비잔티움과 튀르크 제국 사이의 아나톨리아 반도 －1071년부터 1096년까지 비잔티움인들의 저항을 중심으로－ = Anatolia between the Byzantine and Turkish Empire: Focusing on the Byzantine Resistance From 1071 to 1096

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This article`s aim is not only to examine the different stages of the Selcuk-Turkish penetration in Anatolia but also to trace the Byzantine response against the Turkish challenge during the period of 1071-1096. The first point is that under the emperor Michael VII (1071-1078), the Turks penetrated deep into Anatolia, moving out the Byzantine defensive system on the eastern borders. They occupied only a small number of cities, such as Trebizond, Coloneia and Caesarea. Therefore, the gloomy picture that we have usually seen of Anatolia at the end of the reign of Michael VII should be changed. On the other hand, it is sure that under the emperor Nikephoros III Botaneiates (1078-1081), the revolt of Melissenos opened many towns of Bithynia and Phrygia to the Turks. The second point is that at the advent of Emperor Alexios I Komnenos, the Byzantines still occupied important positions. The defense of the eastern border system remained largely in place, and Turks could reach only Propontis by sea. The Byzantines held all coastal territories both in Paphlagonia and in the area of Optimation, Opsikion and Thrakesion. The situation of Anatolia inland was very confusing, but regions, such as those commissioned by Michael Bourtzes, were still resistant. The third point is that the years of 1084 - 85 mark a turning point. At that time the Dani?mend Turks moved around Sebasteia in the northeastern Anatolia. On the other hand, the Emperor Alexios I won territory (including the western part of Anatolia, the Opsikion and the Thrakesion) with the assistance of Theodoros Gabras. Except in Bithynia, the Selcuk-Turks eventually succeeded to break the Byzantine resistant front on the eve of the First Crusade. The final point is that the Byzantine persistence was not in vain, because considering the map of Byzantine regions, held the longest against the Turks, the coastal areas, Pontos, Thrakesion, Bithynia, largely corresponded to the territories that the Byzantines were able to regain after the First Crusade in 1096. Thus it showed that a short Turkish presence in western Anatolia between 1071 and 1096 did not make the Byzantine population forget its natural allegiance to the Empire. (Myongji University / [e-mail])

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 유재원, "터키, 1만년의 시간여행, 2권" 31-33,

2 유재원, "터키, 1만년의 시간여행, 1권" 337-339,

3 유재원, "터키, 1만년의 시간여행 2권" 책문 212-217, 2010

4 유재원, "터키, 1만년의 시간여행 2권" 217-,

5 유재원, "터키 1만년의 시간여행 1권" 271-287, 2010

6 유희수, "거룩한 도둑질: 중세 성유골 도둑 이야기" 도서출판 길 161-173, 2010

7 Michel Attaleiatès, "Ἱστορία, In Corpus Scriptorum Historae Byzantinae" Bonn 135-, 1853

8 Michel Attaleiatès, "Ἱστορία" 198-199,

9 Ἀλέξης Γ.Κ. Σαββίδης, "Ἀττάλεια: 11ος-ἀρχὲς 14ου αἰ.Ἡ Μετάβαση ἀπὸ τὴ Χριστιανικὴ στὴ Μουσουλμανικὴ Ἐξουσία" 3 : 121-162, 1989

10 G. Dédéyan, "pouvoirs arméniens dans le Proche-Orient méditérranéen (1068-1144)" Paris 268-, 1990

11 W.Seibt, "War Gagik II. von Großarmenien ca. 1972-1073: mega doux Charsianou?, In To Hellenikon, Vol. 2" New York 159-168, 1993

12 G. Zacos, "Vente Munz Zentrum, Vol. 76" 1993

13 G.L.Tafel, "Urkunden sur älteren Handels-und Staatgeschichte der Republik Venedig, mit besonderer Beziehung auf Byzanz und die Levante" Vienne 52-, 1856

14 P.Gautier, "Théophylacte d’Achrida, Lettres vol.II, Corpus fontium historiae Byzantinae 16/2" Thessalonike 519-, 1986

15 S. Zakkr, "The emirate of Aleppo : 1004-1094" Beyrouth 186-187, 1971

16 Cl. Foss, "The defense of Asia Minor against the Turks" 27 : 145-205, 1982

17 H. Haspels, "The Highlands of Phrygia" Princeton 205-257, 1971

18 Sp. Vryonis, "The Decline of Medieval Hellenism in Asia Minor and the process of Islamization from the Eleventh Century through the Fifteenth Century" Berkeley 96-104, 1971

19 Sp. Vryonis, "The Decline of Medieval Hellenism in Asia Minor" 103-114,

20 M.E.Martin, "The Chrysobull of Alexius I Comnenus to the Venetians and the Early Venetian Quarter in Constantinople" 39 : 19-22, 1978

21 A. Bryer-D.Winfield, "The Byzantine Monuments and Topography of the Pontos, Vol. 1" Washington D.C. 107-110, 1985

22 C. Foss, "Survey of Midieval Castles of Antolia I : Kütahya" Oxford 1985

23 N. Oikonomides, "Studies of Byzantine Sigillography, Vol. 3" Washington D.C. 78-, 2000

24 N. Oikonomides, "Studies of Byzantine Sigillography, Vol. 2" Washington D.C. 168-169, 1994

25 C.Foss, "Strobilos and Related Sited" 38 : 147-174, 1988

26 G. Schlumberger, "Sigillographie de l’empire byzantin" Paris 282-, 1884

27 V. Šandrovskaja, "Sfragistika, Iskusstvo Vizantii v sobranijach SSSR-Katalog vystavki. Vol. 2" Moscou 1977

28 Cl.Cahen, "Seljukides de Rum, Byzantins et Francs d’après le Seljuk-nameh anonyme"

29 Ebersolt, "Sceaux byzantins du musée de Constantinople" 4 (4): 1914

30 A. Szemioth, "Sceaux byzantins du Musée National de Varsovie" 11 : 63-89, 1966

31 J.-Cl. Cheynet, "Sceaux byzantins de la collection Henri Seyrig" 113-,

32 J.-Cl. Cheynet, "Sceaux byzantins de la collection Henri Seyrig" Paris 1991

33 A. Kazhdan, "Oxford Dictionary of Byzantium, Vol. II" Oxford 1164-1165, 1991

34 Cl. Foss, "Nicomedia and Constantinople, In Constantinople and its Hinterland" Aldershot 181-190, 1995

35 Cecil Morrisson, "Monnaie et finances dans l’Empire byzantin Xe-XIVe siècle, In Hommes et richesses dans l’Empire byzantin VIIIe-XVe siècles" Paris 302-303, 1991

36 G. Dédéyan, "Les pouvoirs arméniens" 292-,

37 V. Laurent, "Les bulles métriques dans la sigillographie byzantine" 1932

38 J.Darrouzes, "Le mouvement des fondations monastiques au XIe siècle" 6 : 170-, 1976

39 Cl. Cahen, "La première pénétration turque en Asie Mineure" 18 : 31-32, 1948

40 A. Tuilier, "La date exacte du chrysobull d’Alexis Ier Comnène en faveur des Vénétiens et son contexte historique’" 4 : 28-38, 1975

41 I.Mélikoff, "La Geste de Melik Danishmend : Etude critique du Danishmendname, 2 vols" Paris 1960

42 A. N. Kurat, "Izmir ve civarindaki adalarin ilk Turk Beyi: MS. 1081-1096" Ankara 1966

43 M. Pinder, "Ioannis Zonarae Epitomae historiarum" Bonn 693-, 1897

44 A. Savvides, "Ho Seltzouos emires tes Smyrnes Tzachas" 14 : 9-24, 1982

45 A. Jaubert, "Géographie d’Edrisi, Vol. 2" Paris 134-, 1836

46 W. Seibt, "Eine prosopographisch-sigillographische Studie, Byzantina Vindobonensia Vol. IX" Vienne 93-, 1976

47 W. Seibt, "Eine prosopographisch-sigillographische Studie" 87-,

48 P. Gautier, "Défection et soumission de la Créte sous Alexis Ier Comnène" 35 : 217-219, 1977

49 W. Seibt, "Die byzantinischen Bleisiegel in Österreich, Vol. 2"

50 A.-K.Wassiliou-W. Seibt, "Die byzantinischen Bleisiegel in Österreich, Vol. 2" Vienne 218-, 2004

51 W.Seibt, "Die byzantinischen Bleisiegel in Österreich" Vienne 140-, 1978

52 "Collection des sceaux de l’Institute Français des Etudes Byzantine"

53 P. Lemerle, "Cinq études sur le XIe siècle byzantin" Paris 167-, 1977

54 J.-B. Chabot, "Chronique de Michel le Syrien, Patriarche jacobite d’Antioche (1166-1199)" Bruxelles 173-, 1963

55 J.Nesbitt, "Catalogue of Byzantine Seals, Vol. 3"

56 J. Nesbitt, "Catalogue of Byzantine Seals at Dumbarton Oaks and in the Fogg Museum of Art, Vol. 3" Washington D.C. 32-, 1996

57 J. Nesbitt, "Catalogue of Byzantine Seals"

58 J. Nesbitt, "Catalogue of Byzantine Seals"

59 Cl.Foss, "Byzantine and Turkish Sardis" Cambridge/Mass 71-, 1976

60 G. Zacos, "Byzantine Lead Seals, Vol. 2, n.400"

61 G. Zacos, "Byzantine Lead Seals, Vol. 2, n. 904"

62 G. Zacos, "Byzantine Lead Seals, Vol. 2, n. 639"

63 G. Zacos, "Byzantine Lead Seals, Vol. 2" Bern 1984

64 E.L. Varanouse, "Byzantina engrapha tes mones Patmou, Vol. 1" Athens 49-55, 1980

65 K.M. Konstantopoulos, "Byzantiaka molyvdoboulla tou en Athenais Ethnikou Nomismatikou Mouseiou" Athens 1917

66 J. Laurent, "Byzance et les Turcs Seldjoukides dans l’Asie Occidentale jusqu’en 1081" Paris-Nancy 110-111, 1913

67 G.Bates, "Archeological Exploration of Sardis, Byzantine Coins" Cambridge/Mass 138-, 1971

68 Anne Comnène, "Alexiade, Vol. 3" 25-,

69 Anne Comnène, "Alexiade, Vol. 3" 142-,

70 Anne Comnène, "Alexiade, Vol. 3" 23-,

71 Anne Comnène, "Alexiade, Vol. 2" 110-111,

72 Anne Comnène, "Alexiade, Vol. 2" 68-,

73 Anne Comnène, "Alexiade, Vol. 2" 186-,

74 Anne Comnène, "Alexiade, Vol. 2" 114-,

75 A.Pertusi, "Ai confini tra religione e politica. La contesa per le relique di s. Nicola tra Bari, Venezia e Genova" 5 : 6-58, 1978

76 A. Dunn, "A Handlist of the Byzantine Lead Seals and tokens and of Western and Islamic seals in the Barber Institute" Birmingham 8-, 1983