Clinical Reasons for Returning Hearing Aids

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Background and Objectives: Increases in older aged populations and exposure to complicated noise environments have increased the number of hearing-impaired patients, creating greater demands for hearing aids. We have assessed the reasons that individuals rejected wearing and returned properly prescribed hearing aids, as well as differences in individual factors between younger and elderly adults. Subjects and Methods: Of 1138 patients for whom hearing aids were prescribed at Kyung Hee University Medical Center Hearing Aid Clinic, 81 (6.14%) returned their hearing aids, including 36 patients aged ＜65 years and 45 aged ≥65 years. Patient-related, hearing-related, and hearing aid-related factors were assessed by retrospective chart analysis and phone survey and compared in the two groups. Results: The primary symptoms reported by the 81 patients who returned their hearing aids were hearing disturbance, ringing, and fullness in the ear, in that order and in both groups. The rate of hearing aid return was similar in elderly females and males (p=0.288). The spondee recognition threshold was significantly higher in younger than in elderly adults (63.3±14.0 dB vs. 55.6±14.74 dB, p=0.019), but the hearing aid return rate was highest in patients with moderate hearing loss in both groups. In evaluating the reasons for return of hearing aids, we found that ineffectiveness of the device was the most frequent reason, accounting for 32.0% of returns, the highest percentage in both groups, with the most frequent patient problem caused by management difficulty in elderly and financial difficulty in younger adults. Conclusions: The reasons for hearing aid return were different in two groups. Financial considerations were cited more by younger adults, while difficulties in managing hearing aids were cited more frequently by elderly adults. Patients in both groups, however, reported that the most frequent reasons for return were inadequate hearing improvement and inconvenience wearing the hearing aid due to noise amplification.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Brooks DN., "The time course of adaptation to hearing aid use" 30 : 55-62, 1996

2 Ministry of Health and Welfare., "The result of disability survey 2011" Ministry of Health and Welfare

3 Korea Centers for Disease Control and Prevention., "The Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 2009" Korea Centers for Disease Control and Prevention 2011

4 Storm K., "The Hearing Review. Annual review of the hearing aid industry" Allied Media 2013

5 Yun DH., "Subjective satisfaction in hearing aid users by APHAB" 43 : 698-702, 2000

6 Statistics Korea., "Statistics for the elderly 2012" Statistics Korea

7 Wilson C., "Reasons for referral and attitudes toward hearing aids : do they affect outcome?" 28 : 81-84, 2003

8 조양선, "Prevalence of Otolaryngologic Diseases in South Korea: Data from the Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 2008" 대한이비인후과학회 3 (3): 183-193, 2010

9 Kochkin, S, "MarkeTrak VIII: Why consumers return hearing aids: A guide for reducing hearing aid returns" Better Hearing Institute 2012

10 Beamer SL., "Hearing aid benefit in patients with high-frequency hearing loss" 11 : 429-437, 2000

11 Warland A., "Factors to consider when in-the-canal hearing instruments are used in aural rehabilitation" 22 : 47-55, 1993

12 Hüls R., "Der Markt für Hörsysteme" Innocentia-Verlag 2004

13 Mulrow CD., "Correlates of successful hearing aid use in older adults" 13 : 108-113, 1992

14 Hosford-Dunn H., "Clinical application of the SADL scale in private practice II : predictive validity of fitting variables. Satisfaction with Amplification in Daily Life" 12 : 15-36, 2001

15 나우성, "Active Noise Cancelling 이어폰이 소음환경에서 선호청취음량에 미치는 영향" 대한이비인후과학회 55 (55): 415-421, 2012

16 Korea Research Institute for Local Administration., "A study on share and management system of welfare finance for aged society" Korea Research Institute for Local Administration

17 Chae SW., "A review of age-related hearing loss" 54 : 908-909, 2011