상황적 행동이론에서 도덕성의 역할: 도덕적 필터링 = The Role of Morality in Situational Action Theory: Moral Filtering

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study attempted to empirically investigate the moral filtering hypothesis as a major role of morality in situational action theory. More specifically, we examined whether people with high morality even in a criminogenic situation do not consider crime as an alternative using a specific hypothetical situation. The current study utilized the data from 「A study of juvenile felony crime」 conducted by the Korean Institute of Criminology(KIC) in 2013. This study estimated logistic regression. The results indicated that people with high morality were less likely to perceive crime as an action alternative in the first place, even in criminogenic settings that cause theft, robbery, and arson. The findings provide support for the moral filtering hypothesis in situational action theory and fill the gap in the existing literature. Lastly, the limitations of the study and suggestions for future research are discussed.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 곽형곤, "청소년비행에 있어 낮은 자기통제력과 도덕성의 상호작용 효과: 상황적 행동이론의 검증" 한국교정복지학회 (74) : 1-25, 2021

2 Brauer, J. R., "When crime is not an option : Inspecting the moral filtering of criminal action alternatives" 34 (34): 818-846, 2017

3 Tabachnick, B. G., "Using multivariate statistics" Pearson/Allyn & Bacon 2019

4 Hitlin, S., "The new sociology of morality" 39 : 51-68, 2013

5 Barton-Crosby, J., "The nature and role of morality in situational action theory" 19 (19): 1421-1437, 2022

6 Silver, J. R., "The nature and role of morality in offending : A moral foundations approach" 58 (58): 343-380, 2021

7 Kroneberg, C., "The interplay of moral norms and instrumental incentives in crime causation" 48 (48): 259-294, 2010

8 Barton-Crosby, J., "The Role of morality and self-control in conditioning the criminogenic Effect of Provocation : A partial test of situational action theory" 42 (42): 1273-1294, 2021

9 Pauwels, L., "Testing situational action theory : A narrative review of studies published between 2006 and 2015" 15 (15): 32-55, 2018

10 Paternoster, R., "Sanction threats and appeals to morality : Testing a rational choice model of corporate crime" 30 (30): 549-584, 1996

11 Messner, S., "Morality, markets, and the ASC : 2011 presidential address to the American Society of Criminology" 50 (50): 5-25, 2012

12 Herman, S., "Morality, deterrability, and offender decision making" 39 (39): 1-25, 2022

13 Kafafian, M., "Moral rules, self-control, and school context : Additional evidence on situational action theory from 28 countries" 38 : 861-889, 2022

14 Cochran, J. K., "Moral propensity, setting, and choice : A partial test of situational action theory" 37 (37): 811-823, 2016

15 Durkheim, E, "Moral education: A study in the theory and application of the sociology of education" Free Press 1973

16 Pogarsky, G., "Identifying"deterrable"offenders : Implications for research on deterrence" 19 (19): 431-452, 2002

17 Wikström, P. H., "Handbook of the Sociology of Morality" Springer Verlag 211-239, 2010

18 Wikström, P. H., "Do people comply with the law because they fear getting caught?" 8 (8): 401-420, 2011

19 Hirtenlehner, H., "Differential self-control effects : Moral filtering and the subsidiary relevance of self-control" 1 : 91-106, 2021

20 Timmer, A., "Deciding to commit crime in adolescence: Do moral beliefs matter?" Advance online publication 2023

21 Wikström, P. H., "Breaking rules: The social and situational dynamics of young people’s urban crime" Oxford University Press 2012

22 Fujino, K., "Application of situational action theory in Jap an using vignette survey" A dvance online publication 0 : 1007-, 2023

23 Sattler, S., "An experimental test of situation action theory of crime causation : Investigating the perception-choice process" 106 : 102693-, 2022