전자의무기록 데이터의 이차활용을 위한 구조화된 데이터 질에 대한 탐색 = Assessing the Quality of Structured Data Entry for the Secondary Use of Electronic Medical Records

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Objective: The raw material of quality improvement is information, whose building block is data. Data in an electronic medical record system have many secondary uses beyond their primary role in patient care, including research and organizational management. This study investigates the data quality of clinical observations recorded using a structured data entry format and assesses the impact of erroneous data. Methods: A total of 4,580,846 input events from 3,348 inpatients, gathered over a three year period in a teaching hospital, were analyzed by using a 2-by-2 conceptual matrix framework for the appropriateness of data types and semantics. The data were classified into three categories: fully usable, partially usable, and not usable. Results: The fully usable data constituted 88.6% of the correctly entered data the remaining 11.4% were erroneous. Among the erroneous data, 0.8% were partially usable (n=3,929), and the remaining 99.2% (n= 510,437) were identified as needing further assessment to improve their quality. Conclusion: Clinical information systems have increasingly used structured data entry or record templates, but the low quality of collected data has severely limited their secondary use potential.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 신아미, "종이의무기록과 전자의무기록의 기재정도 및 일치도 비교 연구: 심방세동 환자 입원기록을 중심으로" 대한의료정보학회 15 (15): 201-208, 2009

2 조인숙, "욕창발생 예측도구 개발을 위한 전자간호기록데이터 이용 가능성" 대한의료정보학회 14 (14): 161-168, 2008

3 Dresselhaus TR, "The ethical problem of false positives: a prospective evaluation of physician reporting in the medical record" 28 (28): 291-294, 2002

4 Thiru K, "Systematic review of scope and quality of electronic patient record data in primary care" 326 (326): 1070-, 2003

5 Lee KN, "Standardization of reference values among laboratories of Korean Association of Health Promotion" 24 : 185-195, 2002

6 Lewis SM, "Medical and surgical nursing. 6th ed" Mosby 1758-1795, 204

7 Ricketts D, "Markers of data quality in computer audit: the Manchester Orthopaedic Database" 75 (75): 393-396, 1993

8 Tang PC, "Electronic Health Record Systems. in: Biomedical Informatics: computer applications in health care and biomedicine. 3rd ed" Springer science and business media 447-475, 2006

9 Porcheret M, "Data quality of general practice electronic health records: the impact of a program of assessments, feedback, and training" 11 (11): 78-86, 2004

10 Witten IH, "Data Mining: practical machine learning tools and techniques with Java implementations" Academic Press 48-56, 2000

11 Brown C, "Computer-based data collection boosts productivity, regulatory compliance" 35 (35): 40B-40D, 2004

12 Kim J, "Clinical chemistry. 3rd ed" Korea Medicine Book Publisher 71-72, 2001

13 Dambro M, "Assessing the quality of data entry in a computerized medical records system" 12 (12): 181-187, 1988

14 Vawdrey DK, "Assessing data quality in manual entry of ventilator settings" 14 (14): 295-303, 2007

15 De Lusignan S, "An educational intervention to improve data recording in the management of ischaemic heart disease in primary care" 26 (26): 34-37, 2004

16 Bloomrosen M, "Advancing the framework: use of health data-a report of a working conference of the American medical informatics association" 15 (15): 715-722, 2008

17 Fayyad UM, "Advances in knowledge discovery and data mining. Califormia" American Association for Artificial Intelligence and MIT Press 48-51, 1996

18 Hogan WR, "Accuracy of data in computer-based patient records" 4 (4): 342-355, 1997

19 Fortinsky R, "A two-phase study of the reliability of computerized morbidity data" 13 : 229-235, 1981

20 Stange K, "A comparison of US and Canadian family physician attitudes toward their respective health-care systems" 34 (34): 837-844, 1996