Academic inbreeding: exploring its characteristics and rationale in Japanese universities using a qualitative perspective

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study analyses why and how academic inbreeding as a recruitment practice continues to prevail in Japan, a country with a mature higher education system, where high rates of academic inbreeding endure in most of the research-oriented universities in spite of several higher education reforms. Based on a qualitative analysis, we disclose three characteristics that lead academics to become inbred at Japanese universities. One characteristic-the adoption of "open recruitment processes" in detriment of "closed recruitment processes"—changed over time, limiting academic inbreeding practices, but two other characteristics remained unchanged over time: the "one university learning experience" and the "concentration of doctoral supervisors at the same university". These latter characteristics represent difficult challenges to be tackled as they are also traditional characteristics of the Japanese higher education system. The research also shows that academic inbreeding practices are a means to assure organizational stability and institutional identity, features perceived as important by Japanese universities. A central challenge for the Japanese universities is then to guarantee these features without needing to rely on academic inbreeding practices to obtain them. However, devising policies to meet this challenge calls for institutional will to change, proactive strategies and time.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 European Commission, "White paper on education and learning—towards the learning society" COM 590-, 1995

2 Cummings, W. K., "Understanding behavior in Japan’s academic marketplace" 34 : 313-340, 1975

3 Reeves, F. W., "The university faculty" The University of Chicago 1933

4 Cummings, W., "The changing role of the Japanese professor, In Comparative perspectives on the academic profession" Praeger 61-62, 1977

5 Altbach, P. G., "The changing academic workplace: Comparative perspectives" Boston College Center for International Higher Education 2000

6 Wilson, L., "The academic man" Oxford University Press 1942

7 Shimbori, M., "The Japanese academic profession" 10 : 75-87, 1981

8 Hirsch, F., "Social limits to growth" Harvard University Press 1976

9 Pelz, D. C., "Scientists in organizations" Wiley 1966

10 Barnett, R., "Realizing the university in an age of supercomplexity" Open University Press 2000

11 Birnbaum, R., "Professor and Sensei: The construction of faculty roles in the United States and Japan" 71-92, 2005

12 March, J. G., "Parochialism in the evolution of a research community: The case of organization studies" 1 : 5-22, 2004

13 Yamanoi, A., "Nippon no Daigaku Kyojyu Shijyo (Academic Marketplace in Japan)" Tamagawa University press 2007

14 Seki, M., "Nihon no daigaku kyouiku kaikaku (University Education Reform in Japan)" Tamagawa University Press 1995

15 Shin, J. C., "New challenges for higher education: global and Asia-Pacific perspectives" 교육연구소 10 (10): 1-13, 2009

16 Horta, H., "Navel grazing: Academic inbreeding and scientific productivity" 56 (56): 414-429, 2010

17 Nowotny, H., "Mode 2’ revisited: The new production of knowledge" 41 : 179-194, 2003

18 Simon, C. J., "Matchmaker, matchmaker: The effect of old boy networks on Job match quality, earnings, and tenure" 10 (10): 306-330, 1992

19 Yonezawa, A., "Japanese flagship universities at a crossroads" 54 : 483-499, 2007

20 Seidman, I., "Interviewing as qualitative research: A guide for researchers in education and the social sciences" Columbia University Press 1998

21 Wyer, J. C., "Institutional inbreeding reexamined" 21 (21): 213-225, 1984

22 Eisenberg, T., "Inbreeding in law school hiring: Assessing the performance of faculty hired from within" 29 (29): 369-388, 2000

23 Hawkins, J. N., "Higher education reform in Japan: The tension between public good and commodification" 1 (1): 164-173, 2008

24 Berelson, B., "Graduate education in the United States" McGraw-Hill 1960

25 Oba, J., "Governance reform of national universities in Japan: Transition to corporate status and challenges" 6 (6): 45-86, 2007

26 Cummings, W. K., "From knowledge seeking to knowledge creation: The Japanese University’s Challenge" 27 (27): 399-415, 1994

27 McNeely, J. H., "Faculty inbreeding in land-grant colleges and universities" Office of Education 1932

28 Massengale, J. D., "Departmental prestige and career mobility patterns of college physical educators" 53 (53): 305-312, 1982

29 Roebken, H., "Departmental networks—an empirical analysis of career patterns among junior faculty in Germany" 54 : 99-113, 2007

30 Ishii, M., "Daigaku Kyoin: Yosei Keikaku naki Senmon Shoku (University teachers: A profession without fostering plan), In Senmonshoku Yosei no Nihonteki Kozo (Japanese Model in Professional Education)" Tamagawa University Press 2009

31 Laudel, G., "Collaboration, creativity and rewards: Why and how scientists collaborate" 22 (22): 762-781, 2001

32 Arimoto, A., "Changing academic profession in the World from 1992 to 2007" 2009

33 Ogawa, I., "Challenging the traditional organization of Japanese universities" 43 : 85-108, 2002

34 Hargens, L. L., "An examination of recent hypotheses about institutional inbreeding" 78 (78): 1381-1402, 1973

35 Bedeian, A. G., "Academic stratification in graduate management programs: Departmental prestige and faculty hiring patterns" 6 (6): 99-115, 1980

36 Enders, J., "Academic staff in Europe: Changing contexts and conditions" Greenwood Press 2001

37 Henkel, M., "Academic identity and autonomy in a changing policy environment" 49 (49): 155-176, 2005

38 Heath, T., "A quantitative analysis of PhD students’ views of supervision" 21 (21): 41-53, 2002