생명윤리학의 방법론 小考 = A Study on the Methods of Bioethics

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Nowadays there are so many approaches to bioethics including traditional deontology and utilitarianism, modern principlism and casuistry as well as virtue bioethics, care bioethics, narrative bioethics, feminist bioethics, communitarian bioethics, pragmatism bioethics, phenomenological bioethics etc. Although the methods of bioethics would never resolve every legal problem resulting from bio-science and bio-technologies, they could provide methodological basis for finding a way to resolve the problems. The methods for bioethics are not going to differ from those for ethics or moral philosophy in general. Like another applied ethics, main ethical theories of bioethics are not different from those of ethics in general. Above all, deontological theories and utilitarian theories are intermingles with each other in bioethics. The structure & process of resolution of bioethical problems is also analogous to that of another applied ethics or practical ethics. The resolution mechanism of bioethical problems will not work by simple case study without appeal to ethical theories. But mere application of ethical theories to particular cases can not resolve bioethical problems properly. In these respects, every method in bioethics has it's strengths and weaknesses. Futhermore some approaches are overlapped, converged and complementary to each other. Nearly all bioethicists reject the extreme approaches in favor of more moderate views that concede much to the other camp. The methodological debate has now moved to a more mature and reflective stage, in which confrontation has begun to be superseded by accommondation and reconciliation.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Ⅰ. 머리말
• Ⅱ. 의무론 vs. 공리주의
• Ⅲ. 원리중심주의 vs. 사례중심주의
• Ⅳ. 대안적 접근방법들
• Ⅴ. 맺음말

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Kant, I., "윤리형이상학 정초" 아카넷 2005

2 이상목, "생명윤리학의 방법론" 14 : 2001

3 권복규, "생명윤리와 법" 이화여대 출판부 2005

4 최경석, "생명윤리에서의 넓은 반성적 평형과 판단력" 한국법철학회 11 (11): 65-84, 2008

5 박은정, "생명공학시대의 법과 윤리" 이화여대 출판부 2000

6 Daniels, N., "“Wide Reflective Equilibrium in Practice”, Philosophical Perspectives on Bioethics" University of Toronto Press 1996

7 Beauchamp, T., "“The Role of Principles in Practical Ethics”, Philosophical Perspectives on Bioethics" U. of Toronto P. 1996

8 Winkler, E., "“Moral Philosophy and Bioethics: Contextualism versus the Paradigm Theory Bioethics”, Philosophical Perspectives on Bioethics" University of Toronto Press 1996

9 Hare, R.M., "“Methods of Bioethics”, Philosophical Perspectives on Bioethics" University of Toronto Press 1996

10 Childress, J., "“Methods in Bioethics”, The Oxford Handbook of Bioethics" OUP 2007

11 Nelson, H., "“Four Narrative Approaches to Bioethics”, Handbook of Bioethics" Kluwer 2004

12 Rachels, J., "“Ethical theory and bioethics”, A Companion to Bioethics" Blackwell 1998

13 Walker, R., "“Bioethics”, Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2.ed, Vol. 1" Macmillan 2006

14 Shanner, L., "“Bioethics through the Back Door: Phenomenology, Narratives, and Insight into Infertility”, Philosophical Perspectives on Bioethics" University of Toronto Press 1996

15 Boyle, J., "“An absolute rule approach”, A Companion to Bioethics" Blackwell 1998

16 Oakley, J., "“A virtue ethics approach”, A Companion to Bioethics" Blackwell 1998

17 Arras, J., "“A Case Approach”, A Companion to Bioethics" Blackwell 1998

18 Manning, R., "“A Care Approach”, A Companion to Bioethics" Blackwell 1998

19 Smart, J.J.C., "Utilitarianism, “Utilitarianism[Addendum]”, Encyclopedia of Philosophy. 2. ed" Thomson Gale 2006

20 Ross, W.D., "The Right and The Good" OUP 1930

21 Steinbock, B., "The Oxford Handbook of Bioethics" OUP 2007

22 Jonsen, A., "The History of Bioethics as a Discipline”, Handbook of Bioethics" Kluwer 2004

23 Jonsen, A., "The Abuse of Casuistry: A History of Moral Reasoning" University of California Press 1988

24 Beauchamp, T., "Principles of Biomedical Ethics" OUP 1979

25 Sumner, L., "Philosophical Perspectives on Bioethics" University of Toronto Press 1996

26 Fletcher, J., "Morals and Medicine" Princeton UP 1954

27 Herring, J., "Medical Law and Ethics" OUP 2006

28 Pattinson, S., "Medical Law and Ethics" Sweet&Maxwell 2006

29 Jackson, E., "Medical Law" OUP 2006

30 Khushf, G., "Handbook of Bioethics" Kluwer 2004

31 Engelhardt, H.T., "Foundations of Bioethics" OUP 1986

32 Frankena, W., "Ethics 2nd ed" Prentice-Hall 1973

33 Düwell, M., "Bioethik" Metzler 2008

34 Gert, B., "Bioethics: A Return to Fundamentals" OUP 1997

35 Jecker, N., "Bioethics. An Introduction to the History, Methods, and Practice" Jones and Barlett 2007

36 Dolgin, J., "Bioethics and the Law, 2.ed" Aspen 2009

37 Paul, E., "Bioethics" Cambridge UP 2002

38 Bentham, J., "An Introduction to the Principles of Morals and Legislation"

39 MacIntyre, A., "After Virtue" Duckworth 1981

40 Veatch, R., "A Theory of Medical Ethics" Basic Books 1981

41 Rawls, J., "A Theory of Justice" Harvard UP 1971

42 Clouser, K., "A Critique of Principlism" 15 : 1990

43 Kuhse, H., "A Companion to Bioethics" Blackwell 1998