진전 변증에 관한 문헌적 고찰 - 중국 논문 중심으로 - = Literature Review on Syndrome Differentiation of Tremor, Focusing on Chinese Journals

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Background : It was not enough to apply three kinds of syndrome differentiation in our oriental medical textbook to tremor's treatment according to reports of Korea and traditional medical textbook of China. Objective : To investigate syndrome differentiations by types of diseases related to tremor through Chinese journals review and to suggest adding possible syndrome differentiations. Methods : Literature search was performed using China Academic Journal (CAJ), the search engine of China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI) from January 1994 to December 2009. Searching key words were Chinese characters in combination meaning tremor, paralysis agitans, and syndrome differentiation. We included all types of articles that explained or referred to definite syndrome differentiations. The symptoms and oriental medications by syndrome differentiation in selected articles were extracted and summarized. Results : 56 Chinese journals were ultimately selected. 37 kinds of syndrome differentiations about tremor were investigated, which included dual deficiency of qi and blood (氣血兩虛) quoted 31 times, liver-kidney yin deficiency (肝腎陰虧) 23 times, liver-kidney deficiency (肝腎不足) 21 times, and phlegm-heat stirring wind (痰熱動風) 20 times. 37 kinds of syndrome differentiation could by group into eight types, such as liver-kidney yin deficiency (肝腎陰虧), dual deficiency of qi and blood (氣血兩虛), phlegm-heat stirring wind (痰熱動風), heart deficiency and spirit weakness (心虛神弱), blood stasis due to qi stagnation (氣滯血瘀), sea of marrow deficiency (髓海不足), liver qi depression (肝氣鬱結), and liver yang transforming into wind (肝陽化風). Conclusion : We suggest that the syndrome differentiations of tremor, such as heart deficiency and spirit weakness (心虛神弱), blood stasis due to qi stagnation (氣滯血瘀), sea of marrow deficiency (髓海不足), liver qi depression (肝氣鬱結), and liver yang transforming into wind (肝陽化風), can be added to liver-kidney deficiency (肝腎不足), dual deficiency of qi and blood (氣血兩虛), and phlegm-heat stirring wind (痰熱動風) of the textbook. Further systematic research will be needed on them.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 郭麗婭, "老年性震顫的辨證論治" 14 (14): 314-315, 1997

2 박병준, "특발성 파킨슨병·파킨슨증후군 환자 7례의 치료경과사례 고찰" 대한한방신경정신과학회 20 (20): 283-295, 2009

3 양희숙, "턱떨림을 주증상으로 내원한 환자 3명에 대한 증례보고" 대한한방신경정신과학회 15 (15): 187-196, 2004

4 김수연, "청심연자탕가미방으로 호전된 진전 환자 치험 7례" 대한한방내과학회 29 (29): 913-921, 2008

5 주종천, "진전환자 24례에 대한 증례보고" 14 (14): 153-159, 2002

6 최병만, "진전을 주소로 내원한 환자 31례에 대한 임상고찰-체질의학적 치료를 중심으로" 13 (13): 57-74, 2002

7 신현철, "진전마비에 대한 문헌적 고찰" 3 : 81-98, 1995

8 임승민, "억간산가미방으로 증상 호전 보인 진전환자 1례에 대한 증례보고" 24 (24): 1062-1066, 2003

9 서영민, "심리적인 충격으로 인해 발병한 下顎振顫 환자 치험 1례" 대한한방신경정신과학회 20 (20): 237-247, 2009

10 전국한의과대학심계내과학교실, "심계내과학" 군자출판사 365-367, 2006

11 대한신경과학회, "신경학" 군자출판사 438-460, 2005

12 전국한의과대학심계내과학교실, "순환ㆍ신경내과학" 군자출판사 435-, 2010

13 이지훈, "소양인 지황백호탕으로 호전된 경증 파킨슨 환자에 대한 임상보고" 14 (14): 153-159, 2002

14 박진용, "불수의근진전환자 32례에 대한 유형별 임상고찰" 21 (21): 773-780, 2000

15 허준, "대역동의보감" 동의보감출판사 117-, 2005

16 손지영, "뇌졸중 후유증으로 나타난 진전 증상 치험 3례" 대한동의병리학회 19 (19): 1450-1455, 2005

17 구범모, "뇌교경색을 동반한 파킨슨병 환자의 소시호탕 치험예" 대한한의학회 28 (28): 34-43, 2007

18 陶春祥, "震顫麻痺辨治體會" 1 : 49-50, 1994

19 張燕龍, "震顫麻痺的中醫治療槪況" 15 (15): 378-379, 1994

20 劉軍, "震顫麻痺的中醫分型及治療" 14 (14): 24-25, 1994

21 任木惠, "震顫麻痹辨證施護的體會" 21 (21): 250-, 1999

22 劉明武, "震顫麻痹辨治探幽" 24 (24): 490-491, 1997

23 張小山, "震顫麻痹證治" 29 (29): 60-61, 1997

24 沙迪克, "震顫麻痹綜合征的辨證施治體會" 24 (24): 14-15, 2006

25 王一德, "震顫麻痹綜合征的中醫辨治" 16 (16): 41-43, 1997

26 劉泰, "震顫麻痹病110例辨治規律探討" 29 (29): 82-83, 2002

27 茅裕新, "震顫麻痹治驗二則" 18 (18): 23-, 1997

28 任志東, "震顫麻痹治驗1則" 14 (14): 14-, 1999

29 倪世秋, "震顫麻痹治療的現狀與展望" 1 (1): 40-42, 2000

30 武繼譸, "震顫麻痹從脾論治" 9 : 399-, 2003

31 陳陽, "震顫麻痹中醫研究治療進展" 20 (20): 33-35, 2005

32 郭梅英, "震顫麻痹135例辨證施治體會" 4 (4): 46-47, 1995

33 陳鳳英, "震顫性麻痹的辨治體會" 6 : 34-35, 1997

34 林天受, "震顫性麻痹治驗" 5 : 47-, 1994

35 祝維峰, "震顫寧治療帕金森病的臨床研究" 5 (5): 22-23, 2004

36 苑秀芝, "除顫湯治療震顫麻痹綜合征30例" 13 (13): 13-, 1997

37 甄建青, "鎮肝養血熄風湯治療震顫麻痹24例" 9 (9): 80-, 2007

38 曹文蘭, "鎮肝熄風法治療震顫麻痹綜合症療效觀察" 12 (12): 17-18, 1995

39 張保平, "鄭紹周辨治震顫麻痹的經驗" 18 (18): 221-, 2003

40 李士瑾, "郑绍周教授治疗震颤经验" 24 (24): 918-919, 2003

41 馬漢明, "辨證分型選方加五蟲散治療老年性震顫麻痺" 14 (14): 550-552, 1994

42 葉中峰, "辨證分型治療震顫麻痹36例" 19 (19): 30-, 2001

43 汪微仙, "補陽還五湯加減治療震顫一得" 8 (8): 40-, 2000

44 熊成熙, "補陽還五湯加減治療瘀血型老年震顫12例報告" 18 (18): 9-10, 1994

45 李傑, "血管性震顫麻痹30例臨床分析" 25 (25): 19-20, 2005

46 오민규, "腎精虧損으로 변증한 파킨슨병 환자의 이상운동증 治驗 1例" 대한한방내과학회 28 (28): 919-928, 2007

47 朱士伏, "老年性震顫麻痹辨治3則" 6 : 61-, 1996

48 申錦林, "老年性震顫麻痹的中醫藥治療進展" 5 : 21-23, 1994

49 陳慧芳, "真武湯治療雙手震顫2例" 19 (19): 91-, 1997

50 周端求, "牛黃降壓丸治療老年震顫麻痹的臨床觀察" 31 (31): 945-946, 2006

51 王玨, "滋陰熄風湯治療原發性震顫麻痹32例" 23 (23): 34-35, 1999

52 劉星磊, "滋水涵木法治療震顫麻痹的臨床觀察" 30 (30): 24-25, 2008

53 張小歡, "淺談震顫麻痹的中醫治療與護理" 9 (9): 44-45, 1997

54 劉澤延, "淺談震顫麻痹的中醫治療" 26 (26): 9-10, 2006

55 李玉香, "杞菊地黃湯加味治療老年震顫麻痹" 38 (38): 38-, 1995

56 武春麗, "息風止顫法治療震顫麻痹28例" 26 (26): 745-, 2004

57 張璐, "張氏醫通" 上海科學技術出版社 291-297, 1990

58 韓冠先, "平胃散爲主治療特發性震顫11例" 33 (33): 55-56, 2001

59 황진우, "小腦梗塞으로 인한 振顫患者의 治驗 1例" 대한한방내과학회 28 (28): 929-936, 2007

60 魏慶蘭, "定振丸加減治療震顫麻痹21例" 20 (20): 21-, 1999

61 吳沛田, "如何辨證治療震顫麻痹" 47 (47): 233-, 2006

62 王毅, "周紹華治療震顫麻痹經驗" 4 (4): 1027-1028, 2006

63 王伯仕, "化痰熄風法治愈震顫症" 6 (6): 1341-, 2008

64 李學文, "中醫辨證分型治療震顫麻痹症的臨床體會" 24 (24): 28-, 2000

65 齊建貞, "中醫藥治療震顫麻痹近況" 17 (17): 34-36, 1995

66 陶春梁, "中醫藥治療震顫麻痹近況" 22 (22): 286-287, 1995

67 張雲嶺, "中醫藥治療震顫痲痺的進展" 36 (36): 113-114, 1995

68 淩玲, "中醫治療震顫麻痹近況" 22 (22): 187-189, 2001

69 趙志新, "中醫治療震顫麻痹的臨床體會" 400 : 1994

70 謝瀟俠, "中醫治療震顫麻痹症綜述" 23 (23): 110-113, 2005

71 朱文鋒, "中醫常見症狀鑒別診斷(23)-癱瘓,震顫,紫斑-" 26 (26): 494-495, 1999

72 周仲瑛, "中醫內科學" 中國中醫藥出版社 489-496, 2007

73 勞國平, "中西醫結合治療震顫麻痹的療效觀察" 22 (22): 777-778, 2000

74 王增梅, "中西醫結合治療震顫麻痹症62例" 19 (19): 28-, 2001

75 張惠峨, "中西醫結合治療震顫麻痹40例" 27 (27): 26-, 1996

76 宋宇新, "中西醫結合治療震顫麻痹19例" 7 (7): 1806-1807, 1998

77 劉淑眞, "中西醫結合治療老年性震顫麻痹" 6 (6): 82-, 1997