Right Dislocation vs. Fragment: A Reply to Ko (2014)

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Ahn & Cho (2005) proposes that some fragmentary utterances in Korean are derived from the full sentential structure via movement and deletion. Right dislocation (RD) in Korean can be analyzed in a similar way to fragments. D. Chung (2009), Kim & Hong (2013), and Ahn & Cho (2014) suggest that RD in Korean has bi-clausal structure (host clause plus appendix clause) and that an RDed phrase undergoes movement to a clause initial position in appendix clause and the rest of the clause undergoes deletion. This type of analysis accounts for the fact that RDed elements and fragments share core properties (cf. D. Chung 2009, 2012a, Kim & Hong 2013). Ko (2014), however, examines the question of whether the RDed elements can be treated in the same way as sentence fragments and argues that RDed elements significantly differ from fragments. This paper aims to defend the parallelism between RDed elements and fragments by reconsidering the data Ko (2014) discusses.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 고희정, "Two Ways to the Right: A Hybrid approach to Right-dislocation in Korean" 언어교육원 51 (51): 3-40, 2015

2 Merchant, J., "The syntax of silence: Sluicing, islands, and the theory of ellipsis" Oxford University Press 2001

3 Watanabe, A, "The genesis of negative concord: Syntax and morphology of negative doubling" 37 : 551-579, 2004

4 Chung, D., "Some notes on Ko's (2014, 2015) hybrid analysis of the Korean RDC" Hankuk University of Foreign Studies 2015

5 Chung, S., "Sluicing(:) between structure and inference,' in Gutiérrez-Bravo, Rodrigo, Line Mikkelsen and Eric Potsdam (2011) Representing Language: Essays in Honor of Judith Aissen" California Digital Library eScholarship Repository. Linguistic Research Center, University of California 31-50, 2011

6 Chung, S., "Sluicing and the lexicon: The point of no return" Department of Linguistics 73-91, 2005

7 Chung, S., "Sluicing and logical form" 3 : 239-282, 1995

8 Ahn, H.-D., "Selected Papers from the 2006 Cyprus Syntaxfest" Cambridge Scholars Publishing 29-62, 2009

9 Ahn, H.-D., "Right dislocation in Korean" 2014

10 Ott, D., "Right dislocation as deletion" University of Groningen 2013

11 고희정, "Remarks on Right Dislocation Construction in Korean: Challenges to bi-clausal analyses" 언어교육원 50 (50): 275-310, 2014

12 Ahn, H.-D., "Reconstruction asymmetries in ellipsis: Implication for scrambling" 3-4, 2010

13 정대호, "Pre- vs. Post-verbal Asymmetries and the Syntax of Korean Right Dislocated Construction" 한국생성문법학회 22 (22): 703-721, 2012

14 정대호, "On the nature of null WH-phrases in Korean" 언어정보연구소 30 (30): 473-487, 2013

15 Ahn, H.-D., "On some ellipsis phenomena in Korean" Hankuk Publishing Co 3-33, 2012

16 안희돈, "On Scope Asymmetries in Fragments" 한국생성문법학회 15 (15): 661-678, 2005

17 안희돈, "On Caseless Fragments in Korean" 현대문법학회 70 (70): 25-47, 2012

18 안희돈, "Notes on Two Types of Fragments" 언어정보연구소 28 (28): 19-35, 2011

19 Park, B-S., "Island-insensitivity fragment answers in Korean" 2005

20 정대호, "Is amwu( N)-to a negative quantifier?" 언어정보연구소 29 (29): 541-562, 2012

21 Kim, S-W., "Hanging topic, pseudo-right dislocation and (pseudo) fragment answers" Dongguk University 2013

22 Ross, J, "Guess who?" 5 : 252-286, 1969

23 안희돈, "Fragments, Clause Type, and Clausal Architecture" 한국생성문법학회 21 (21): 201-214, 2011

24 Merchant, J, "Fragments and ellipsis" 27 : 661-738, 2004

25 Romero, M., "Focus and reconstruction effects in wh-phrases" University of Massachusetts at Amherst 1998

26 Ahn, H. -D., "Cokakmwun Yenkwu [Studies on Fragments]" Hankuk Mwunhwasa 2012

27 정대호, "An Elliptical Coordination Analysis of the Right Dislocated Construction in Korean" 대한언어학회 17 (17): 1-23, 2009