‘과학의 본성’ 교육 -그 다원성 고찰- = A Study on the Plurality of Nature of Science in Science Education

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Nature of Science(NOS) has been a well-organized focus of science education and one of the key elements in defining and cultivating scientific literacy for more than a century. In recent years, a specific description of NOS, which is often known as ‘the consensus view of NOS’, has become very influential and has gained ready acceptance as an arrangement for both curriculum building and research into understanding of NOS by students and teachers in many countries around the world. This study has two purposes; one is to review some debates and criticism on the consensus view of NOS which consists of a list of sentences to describe nature of refined and general science, which have been heated up for the last few years by many prominent science education researchers, and the other is to consider alternative perspectives on NOS for the purpose of a new direction of NOS education. As a result of an investigation into such views as ‘Teaching about NOS’, ‘Critical NOS’, ‘Critical Thinking-NOS’, ‘Whole Science’, ‘Features of Science’ and ‘Reconceptualized Family Resemblance Approach to NOS’, some implications which focus on the generality and plurality of content knowledge of NOS based on current philosophy of science and sociology of scientific knowledge are suggested for the improvement of teaching and learning NOS.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 정용욱, "법칙, 이론, 그리고 원리: 규범적 의미와 실제사용에서의 혼란" 한국과학교육학회 34 (34): 459-468, 2014

2 이수정, "미래 지향적인 실과(기술·가정) 교육과정 탐색" 한국실과교육학회 21 (21): 21-39, 2008

3 이정원, "교육과정 개정에 따른 과학의 본성 수준 및 반영정도 탐색: 7차 및 2009 개정교육과정사례 분석" 대한지구과학교육학회 9 (9): 217-232, 2016

4 노태희, "과학의 본성에 대한 초등학생들의 견해" 한국과학교육학회 22 (22): 882-891, 2002

5 Acevedo-Díaz, J. A., "«Algo antiguo, algo nuevo, algo prestado». Tendencias sobre la naturaleza de la ciencia en la educación científica" 13 (13): 3-19, 2016

6 Driver, R., "Young People’s Images of Science" Open University Press 1996

7 Alters, B. J., "Whose nature of science?" 34 (34): 39-55, 1997

8 Rudge, D. W., "Whither the VNOS?" 225 : 2013

9 Osborne, J. F., "What"ideas-about science"should be taught in school science? A Delphi study of the expert community" 40 (40): 692-720, 2003

10 Erduran, S., "Visualising the nature of science: beyond textual pieces to holistic images in science education" Springer 2016

11 Lederman, N. G., "Views of nature of science questionnaire(VNOS) : Toward valid and meaningful assessment of learners conceptions of nature of science" 39 (39): 497-521, 2002

12 Ryder, J., "Undergraduate Science Students’Images of Science" 36 (36): 201-220, 1999

13 Duschl, R. A., "Two views about explicitly teaching nature of science" 22 : 2109-2139, 2013

14 Millar, R., "Twenty first century science : Insights from the design and implementation of a scientific literacy approach in school science" 28 (28): 1499-1521, 2006

15 Chang, Y., "Trends of science education research : an automatic content analysis" 19 : 315-332, 2010

16 Hodson, D., "Towards scientific literacy : A teachers’ guide to the history, philosophy and sociology of science" Sense Publishers 2008

17 Yacoubian, H. A., "Towards a philosophically and a pedagogically reasonable nature of science curriculum"

18 Hodson, D., "Time for action : Science education for an alternative future" 25 (25): 645-670, 2003

19 Kwak Y., "Theoretical background of constructivist epistemology" 22 (22): 427-447, 2001

20 Kampourakis, K., "The"general aspects"conceptualization as a pragmatic and effective means to introducing students to nature of science" 53 (53): 667-682, 2016

21 Merton, R. K., "The sociology of science : Theoretical and empirical investigations" University of Chicago press 1973

22 Resnik, D. B., "The price of truth : How money affects the norms of science" Oxford University Press 2007

23 McCain, K., "The nature of scientific knowledge : An explanatory approach" Springer 2016

24 McComas, W. F., "The nature of science in science education: Rationales and strategies" Kluwer 53-70, 1998

25 Abd-El-Khalick, F., "The nature of science and instructional practice : Making the unnatural natural" 82 (82): 417-436, 1998

26 Abd-El-Khalick, F., "The influence of history of science courses on students’ views of nature of science" 37 (37): 1057-1095, 2000

27 Oliveira, A. W., "The implicit communication of nature of science and epistemology during inquiry discussion" 96 (96): 652-684, 2012

28 Meichtry, Y. J., "The impact of science curricula on student views about the nature of science" 30 (30): 429-443, 1993

29 Aikenhead, G. S., "The development of a new instrument : ‘Views on Science-Technology-Society’(VOSTS)" 76 (76): 477-491, 1992

30 Eflin, J. T., "The Nature of Science: A Perspective from the Philosophy of Science" 36 (36): 107-117, 1999

31 Norris, S. P., "The Cambridge handbook of literacy" 271-285, 2009

32 McComas, W. F., "Ten myths of science : Reexamining what we think we know about the nature of science" 96 (96): 10-16, 1996

33 Abd-El-Khalick, F., "Teaching with and about nature of science, and science teacher knowledge domains" 22 (22): 2087-2107, 2012

34 McComas, W. F., "Teaching the nature of science: What illustrations and examples exist in popular books on the subject" 2005

35 Allchin, D., "Teaching the nature of science. Perspectives and resources" SHiPS Education Press 2013

36 Clough, M. P., "Teaching the Nature of Science to Secondary and Post-Secondary Students : Questions Rather Than Tenets, The Pantaneto Forum, Issue 25, January" 8 (8): 31-40, 2007

37 Osborne, J. F., "Teaching scientific practices : Meeting the challenge of change" 25 (25): 177-196, 2014

38 Stanley, W. B., "Teaching sciences : The multicultural question revisited" 85 (85): 35-49, 2001

39 Hodson, D., "Teaching and learning science : Towards a personalized approach" McGraw-Hill Education 1998

40 Hodson, D., "Teaching and learning about science : Language, theories, methods, history, traditions and values" Sense Publishers 2009

41 Clough, M. P., "Teaching and assessing the nature of science" 78 (78): 56-60, 2011

42 Wheeler-Toppen, J. L., "Teaching NOS Tenets: Is it time for a change?" 2005

43 Deng, F., "Students’ views of the nature of science : A critical review of research" 95 (95): 961-999, 2011

44 Lederman, N. G., "Students’ and teachers’ conceptions of the nature of science : A review of the research" 29 (29): 331-359, 1992

45 Abd-El-Khalick, F., "Springer international handbooks of education: vol. 24. Second international handbook of science education" Springer Science+Business Media B. V 1041-1060, 2012

46 Kim, H., "Sociological understanding of science and technology" 20 : 223-238, 1997

47 Sadler, T. D., "Situated learning in science education : socio‐scientific issues as contexts for practice" 45 (45): 1-42, 2009

48 McComas, W. F., "Seeking historical examples to illustrate key aspects of the nature of science" 17 (17): 249-263, 2008

49 DeBoer, G. E., "Scientific literacy : Another look at its historical and contemporary meanings and its relationship to science education reform" 37 (37): 582-601, 2000

50 Lederman, N. G., "Scientific inquiry and nature of science" Springer 301-317, 2006

51 Laudan, L., "Scientific change : Philosophical models and historical research" 69 (69): 141-223, 1986

52 Bybee, R. W., "Scientific and engineering practices in K-12classrooms" 78 (78): 34-40, 2011

53 National Science Teachers Association(NSTA), "Science-Technology-Society : Science Education for the 1980s(An NSTA position statement)" National Science Teachers Association(NSTA) 1982

54 Matthews, M. R., "Science teaching : The role of history and philosophy of science" Psychology Press 1994

55 American Association for the Advancement of Science(AAAS), "Science for all Americans" Oxford University Press 1990

56 Polanyi, M., "Science bought and sold: Essays in the economics of science" University of Chicago Press 465-485, 1969

57 Salomon, J., "Science as a commodity" Longman 78-98, 1985

58 Osborne, J. F., "Science Education for the Twenty First Century" 3 (3): 2007

59 Erduran, S., "Science Education Research and Practice in Asia-Pacific and Beyond" Springer 3-24, 2018

60 Abd-El-Khalick, F., "Representations of nature of science in high school chemistry textbooks over the past four decades" 45 (45): 835-855, 2008

61 Yang, S., "Representations of Nature of Science in New Korean Science Textbooks: The Case of ‘Science Laboratory Experiment’" Seoul National University 2019

62 Ackerson, V., "Relationships among learner characteristics and preservice teachers’ views of the nature of science" 20 (20): 45-58, 2008

63 Allchin, D., "Rekindling phlogiston : From classroom case study to interdisciplinary relationships" 6 (6): 473-509, 1997

64 Erduran, S., "Regaining focus in Irish junior cycle science : Potential new directions for curriculum development on nature of science" 33 (33): 335-350, 2014

65 Rudolph, J. L., "Reconsidering the ‘nature of science’ as a curriculum component" 32 (32): 403-419, 2000

66 Dagher, Z. R., "Reconceptualizing the nature of science:Why does it matter?" 25 (25): 147-164, 2016

67 Erduran, S., "Reconceptualizing the nature of science for science education: Scientific knowledge, practices and other family categories" Springer 2014

68 Harding, P., "Portraying science accurately in classrooms : Emphasizing open‐mindedness rather than relativism" 37 (37): 225-236, 2000

69 Musgrave, A., "Philosophy of science: The central issues" Norton 1088-1113, 1998

70 van Fraassen, B. C., "Philosophy of science: The central issues" Norton 1064-1087, 1998

71 Wittgenstein, L., "Philosophical investigations" John Wiley & Sons, Inc 2009

72 Swinbank, E., "Perspectives on Science. The History, Philosophy and Ethics of Science. Teachers’ Resource File" Heinemann 2007

73 Elby, A., "On the substance of a sophisticated epistemology" 85 (85): 554-567, 2001

74 NGSS Lead States., "Next Generation Science Standards : For States, By States" The National Academies Press 2013

75 Martins, A. F. P., "Natureza da Ciência no ensino de ciências : uma proposta baseada em"temas"e"questões"" 32 (32): 703-737, 2015

76 Good, R., "Nature-of-science literacy in Benchmarks and Standards: Postmodern/relativist or modern/realist?" 10 : 173-185, 2001

77 Lederman, N. G., "Nature of science, scientific inquiry, and socio-scientific issues arising from genetics : A pathway to developing a scientifically literate citizenry" 23 (23): 285-302, 2014

78 Irez, S., "Nature of science as depicted in Turkish biology textbooks" 93 (93): 422-447, 2009

79 Khishfe, R., "Nature of science and decision-making" 34 (34): 67-100, 2012

80 Kaya, E., "Nature of Science in Teacher Education: A Holistic Approach" 11 (11): 2017

81 National Research Council(NRC), "National science education standards" National Academy Press 1996

82 Wong, S. L., "More from the horse’s mouth : What scientists say about science as a social practice" 32 (32): 1431-1463, 2010

83 Lederman, J. S., "Meaningful assessment of learners’understandings about scientific inquiry—The views about scientific inquiry(VASI)questionnaire" 51 (51): 65-83, 2014

84 Ennis, R. H., "Logic in teaching" Prentice-Hall 1969

85 SL, "Lehrplan" Philosophie 2008

86 Moss, P. A., "Learning from our differences : A dialogue across perspectives on quality in education research" 38 (38): 501-517, 2009

87 Feyerabend, P., "Knowledge without foundations" Oberlin College 1962

88 NW., "Kernlehrplan für die Sekundarstufe II, Gymnasium, Gesamtschule in Nordrhein-Westfalen" Philosophie 2014

89 Irzik, G., "International handbook of research in history, philosophy and science teaching" Springer 999-1021, 2014

90 Dagher, Z. R., "International handbook of research in history, philosophy and science teaching" Springer 1203-1233, 2014

91 Hodson, D., "International handbook of research in history, philosophy and science teaching" Springer 911-970, 2014

92 Ryder, J., "International handbook of research and development in technology education" Sense Publishers 287-296, 2009

93 Settlage, J., "Inquiry Science, Sheltered Instruction, and English Language Learners : Conflicting Pedagogies in Highly Diverse Classrooms" 14 (14): 39-57, 2005

94 Abd-El-Khalick, F., "Improving science teachers’conceptions of the nature of science : A critical review of the literature" 22 (22): 665-701, 2000

95 Pomeroy, D., "Implications of teachers’ beliefs about the nature of science : Comparison of the beliefs of scientists, secondary science teachers, and elementary teachers" 77 (77): 261-278, 1993

96 Ryder, J., "Identifying science understanding for functional scientific literacy" 36 : 1-42, 2001

97 Matthews, M. R., "How pendulum studies can promote knowledge of the nature of science" 10 (10): 359-368, 2001

98 Hodson, D., "History, philosophy and science teaching" OISE Press/Columbia University Press 1991

99 Duschl, R. A., "Handbook of research on science teaching and learning (Volume II)" MacMillan 443-465, 1994

100 Lederman, N. G., "Handbook of research on science education (Volume Ⅱ)" Lawrence Erlbaum 1739-1815, 2014

101 Roberts, D. A., "Handbook of research on science education (Volume Ⅰ)" Lawrence Erlbaum Associates 729-780, 2007

102 Roberts, D. A., "Handbook of research on science education" Routledge 2014

103 Lederman, N. G., "Handbook of research on science education" Lawrence Erlbaum 831-879, 2007

104 Matthews, M. R., "Handbook of research on history, philosophy and sociology of science" Springer 2014

105 Mirowski, P., "Handbook of Science and Technology Studies" MIT Press 635-689, 2008

106 Hodson, D., "Going beyond the consensus view:Broadening and enriching the scope of NOS-oriented curricula" 17 (17): 3-17, 2017

107 Osborne, J. F., "Going beyond the consensus view: A response" 17 (17): 53-57, 2017

108 Carter, L., "Globalization and science education : The implications of science in the new economy" 45 (45): 617-633, 2008

109 Kampa, N., "German national proficiency scales in biology : Internal structure, relations to general cognitive abilities and verbal skills" 100 (100): 903-922, 2016

110 Neumann, K., "From PISA to educational standards : The impact of large-scale assessments on science education in Germany" 8 : 545-563, 2010

111 Bazzul, J., "From Orthodoxy to Plurality in the Nature of Science (NOS) and Science Education: A Metacommentary" 17 (17): 66-71, 2017

112 Kaya, E., "From FRA to RFN, or how the Family Resemblance Approach can be transformed for science curriculum analysis on nature of science" 25 (25): 1115-1133, 2016

113 Lakatos, I., "Falsification and the methodology of scientific research programmes" 4 : 91-196, 1970

114 Abd-El-Khalick, F., "Examining the sources for our understandings about science : enduring conflations and critical issues in research on nature of science in science education" 34 (34): 353-374, 2012

115 Allchin, D., "Evaluating knowledge of the nature of(whole)science" 95 (95): 518-542, 2011

116 Duschl, R. A., "Epistemology and Science Education: Understanding the Evolution vs. Intelligent Design Controversy" Routledge 3-19, 2011

117 Abd-El-Khalick, F., "Embedding Nature of Science Instruction in Preservice Elementary Science Courses : Abandoning Scientism, But" 12 (12): 215-233, 2001

118 Kim, M., "Educational Effects of the Integrated Science Developed Under the 2009 Revised National Curriculum: Focused on Student’s Views on Nature of Science and Science-Technology-Society Relationship, Interest in Science, and Science Aspiration" Seoul National University 2016

119 Matthews, M. R., "Editorial" 6 (6): 323-329, 1997

120 Finson, K. D., "Drawing a scientist : What we do and do not know after fifty years of drawings" 102 (102): 335-345, 2002

121 van Dijk, T. A., "Discourse Studies : A Multidisciplinary Introduction(Vol. Ⅰ)" Sage Publishing 2011

122 Smith, M. U., "Defining versus describing the nature of science : A pragmatic analysis for classroom teachers and science educators" 83 (83): 493-509, 1999

123 Kötter, M., "Controversy as a Blind Spot in Teaching Nature of Science" 26 (26): 451-482, 2017

124 Karisan, D., "Contextualization of nature of science within the socioscientific issues framework: A review of research" 5 (5): 139-152, 2017

125 Giere, R. N., "Constructive realism" Images of Science 75-98, 1985

126 Grandy, R. E., "Consensus: Expanding the scientific method and school science" Teaching Scientific Inquiry:Recommendations for Research and Implementation 304-325, 2008

127 Hogan, K., "Comparing the epistemological underpinnings of students’ and scientists’ reasoning about conclusions" 38 (38): 663-687, 2001

128 Allchin, D., "Beyond the consensus view: Whole science" 17 (17): 18-26, 2017

129 Erduran, S., "Beyond Nature of Science : The Case for Reconceptualising"Science"for Science Education" 25 (25): 93-111, 2014

130 American Association for the Advancement of Science(AAAS), "Benchmarks for scientific literacy" Oxford University Press 1993

131 Erduran, S., "Argumentation in science education : Recent developments and future directions" Springer 2007

132 Ziman, J., "Are debatable scientific questions debatable?" 14 (14): 187-199, 2000

133 Matthews, M. R., "Advances in nature of science research. Concepts and methodologies" Springer 3-26, 2012

134 Bybee, R. W., "Achieving scientific literacy : From purposes to practices" Heinemann Publishing 1997

135 Dagher, Z. R., "Abandoning patchwork approaches to nature of science in science education" 17 (17): 46-52, 2017

136 Zammito, J. H., "A nice derangement of epistemes : Post-positivism in the study of science from Quine to Latour" University of Chicago Press 2004

137 Yacoubian, H. A., "A framework for guiding future citizens to think critically about nature of science and socioscientific issues" 15 (15): 248-260, 2015

138 National Research Council(NRC), "A framework for K-12 science education" National Academy Press 2012

139 Irzik, G., "A family resemblance approach. Plenary presentation session with N. Lederman titled: Current philosophical and educational issues in nature of science (NOS) research, and possible future directions" 2011

140 Irzik, G., "A family resemblance approach to the nature of science for science education" 20 : 591-607, 2011

141 Ministry of Education(MOE)., "2015 revised national curriculum of science" Ministry of Education, Science and Technology 2015

142 양찬호, "2009 개정 교육과정에 의한 융합형 과학이 학생들의 과학의 본성과 STS에 대한 견해, 과학에 대한 흥미 및 포부에 미치는 영향" 한국과학교육학회 35 (35): 549-555, 2015