L'icône, l'hypoicône et la métaphore: L'avancée dans l'hypoicône jusqu'à la frontière du non conceptualisable

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

After briefly defining the central notion of icon in its relations to the
three phaneroscopic categories, the author deals more specifically with
the hypoicons: the image, the diagram, and the metaphor. As a result of
that analysis, it appears that the metaphor-trope should rather be
understood as pertaining to the logic of the diagram. Metaphor, given
under the hypoicon analysis, is defined as an inference that registers a
discovery process announcing an object not yet conceptualizable.
Referring to the historic context of the Lowell Conferences of 1903, the
author is led to recognize the strangeness of the definition of metaphor,
which, because of contradictions acknowledged by Peirce himself, does
not fit into the conception of the first semiotics. The author, therefore,
interprets this proposition made by Peirce as an exploratory advancement,
or as a leap forward opening the way to the elaboration of the second
semiotics, of which the central concept -the nonfulfillement of the sign,
the “would be”, the “semiosis ad infinitum”- perfectly integrates this
notion of metaphor. Brought closer to the epistemological positions
historically attributed to Nietzsche- a contemporary of Peirce -, and also
to those of the surrealists -whose advent was near-metaphor is thought
in a logic belonging as much to the order of the cognition as to that of
the aesthetics.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 BALAT, Michel, "≪Rhèmes d'amour≫ dans Protée, 26,3 (≪Logique de l'icône≫), pp. 77-87"

2 FISETTE, Jean, "≪Parler du virtuel. La musique comme cas exemplaire de l’icône≫, dans Protée 26-3, ≪Logique de l’icône≫, pp.45-54"

3 BRETON, André, "≪Manifeste du surréalisme≫ dans Manifestes du surréalisme" Gallimard 188-, 1924

4 HAUSMAN, Carl H., "≪Appendix. Metaphorical Reference and Peirce's Dynamical Object≫, dans Metaphor and art. Interactionism and Reference in the Verbal and Nonverbal Arts, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, pp.209-231"

5 "Écrits sur le signe (Textes rassemblés, traduits et commentés par G. Deledalle), Paris, 1978, Seuil, (≪L'Ordre philosophique≫) p.268. Abrégé ≪ÉS≫ suivi de la pagination, dans les renvois"

6 "The Essential Peirce. Selected Philosophical Writings. Vol. II (1893-1913), Edited by the Peirce Edition Project. Nathan Houser, General Editor., Bloomington, 1998, Indiana Univ. Press, p.584. Abrégé ≪EP2≫ suivi de la pagination, dans les renvois"

7 "The Essential Peirce. Selected Philosophical Writings. Vol. I (1867-1893), Edited by Nathan Houser and Christian Klosel, Bloomington, 1992, Indiana Univ. Press, p.399. Abrégé ≪EP1≫ suivi de la pagination, dans les renvois"

8 PEIRCE, Charles S., "The Collected Papers (vol I-VI:1931-35 par C. Hartshorne, P. Weiss; vol.VII-VIII:1958 par W. Burks), Harvard, Harvard Univ. Press,. Abrégé ≪CP≫ suivi du numéro du tome et du numéro du paragraphe, dans les renvois"

9 MERLEAU-PONTY, Maurice, "Signes" Gallimard 562-, 2001

10 MU, groupe, "Rhétorique générale, Paris, Larousse (≪Langue et langages≫), p.206"

11 FISETTE, Jean, "Pour une pragmatique de la signification. Suivi d’un choix de textes de Charles S. Peirce en langue française, Montréal, XYZ éditeur, (≪Documents≫) p.300"

12 KOFMAN, Sarah, "Nietzsche et la metaphore, Paris, Payot, (≪Bibliothèque scientifique≫) p.210"

13 LAKOFF, George, "Les métaphores dans la vie quotidienne" Minuit 1985-, 1980

14 NÖTH, Winfried, "Handbook of semiotics" Indiana University Press 576-, 1990

15 DELEDALLE, Gérard, "Charles S. Peirce’s Philosophy of Signs" Indiana Univertity Press 2000

16 DELEDALLE, Gérard, "Charles S. Peirce, phénoménologue et sémioticien, Amsterdam, J. Benjamins, (≪Foundations of semiotics≫-14) p.114"

17 FISETTE, Jean, "C.-S. Peirce, The Essential Peirce. Selected Philosophical Writings. Volume 2. Compte rendu" 20 (20): 351-367, 2000

18 SAVAN, David, "An Introduction to C. S. Peirce’s Full System Semeiotic, Toronto, Victoria College in University of Toronto, (≪Monograph Series TSC≫-1) p.74"