Education for all: quasi-experimental estimates of the impacts of compulsory primary education in Hong Kong

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper examines the causal impacts of Hong Kong’s 1971 policy of free compulsory education on students’ educational attainment. Using a regression discontinuity method and Hong Kong Census data, this study compares children born just before and just after the month in which the compulsory-education law came into effect. The results show that the law reduces approximately 10 percent of the dropout probability by age 12 and 8 percent of the dropout probability by age 15. The effect is substantial considering that approximately 90 percent of primary-school-age children were already in school in Hong Kong when the policy was implemented. The policy has larger impacts for socially and economically disadvantaged children, and the law also increases their probability of obtaining an education beyond middle school. Robustness is tested with several sensitivity checks. The results will help policy makers and stakeholders better understand the potential efficacy of mandated education policies and increasing educational access to targeted populations, especially for developing economies.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Pischke, J. -S., "Zero returns to compulsory schooling in Germany : Evidence and interpretation" 90 (90): 592-598, 2008

2 Xianggang nian bao, "Xianggang : Tian tian ri bao you xian gong si, 1971–1973 Xianggang nian jian" Hua qiao ri bao 1972

3 Salaff, J. W., "Working daughters of Hong Kong : Filial piety or power in the family?" Cambridge University Press 1981

4 Hong Kong Government., "White paper : Education policy" Government Printer 1965

5 "White Paper: Education Policy" Government Printer 1965

6 Choi, P. K., "Wan wan liu dian ban: qishi niandai shang ye xiao de nvgong. (晚晚6 點半:.七十年代上夜校的女工)" Step Forward Multi Media Company Limited 1998

7 Pong, S. -L., "Trends in gender and family background effects on school attainment : The case of Hong Kong" 42 (42): 249-271, 1991

8 Llera-Muney, A., "The relationship between education and adult mortality in the United States" 72 (72): 189-221, 2005

9 Del Bono, E., "The long term impacts of compulsory schooling: evidence from a natural experiment in school leaving dates" Centre for the economics of education, london school of economics 2007

10 Kan, K., "The fertility effect of education:Regression discontinuity for counts and exponential models" Institute of Economics Academia Sinica 2011

11 Murtin, F., "The expansion and convergence of compulsory schooling in Western Europe, 1950–2000" 78 (78): 501-522, 2011

12 Clark, D, "The effect of education on adult health and mortality: Evidence from Britain"

13 Dammert, A. C., "Siblings, child labor, and schooling in Nicaragua and Guatemala" 23 (23): 199-224, 2010

14 Morduch, J., "Sibling rivalry in Africa" 90 (90): 405-409, 2000

15 Malamud, O., "School tracking and access to higher education among disadvantaged groups" 95 (95): 1528-1549, 2011

16 Trochim, W. M. K., "Research design for program evaluation : The regression discontinuity approach" Sage 1984

17 Board of Education., "Report on review of 9-year compulsory education" Government Printer 1997

18 Lee, D., "Regression discontinuity inference with specification error" 142 (142): 655-674, 2008

19 Lee, D. S., "Regression discontinuity designs in economics" 48 (48): 281-355, 2010

20 Fitzpatrick, M. D., "Preschoolers enrolled and mothers at work? The effects of Universal Prekindergarten" 28 (28): 51-85, 2010

21 "Minutes of Education Department (GR) 4/278/68, 8 July 1971. Department of Education, Hong Kong"

22 "Memorandum for Executive Council: Provision on compulsory powers to secure attendance of children at primary school. 20 July, 1971.(XCR(71)171) Hong Kong Government"

23 Grenet, J., "Is extending compulsory schooling alone enough to raise earnings? Evidence from French and British compulsory schooling laws" 115 (115): 176-210, 2013

24 Hanushek, E. A., "International Encyclopedia of Education (vol. 2)" Elsevier 245-252, 2010

25 Census and Statistics Department., "Hong Kong social and economic trends : 1970–1980" Government Printer 1981

26 Government Secretariat, "Hong Kong education system" Government Printer

27 Devereux, P. J., "Forced to be rich? Returns to compulsory schooling in Britain" 120 (120): 1345-1364, 2010

28 van der Klaauw, W., "Estimating the effect of financial aid offers on college enrollment : A regression-discontinuity approach" 43 (43): 1249-1287, 2002

29 Harmon, C., "Estimates of the economic return to schooling for the UK" 85 (85): 1278-1286, 1995

30 Post, D., "Educational stratification, school expansion, and public policy in Hong Kong" 67 (67): 121-138, 1994

31 Wong, N., "Educational reform in Japan and Hong Kong: A comparative study of curriculum decentralization" Hong Kong University

32 Post, D., "Educational attainment and the role of the state in Hong Kong" 37 (37): 240-262, 1993

33 Meghir, C., "Education, health and mortality: Evidence from a social experiment" National Bureau of Economic Research 2012

34 Cabus, S. J., "Does school time matter? On the impact of compulsory age on school dropout" 30 (30): 1384-1398, 2011

35 Powdthavee, N., "Does education reduce the risk of hypertension? Estimating the biomarker effect of compulsory schooling in England" 4 (4): 173-202, 2010

36 Angrist, J. D., "Does compulsory school attendance affect schooling and earnings?" 106 (106): 979-1014, 1991

37 Oreopoulos, P., "Do dropouts drop out too soon? Wealth, health and happiness from compulsory schooling" 91 (91): 2213-2219, 2007

38 Parish, W. L., "Daughters, education, and family budgets : Taiwan experiences" 28 (28): 863-898, 1993

39 Bray, M., "Colonialism, scale, and politics : Development and convergence of educational development in Hong Kong and Macau" 36 (36): 322-342, 1992

40 Smith, J., "Can regression discontinuity help answer an ageold question in education? The effect of age on elementary and secondary school achievement" 9 (9): 48-, 2009

41 Kaestner, R., "Are brothers really better? Sibling sex composition and educational achivement revisited" 32 (32): 250-284, 1997