자발적 대가성 성관계의 비범죄화 = Decriminalization of Spontaneous Sexual Relations for Compensation

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The important thing in the reality where prostitution is becoming a problem is not examining whether it is the most appropriate ethical solution, but what kind of policy can reduce crimes related to such problems. The current dichotomous policy that divides largely into forceful or Spontaneous Sexual Relations for compensation(prostitution) does not give up the perspective that sex trade women, middle mediators and sex trade men are accomplices in crime, and therefore the seriousness of the co-existence of skillful rule and sex exploitation in the prostitution market is diluted in the actual criminal investigation process and rather making crime problems related to negative and abnormal sexual acts more serious.
Criminalizing Spontaneous sexual relations for compensation (prostitution) under the current policy may be ethical but it is difficult to guarantee actual effectiveness, and if there is a chance it could rather sustain various deviating sexual actions and promote related crimes, it can be said that there is a need to reexamine the fundamental prostitution prevention policy direction. Thus related policy should take a direction of change of perspective that develops a strategy to control the now vague idea of sex extortion as a main axis.
Most fundamentally, the focus of interest of criminal policy should not be sexual actions that are morally unacceptable, but should move to a direction that can punish debt subjugation human trafficking under the name of stern law and justice.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The important thing in the reality where prostitution is becoming a problem is not examining whether it is the most appropriate ethical solution, but what kind of policy can reduce crimes related to such problems. The current dichotomous policy that divides largely into forceful or Spontaneous Sexual Relations for compensation(prostitution) does not give up the perspective that sex trade women, middle mediators and sex trade men are accomplices in crime, and therefore the seriousness of the co-existence of skillful rule and sex exploitation in the prostitution market is diluted in the actual criminal investigation process and rather making crime problems related to negative and abnormal sexual acts more serious.
Criminalizing Spontaneous sexual relations for compensation (prostitution) under the current policy may be ethical but it is difficult to guarantee actual effectiveness, and if there is a chance it could rather sustain various deviating sexual actions and promote related crimes, it can be said that there is a need to reexamine the fundamental prostitution prevention policy direction. Thus related policy should take a direction of change of perspective that develops a strategy to control the now vague idea of sex extortion as a main axis.
Most fundamentally, the focus of interest of criminal policy should not be sexual actions that are morally unacceptable, but should move to a direction that can punish debt subjugation human trafficking under the name of stern law and justice.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 배종대, "형법, 형벌, 양형 - 성매매특별법의 경우 -" 한국형사정책연구원 17 (17): 437-470, 2006

2 "한국의 성문화와 형사법" 한국외국어대학교 법학연구소 25 : 2007

3 정현미, "한국 형사법의 발전과 여성" 한국형사법학회 19 (19): 223-246, 2007

4 오세혁, "정책연구 06?4 산업형 성매매 실태와 방지대책에 관한 연구" 국회여성가족위원회 2006

5 여성부, "여성정책 전략센터 연구자료(2)" 2007

6 김지영, "성판매 사범과 성매매 피해 여성을 변별하는 사회심리적 특성에 대한 연구" 한국피해자학회 14 (14): 301-325, 2006

7 천진호, "성착취와 성착취형 인신매매에 대한 형사법적 대응과 개선방안" 한국형사정책연구원 13 (13): 1-45, 2002

8 권영상, "성매매방지법의 집행효과에 관한 실증연구: 단속과 처벌강화를 中心으로" 서울행정학회 18 (18): 221-241, 2007

9 김은경, "성구매자재범방지교육(존스쿨)의 효과성 분석" 한국형사정책학회 18 (18): 2006

10 주승희, "법여성주의 이론의 흐름과 형사법에의 투영－성매매특별법을 중심으로－" 한국법철학회 8 (8): 275-296, 2005

11 하태영, "법사회학적 관점에서 본 매춘에 관한 연구- 매춘정책을 중심으로 -" 한국비교형사법학회 4 (4): 17-486, 2002

12 범죄백서, "법무연수원" 2007

13 대검찰청, "범죄분석" 2007

14 오정진, "性에 관한 법적 담론의 전개와 전망" 한국법철학회 6 (6): 253-264, 2003

15 Arthur Kaufmann, "Subsid?itatsprinzip und Strafrecht" 1974

16 Roxin, "Strafrecht: Allgemeiner Teil, BandⅠ, 3. Aufl"

17 Garland, David, "Punishment and Modern Society: A Study in Social Theory" 1990

18 C. Smart, "Penetrating Women’s Bodies; The Problem of Law and Medical Technology in Gender, Power & Sexuality" 1991

19 Hilde Kaufmann, "Kriminolgie Ⅲ" 1977

20 국회여성가족위원회, "2007년도 국정감사자료집" 2007