집단미술치료가 치매 노인에게 미치는 영향에 대한 체계적 고찰 = A Systematic Review on the Effects of Group Art Therapy on the Older with Dementia

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Purpose : This study aimed to present evidence by analyzing the characteristics and effectiveness of group art therapy interventions through an examination of domestic studies on group art therapy for older people with dementia.
Methods : The database used DBpia, Riss, and Google Scholar, and the research period was from 2016 to November 2021. For the selected studies, the level of evidence was analyzed, bias evaluation was performed, and patient, intervention, comparison, and outcome were analyzed. For the evaluation of bias, the risk of bias assessment tool for non-randomized study (RoBANS) and Cochrane’s risk of bias (RoB) were used.
Results : As for the level of evidence of the included studies, level Ⅰ consisted of five studies, and levels Ⅱ and Ⅲ each had one article. As a result of the bias evaluation of five studies through RoB, a “low risk of bias” was found for incomplete result data, selective result reporting, and others, except for four unclear evaluation areas. The “low risk of bias” ratio was 0~25 % in the evaluation of bias in two studies through RoBANS. For the evaluation tool, cognitive evaluation tool was used the most while mini-mental state examination-Korea was used the most frequently. For the intervention method, the most frequently used was group art therapy that employed recall in three studies, while collage, Korean painting, use of paper media, and procedural memory were used in each of the other studies. Each intervention was found to be significantly effective overall.
Conclusion : This study provided clinical evidence by systematically reporting research on group art therapy for older people with dementia. In the future, it is necessary to check the effect of group art therapy on various areas other than cognition for older people with dementia. Moreover, the study should be conducted with the risk of bias sufficiently taken into consideration.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이승희 ; 장덕희, "회상을 통한 미술프로그램이 요양병원 치매 노인의 자아통합감에 미치는 효과" 인문사회 21 10 (10): 1405-1420, 2019

2 오영이 ; 이숙민, "회상요법을 적용한 집단미술치료가 주간보호시설 경증치매노인의 삶의 질과 정서에 미치는 영향" 산업진흥원 1 (1): 79-86, 2016

3 채윤희 ; 문정민, "한국화 매체를 활용한 집단미술치료가치매노인의 자기표현에 미치는 효과" 한국미술치료학회 25 (25): 851-872, 2018

4 이연주 ; 이근매, "콜라주 집단미술치료 프로그램이 치매노인의 인지기능과 우울에 미치는 효과" 한국재활심리학회 25 (25): 243-258, 2018

5 한경아 ; 문리학, "치매노인 대상 미술치료의 효과성에 대한 메타분석" 한국예술심리치료학회 15 (15): 285-311, 2019

6 김용숙 ; 전순영, "종이매체를 활용한 집단미술치료가 치매노인의 인지기능과 소근육 운동에 미치는 효과" 한국미술치료학회 26 (26): 901-923, 2019

7 이윤주 ; 김택호, "절차기억을 활용한 집단미술치료가 경증치매노인의 기억력과 자아존중감에 미치는 효과" 한국미술치료학회 27 (27): 767-788, 2020

8 이주영 ; 임나영, "세시풍속을 활용한 회상 중심 집단미술치료가 경증치매노인의 기억력과 우울에 미치는 효과" 한국미술치료학회 23 (23): 895-916, 2016

9 이순덕 ; 장유진 ; 박천호, "서울형 데이케어(day-care)센터의 원예치료 프로그램 인식과 실태" 인간식물환경학회 15 (15): 79-84, 2012

10 박주연 ; 김선희, "사이코사이버네틱 모델을 활용한 집단미술치료가 시설거주 경증치매노인의 불안, 자아존중감, 자기표현에 미치는 영향" 한국예술심리치료학회 15 (15): 21-45, 2019

11 이승욱, "메타분석에 있어서 무작위대조연구의 질 분석" 한양대학교 의과대학 35 (35): 33-39, 2015

12 성윤정 ; 이원우 ; 서가현 ; 임진서 ; 전성원 ; 양영애, "만 65세 이상 노인의 인지기능과 키오스크(KIOSK) 사용능력의 상관관계" 대한고령친화산업학회 11 (11): 135-142, 2019

13 Arbesman M, "Using AOTA ’s critically appraised topic(CAT)and critically appraised paper(CAP)series to link evidence to practice" 13 (13): 18-22, 2008

14 Kang YH, "The influence of group art therapy using sewing on memory, depression of the elderly with dementia" Graduate school of Myongji University 2018

15 Oh SW, "The effect of group art therapy on empathic ability and peer relationship of children" Graduate school of Myongji University 2016

16 Kim SY, "Testing a tool for assessing the risk of bias for nonrandomized studies showed moderate reliability and promising validity" 66 (66): 408-414, 2013

17 Kim SY, "Revision of clinical research literature classification tool and risk of bias assessment tool"

18 Shin GH, "On the effects group art therapy for enhancing self-esteem on demented elders' quality of life" Graduate school of Dongkuk University 2008

19 Central Dementia Center, "Korean Dementia observatory"

20 Law M, "Evidence-based rehabilitation:a guide to practice" SLACK 381-386, 2008

21 Central Dementia Center, "Dementia safety center project guide"