고빈도 알고리즘 매매의 투기거래 분석: 주가지수 선물시장을 중심으로 = The Speculation Performance in High Frequency Trading: Focused on the Stock Index Futures Market

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study analyzes the investment performance of day trading using the stock index futures, which is a typical speculative trading strategy, in a situation where speculative transactions of High Frequency Trading using futures are increasing recently.
The main results of this study are as follows : First, day trading, which is a speculative trading strategy in the stock index futures market, showed statistically significant profits, and all of investments showed such profits. Second, as in previous studies, individual investors and general accounts of day trading did not show significant investment performance, but foreign investors showed significant profits in all accounts and HFT accounts of all investors also showed significant profits. Third, if all stock index futures are invested and the day trading strategy is continuously used, the investment performance is significantly improved.
This study is meaningful in that it clearly distinguishes the HFT compared to previous studies and shows that day trading strategy of HFT realizes statistically significant levels of profits.
In addition, the main results of this study suggest that HFT-based tradings will spread more and futures tradings will be more likely to be used in speculative trading, so the competition for an order speed cannot be seen as a positive change in the market as a whole.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이은정 ; 박경서 ; 장하성, "한국주식시장에서 데이트레이딩의 수익성에 관한 연구" 36 (36): 351-385, 2007

2 우민철 ; 최혁, "데이트레이딩 전략의 수익성 분석 : ETF 시장을 대상으로" 41 (41): 677-704, 2012

3 우민철 ; 최혁, "고빈도거래자의 매매양태 분석 : ELW 시장을 대상으로" 42 (42): 699-732, 2013

4 우민철 ; 이우백, "개인투자자의 고빈도매매 행태와 성과분석" 43 (43): 847-878, 2014

5 Ye, M., "e Externalities of High Frequency Trading" WBS 2013

6 Carrion, A., "Very Fast Money : High Frequency Trading on the NASDAQ" 16 : 680-711, 2013

7 Barber, B. M., "Trading is Hazardous to Your Wealth : The Common Stock Investment Performance of Individual Investors" 55 : 773-806, 2002

8 Harris, J. H., "The Trading Profits of SOES Bandits" 50 : 39-62, 1998

9 Baron, M., "The Trading Profits of High Frquency Traders"

10 Garvey, R., "The Profitability of Active Stock Traders" 15 : 93-100, 2005

11 Linnainmaa, J., "The Individual Day Trader" UCLA 2005

12 정재만 ; 최혁 ; 고봉찬, "The Impact of Day-Trading on Volatility and Liquidity" 38 : 237-275, 2009

13 Hagstromer, B., "The Diversity of High-Frequency Traders" 16 : 741-770, 2013

14 Barber, B. M., "The Cross-Section of Speculator Skill : Evidence from Day Trading" 18 : 1-24, 2014

15 Hautsch, N., "The Ambivalent Role of High Frequency Trading in Turbulent Market Period" CFS

16 Baron, M., "Risk and Return in High Frequency Trading" 54 : 993-1024, 2019

17 Saulius, M, "Quantitative Research In High Frequency Trading for Natural Gas Futures Market" BIS 2015

18 Benos, E., "Price Discovery and the Cross-Section of High Frequency Trading" 30 : 54-77, 2016

19 Foucault, T., "News Trading and Speed" 71 : 335-382, 2016

20 Zhang, S. S., "Need for Speed : Hard Information Processing In a High Frequency World" 38 : 3-21, 2018

21 Jovanovic, B., "Middlemen in Limit Order Market"

22 Seru, A., "Learning by Trading" 23 : 705-739, 2010

23 Michael, J. B., "International Portfolio Investment Flows" 52 : 1851-1880, 2012

24 Ding, S., "How Slow is the NBBO? A Comparison with Direct Exchange Feeds" 49 : 313-332, 2014

25 Brogaard, J., "High-frequency Trading and the Execution Costs of Institutional Investors" 49 (49): 345-369, 2014

26 Schlepper, K., "High Frequency Trading in the Bund Futures Market" Bundesbank 2016

27 O’Hara, M., "High Frequency Trading and Its Impact on Market" 70 : 18-27, 2014

28 Brogaard, J., "High Frequency Trading and Extreme Price Movements" 30 : 253-265, 2016

29 Cvitanic, J., "High Frequency Traders and Asset Prices"

30 Mahani, R., "Financial Speculators’ Underperformance : Learning, Self-selection, and Endogeneous Liquidity" 12 : 1313-1340, 2007

31 Biais B., "Equilibrium Fast Trading" 116 (116): 292-313, 2015

32 Malinova, K., "Do Retail Investor Suffer from High Frequency Traders?" 12 : 1313-1340, 2007

33 Nicolosi, G., "Do Individual Investors Learn From Their Trading Experience?" 12 : 317-336, 2009

34 Hirschey, N., "Do High-Frequency Traders Anticipate Buying and Selling Pressure?" 67 (67): 3321-3345, 2021

35 Van Kervel, V., "Competition for Order Flow with Fast and Slow Traders" 28 (28): 2094-2127, 2015

36 Hendershott, T., "Algorithmic Trading and Market for Liquidity" 48 : 1001-1024, 2013

37 Hoffmann, P., "A Dynamic Limit Order Market with Fast and Slow Traders" 113 (113): 156-169, 2014