正デモクラシーの底流 : ‘土俗’的精神の回歸" 日本放送出版會 1973

16 松尾尊兌, "大正デモクラシイー" 岩波書店 1974

17 中野敏男, "ボランテイア動員形市民社會論の陷穽, In 現代思想" 1999

18 有馬學, "‘國際化’の中の帝國日本, 1905~1924" 中央公論新社 1999

19 Yutaka Tsujinaka, "rom Developmentalism to Maturity : Japan's Civil Society Organizations in Comparative Perspective, In The State of Civil Society in Japan" Cambridge University Press 2003

20 Frank E. Manuel, "Utopian Thought in the Western World" Harvard University Press 1979

21 Alan G. Rix, "Tokyo's Governor Minobe and Progressive Local Politics in Japan" 15 (15): 1975

22 George O. Totten III, "The Socialist Democratic Movement in Prewar Japan" Yale University Press 1966

23 Karel van Wolferen, "The Enigma of Japanese Power: People and Politics in a Stateless Nation" Macmillan London 1989

24 Alan Przeworski, "Social Democracy as a Historical Phenomenon" (122) : 1980

25 Daniel P. Aldrich, "Site Fights : Divisive Facilities and Civil Society in Japan and the West" Cornell University Press 2008

26 Tsuyoshi Hasegawa, "Racing the Enemy : Stalin, Truman, and the Surrender of Japan" Harvard University Press 2005

27 George M. Packard III, "Protest in Tokyo : The security Treaty Crisis of 1960" Princeton University Press 1978

28 Charles Taylor, "Philosophical Arguments" Cambridge University Press 1995

29 Peter Duus, "Party Rivalry and Political Change in Taishô Japan" Harvard University Press 1968

30 Gordon M. Berger, "Parties Out of Power in Japan, 1931~1941" Princeton University Press 1977

31 Stephen S. Large, "Organized Workers and Socialist Politics in Interwar Japan" Cambridge University Press 1981

32 Andrew Gordon, "Managing the Japanese Household : The New Life Movement in Postwar Japan" (Summer) : 1997

33 Simon Avenell, "Making Japanese Citizens : Civil Society and the Mythology of the Shimin in Postwar Japan" University of California Press 2010

34 Chalmers Johnson, "MITI and the Japanese Miracle : The Growth of Industrial Policy, 1925~1975" Stanford University Press 1982

35 Andrew Gordon, "Labor and Imperial Democracy in Prewar Japan" University of California Press 1991

36 Jung-Sun N. Han, "Jung-Sun N. Han, An Imperial Path to Modernity: Yoshino Sakuzo and a New Liberal Order in East Asia, 1905~1937" Harvard University Press 2012

37 Chalmers Johnson, "Japan: Who Governs?-An Essay on Official Bureaucracy" 2 (2): 1976

38 Robert Pekkanen, "Japan's New Politics: The Case of the NPO Law" 26 (26): 2000

39 Theodore H. McNelly, "Induced Revolution’: The Policy and Process of Constitutional Reform in Occupied Japan, In Democratizing Japan" University of Hawaii Press 1987

40 Tetsuo Najita, "Hara Kei in the Politics of Compromise, 1905~1915" Harvard University Press 1967

41 Simon Avenell, "From the “People” to the “Citizen” : Tsurumi Shunsuke and the Roots of Civic Mythology in Postwar Japan" 16 (16): 2008

42 Simon A. Avenell, "Facilitating Spontaneity : The State and Independent Volunteering in Contemporary Japan" 13 (13): 2010

43 John W. Dower, "Embracing Defeat : Japan in the wake of World War II" W. W. Norton & Company 2000

44 H. D. Harrotunian, "Disciplinizing Native Knowledge and Producing Place : Yanagita Kunio, Origuchi Shinobu, Takata Yasuma, In Culture and Identity : Japanese Intellectuals during the Interwar Years" Princeton University Press 1990

45 Koji Taira, "Dialectics of Economic Growth, National Power, and Distributive Struggles, In Postwar Japan as History" University of California Press 1993

46 Richard H. Mitchell, "Censorship in Imperial Japan" Princeton University Press 1983

47 Kein M. Doak, "Building National Identity through Ethnicity: Ethnology in Wartime Japan and After" 27 (27): 2001

48 Mary A. Haddad, "Building Democracy in Japan" Cambridge University Press 2012

49 Kenneth B. Pyle, "Advantages of Followership: German Economics and Japanese Bureaucrats" 1 (1): 1974

50 Byron K. Marshall, "Academic Freedom and the Japanese Imperial University, 1868~1939" University of California Press 1992

51 小熊英二, "<民主>と<愛國> : 戰後日本のナショナリズ厶と公共性" 新曜社 2002