부동산 신탁 관련 재산세 및 부가가치세 검토

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This thesis reviews the real estate tax and VAT issues on real estate trust. (1) Recently, the Local Tax Law revised the tax payment obligator of trust as trustee from truster. Trust companies have been objected on that tax revision, because it is not conformable to the Conduit Theory of trust and can generate several inconvenience to them. (2) Regarding trusts which have collateral function, tax authority interprets the VAT law as follows. ① When actual controlling power is transferred to beneficiary, VAT will be imposed to truster, ② When trusted properties are sold out, VAT will be imposed to beneficiary. Such interpretation, however, loses fairness comparing with mortgage. This thesis concludes (1) regarding real estate tax, it is not desirable to revise tax obligator again, but it is necessary to levy joint and several liability for real estate tax to truster, (2) regarding VAT, it is necessary to consider fairness on taxation between mortgage and collateral trust, and based on that consideration, we can conclude the transfer of real controlling power is irrelevant with VAT taxation and truster only can be taxed when trusted property is sold out.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 장승희, "지방세 개정에 따른 부동산신탁사 실무처리 방안에 관한 연구 - 재산세를 중심으로" 대한부동산학회 33 (33): 169-186, 2015

2 김성남, "일본 신탁제도와 우리나라 신탁제도의 비교" 4 (4): 2013

3 백승재, "신탁재산의 관리처분상 부가가치세 납세의무자(대법원 2003.4.25.선고 2003다33,34,99다59290판결)"

4 한원식, "신탁소득의 납세의무자에 대한 연구" 한국세법학회 19 (19): 245-282, 2013

5 이재호, "신탁부동산의 양도와 부가가치세법상 납세의무자" 법학연구소 13 (13): 797-830, 2012

6 이중교, "신탁법상의 신탁에 관한 과세상 논점" 법조협회 58 (58): 318-359, 2009

7 신영수, "신탁 과세제도 체계화 방안-신탁재산의 보유세 중심으로-" 2016

8 김성균, "수익증권발행신탁 세제" 중앙법학회 16 (16): 241-308, 2014

9 마정화, "부동산신탁에 관한 합리적인 지방세 과세방안" 한국지방세연구원 2017

10 김성균, "부동산신탁관련 취득세 등 납세의무자 검토" 중앙법학회 17 (17): 123-148, 2015

11 김성균, "開發信託 관련 租稅債權을 원인채권으로 하는 信託財産에 대한 押留" 중앙법학회 13 (13): 319-348, 2011

12 金子 宏, "信託税制の体系的研究-制度と解釈-" 財団法人日本税理研究センター 2011

13 三陵UFJ信託銀行, "信託の法務と実務" 社団法人金融財政事情研究会 2008