Perceived color shift of ceramics according to the change of illuminating light with spectroradiometer

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

PURPOSE. Perceived color of ceramics changes by the spectral power distribution of ambient light. This study aimed to quantify the amount of shifts in color and color coordinates of clinically simulated seven all-ceramics due to the switch of three ambient light sources using a human vision simulating spectroradiometer. MATERIALS AND METHODS. CIE color coordinates, such as L*, a* and b*,of ceramic specimens were measured under three light sources, which simulate the CIE standard illuminant D65 (daylight), A (incandescent lamp), and F9 (fluorescent lamp). Shifts in color and color coordinate by the switch of lights were determined. Influence of the switched light (D65 to A, or D65 to F9), shade of veneer ceramics (A2 or A3), and brand of ceramics on the shifts was analyzed by a three-way ANOVA. RESULTS. Shifts in color and color coordinates were influenced by three factors (P<.05). Color shifts by the switch to A were in the range of 5.9 to 7.7 ΔE*abunits, and those by the switch to F9 were 7.7 to 10.2; all of which were unacceptable (ΔE*ab > 5.5). When switched to A, CIE a* increased (Δa*: 5.6 to 7.6), however, CIE b* increased (Δb*: 4.9 to 7.8) when switched to F9. CONCLUSION. Clinically simulated ceramics demonstrated clinically unacceptable color shifts according to the switches in ambient lights based on spectroradiometric readings. Therefore, shade matching and compatibility evaluation should be performed considering ambient lighting conditions and should be done under most relevant lighting condition.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Lee YK, "Variation in instrument-based color coordinates of esthetic restorative materials by measurement method-A review" 26 : 1098-1105, 2010

2 Marcus RT, "The measurement of color, In Color for science, art and technology" Elsevier 48-49, 1998

3 Carsten DL, "Successful shade matching--what does it take" 24 : 175-182, 2003

4 Ishikawa-Nagai S, "Spectrophotometric analysis of tooth color reproduction on anterior all-ceramic crowns: Part 1: analysis and interpretation of tooth color" 22 : 42-52, 2010

5 Gokce HS, "Shade matching performance of normal and color vision-deficient dental professionals with standard daylight and tungsten illuminants" 103 : 139-147, 2010

6 Heffernan MJ, "Relative translucency of six all-ceramic systems. Part I: core materials" 88 : 4-9, 2002

7 Anusavice K, "Philips’' science of dental materials" Saunders 655-719, 2003

8 Lee YK, "Perceived color shift of a shade guide according to the change of illuminant" 105 : 91-99, 2011

9 Volpato CA, "Optical influence of the type of illuminant, substrates and thickness of ceramic materials" 25 : 87-93, 2009

10 O’'Brien WJ, "One-dimensional color order system for dental shade guides" 5 : 371-374, 1989

11 Lee YK, "Metameric effect between resin composite and dentin" 2 : 971-976, 2005

12 Corcodel N, "Metameric effect between natural teeth and the shade tabs of a shade guide" 118 : 311-316, 2010

13 Kim SH, "Metameric effect between dental porcelain and porcelain repairing resin composite" 23 : 374-379, 2007

14 Ferreira D, "Measurement of spectral reflectance and colorimetric properties of Vita shade guides" 46 : 63-65, 1991

15 Lee YK, "Lightness, chroma, and hue distributions of a shade guide as measured by a spectroradiometer" 104 : 173-181, 2010

16 Lee YK, "Layered color of all-ceramic core and veneer ceramics" 97 : 279-286, 2007

17 Douglas RD, "Intraoral determination of the tolerance of dentists for perceptibility and acceptability of shade mismatch" 97 : 200-208, 2007

18 Bolt RA, "Influence of window size in small-window color measurements, particularly of teeth" 39 : 1133-1142, 1994

19 Park JH, "Influence of illuminants on the color distribution of shade guides" 96 : 402-411, 2006

20 Li Q, "In vivo spectroradiometric evaluation of colour matching errors among five shade guides" 36 : 65-70, 2009

21 Yap AU, "Human-eye versus computerized color matching" 24 : 358-363, 1999

22 Zhang Y, "Graded zirconia glass for resistance to veneer fracture" 89 : 1057-1062, 2010

23 Lehmann KM, "Four color-measuring devices compared with a spectrophotometric reference system" 38 (38): 65-70, 2010

24 Barão VA, "Factors to achieve aesthetics in all-ceramic restorations" 21 : 2007-2012, 2010

25 Gozalo-Diaz D, "Estimating the color of maxillary central incisors based on age and gender" 100 : 93-98, 2008

26 Lee YK, "Effects of colour measuring mode and light source on the colour of shade guides" 29 : 1099-1107, 2002

27 Cha HS, "Difference in illuminant-dependent color changes of shade guide tabs by the shade designation relative to three illuminants" 22 : 350-356, 2009

28 Bayindir F, "Coverage error of gingival shade guide systems in measuring color of attached anterior gingiva" 101 : 46-53, 2009

29 Kim JG, "Correlations between color differences based on three color-difference formulas using dental shade guide tabs" 18 : 135-140, 2009

30 Rosenstiel SF, "Contemporary fixed prothodontics" Mosby 774-, 2006

31 "Commission Internationale de l’'Eclairage (CIE) Colorimetry-technical report" Bureau Central de la CIE 2004

32 Wyszecki G, "Color science - Concepts and methods, quantitative data and formulae" John Wiley and Sons 2000

33 Vichi A, "Color related to ceramic and zirconia restorations: a review" 27 : 97-108, 2011

34 Davis S, "Color perception - philosophical, psychological, artistic, and cognitive perspectives" Oxford University Press 88-90, 2000

35 Paravina RD, "Color interaction of dental materials: blending effect of layered composites" 22 : 903-908, 2006

36 Ghinea R, "Color difference thresholds in dental ceramics" 38 (38): 57-64, 2010

37 Lee YK, "Color difference of four esthetic restorative materials by the illuminant" 18 : 359-363, 2005

38 Yu B, "Color difference of all-ceramic materials by the change of illuminants" 22 : 73-78, 2009

39 Lee YK, "Color characteristics of low-chroma and high-translucence dental resin composites by different measuring modes" 58 : 613-621, 2001

40 Barnes D, "Clinical evaluation of an all-ceramic restorative system: a 36-month clinical evaluation" 23 : 87-92, 2010

41 Johnston WM, "Analysis of edge-losses in reflectance measurements of pigmented maxillofacial elastomer" 75 : 752-760, 1996

42 van der Burgt TP, "A new method for matching tooth colors with color standards" 64 : 837-841, 1985

43 van der Burgt TP, "A comparison of new and conventional methods for quantification of tooth color" 63 : 155-162, 1990

44 Judeh A, "A comparison between conventional visual and spectrophotometric methods for shade selection" Quintessence Int 40 : 69-79, 2009