과학기술 위험갈등의 근원 -지식 혹은 감정?- = Origines of Risk Conflicts on Science Technology: Knowledge or Feeling?

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This research aims to explore origines of risk conflicts on science technology of the public. Especially, this research analyzes relative impact of contrasting conceptions, 'knowledge' and 'feeling', to risk conflicts. Results are as follows; first, difference of risk perception is appeared by feeling more clearly than by level of knowledge. Second, in correlation analysis, risk perceptions of science technology are significantly correlated with both knowledge and feeling variables. However, the correlation knowledge with feeling shows the complex pattern. This result means that high level of scientific knowledge not always bring about positive feeling to each science technology. Lastly, in regression analysis, feeling variables impact to risk perceptions on science technology more than knowledge ones. Through this analysis, the public judgements on risk of science technologies are more dependent upon feeling than scientific knowledge.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 박희제, "일반시민들의 과학에 대한 인식을 결정하는 요인들: 과학의 정당성 위기?" 35 (35): 29-57, 2001

2 오미영, "위험을 수반한 과학기술의 낙인효과 : 원자력에 대한 위험인식이 방사선기술 이용 생산물에 대한위험인식과 수용에 미치는 영향" 한국언론학회 52 (52): 467-500, 2008

3 노진철, "위험시설 입지정책 결정과 위험갈등: 부안 방사성폐기물처분장 입지선정을 중심으로" 6 : 188-219, 2004

4 최진식, "위험성 인식의 사회적 증폭요인에 관한 연구: 언론보도와 사회적 신뢰가 광우병 위험성 판단에 미치는 영향을 중심으로" 한국정책과학학회 13 (13): 165-188, 2009

5 박희제, "생명공학의 편익과 위험에 대한 인식이 GMO의 수용성에 미치는 영향" 123-137, 2003

6 정병걸, "기술위험관리와 위험갈등" 8 (8): 97-129, 2008

7 왕재선, "과학기술인식의 다원성과 영향요인: 유전자변형식품(Genetically Modified Food: GM Food)에 대한 일반인의 인식을 중심으로" 정부학연구소 17 (17): 145-185, 2011

8 송해룡, "과학기술 위험보도에 관한 수용자 인식 연구: GMO(유전자변형식품) 사례를 중심으로" 한국언론학회 49 (49): 105-128, 2005

9 김서용, "新과학기술 수용성의 결정요인 분석과 정책적 함의" 한국정책학회 19 (19): 211-244, 2010

10 Honkanen, P, "Understanding Attitudes Towards Genetically Modified Food: The Role of Values and Attitude Strength" 27 : 401-420, 2004

11 Slovic, P, "Trust, Emotion, Sex, Politics, and Science: Surveying the Risk_Assessment Battlefield" 19 (19): 689-701, 1999

12 Evans, G, "The Relationship between Knowledge and Attitudes in the Public Understanding of Science in Britain" 4 : 57-74, 1995

13 Scheufele, D. A, "The Public and Nanotechnology: How Citizens Make Sense of Emerging Technologies" 7 : 659-667, 2005

14 Siegrist, M., "The Influence of Trust and Perceptions of Risks and Benefits on the Acceptance of Gene Technology" 20 (20): 195-204, 2000

15 Fiske, S. T., "Social Cognition" McGraw-Hill 1991

16 Loewenstein, G. F, "Risk as Feeling" 127 : 267-286, 2001

17 Slovic, P., "Risk as Analysis and Risk as Feelings: Some Thoughts about Affect, Reason, Risk, and Rationality" 24 (24): 311-322, 2004

18 Scheufele, D. A, "Religious Beliefs and Public Attitudes toward Nanotechnology inEurope and the United States" 4 : 91-94, 2009

19 Frewer, L. J., "Reactions to Information about Genetic Engineering: Impact of Source Characteristics, Perceived Personal Relevance, and Persuasiveness" 8 : 35-50, 1999

20 Wynne, B., "Public Understanding of Science, In Handbook of Science and Technology Studies" Sage 1995

21 Durant, J., "Public Understanding of Science in Britain: The Role of Medicine in the Popular Representation of Science" 1 : 161-182, 1992

22 Freudenburg, W., "Public Responses to Technological Risks: Toward a Sociological Perspective" 33 (33): 389-412, 1992

23 Hossain, F, "Public Perceptions of Biotechnology and Acceptance of Genetically Modified Food" 34 (34): 36-50, 2003

24 Cobb, M. D., "Public Perceptions about Nanotechnology: Risks, Benefits and Trust" 6 : 395-405, 2004

25 Finucan, M. L, "Public Perception of the Risk of Blood Transfusion" 40 : 1017-1922, 2000

26 Durant, R., "Public Opinion, Risk Perceptions, and Genetically Modified Food Regulatory Policy: Reassessing the Calculus of Dissent among European Citizens" 6 (6): 181-200, 2005

27 Siegrist, M., "Public Acceptance of Nanotechnology Foods and Food Packaging: The Influence of Affect and Trust" 49 : 459-466, 2007

28 Townsend, E., "Psychological Determinants of Willingness to Taste and Purchase Genetically Modified Food" 24 (24): 1385-1393, 2004

29 Siegrist, M., "Perception of Hazards: The Role of Social Trust and Knowledge" 20 (20): 713-719, 2000

30 Macoubrie, J., "Nanotechnology: Public Concerns, Reasoning and Trust in Government" 15 : 221-241, 2006

31 Siegrist, M., "Laypeople's and Experts' Perception of Nanotechnology Hazards" 27 (27): 59-69, 2007

32 Frewer, L. J., "Genetic Engineering and Food: What Determines Consumer Acceptance?" 97 (97): 31-36, 1995

33 Gaskell, G., "GM Foods and the Misperception of Risk Perception" 24 (24): 185-194, 2004

34 Lerner, J. S, "Fear, Anger, and Risk" 81 (81): 146-159, 2001

35 Mauro, I. J, "Farmer Knowledge and Risk analysis: Postrelease Evaluation of Herbicide-Tolerant Canola in Western Canada" 28 (28): 463-476, 2008

36 Spence, A., "Examining Consumer Behavior Toward Genetically Modified(GM) Food in Britain" 25 (25): 657-670, 2006

37 Townsend, E, "Effects of Context and Feelings on Perceptions of Genetically Modified Food" 24 (24): 1369-1384, 2004

38 Knight, A., "Do Worldviews Matter? Post-materialist, Environmental, and Scientific/Technological Worldviews and Support for Agricultural Biotechnology Applications" 10 (10): 1047-1063, 2007

39 Bredhal, L., "Consumer's Cognitions with Regard to Genetically Modified Foods: Results of a Qualitative Study in Four Countries" 33 : 343-360, 1999

40 Kuznesof, S, "Consumer Acceptability of Genetically Modified Foods with Special Reference to Farmed Salmon" 98 (98): 39-47, 1996

41 Lerner, J. S., "Beyond Valence: Toward a Model of Emotion-Specific Influences on Judgement and Choice" 14 (14): 473-493, 2000

42 Allum, N., "An Empirical Test of Competing Theories of Hazard-Related Trust: The Case of GM Food" 27 (27): 935-946, 2007

43 Peters, E. M, "An Emotion-Based Model of Risk Perception and Stigma Susceptibility: Cognitive Appraisals of Emotion, Affective Reactivity, Worldviews, and Risk Perceptions in the Generation of Technological Stigma" 24 (24): 1349-1367, 2004

44 Townsend, E, "Affective Influences on Risk Perceptions of, and Attitudes Toward, Genetically Modified Food" 9 (9): 125-139, 2006

45 Siegrist, M., "A Causal Model Explaining the Perception and Acceptance of Gene Technology" 29 (29): 2093-2106, 1999