판례평석 방법론에 관한 시론적 고찰 - 민사법 분야를 중심으로 = Methods of Commentary on Judgement

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

  The legal system in Korea mainly consists of statutes. But, precedents are regarded as a essential component of Korean legal system. Precedents have enriched contents of law and developed law. Now precedents play an important part in law and legal science in civil-law system as well as in common-law system.<BR>  It is commentary on judgement that analyses the content of precedents and evaluates correctness/reasonableness of precedents. Commentary functions like a bridge that connects between precedents and legal doctrines. Precedents remain live through commentaries on the precedents. Commentary on judgement will provide legal scholars and practioners with the common forum of legal studies.<BR>  Each country has its own method of commentary on judgement related to legal systems, legal institution and legal culture at various levels. Above all, there is an indissoluble connection between commentary on judgement and the status of precedents in legal system concerned. The different status of precedents in each legal system demands for different method of commentary on judgement. Secondarily, commentaries on judgement are connected with the objects, the contents, the structures and the styles of judicial judgements. Commentaries on judgement, furthermore, are connected with openness of judgement and access to judgement, the interrelation between precedents and legal doctrines, the realities of legislation, the legal sentiment, the legal consciousness.<BR>  So, it is necessary to investigate into the structure, procedure and function of judiciary system as well as the status of precedents, the style of judgement in order to advance a theory of commentary on judgement. Then the complete standard model of commentary on judgement can be presented.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Ⅰ. 들어가는 말
  Ⅱ. 판례평석 일반론
  Ⅲ. 우리나라 판례평석의 현황 : 민사법 분야를 중심으로
  Ⅳ. 우리나라 판례평석의 구조와 그 한계
  Ⅴ. 새로운 판례평석 방법론의 모색
  〈판례평석의 표준모델〉
  【참고문헌】
  【Abstract】
  

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 "판례의 형성과정 민사판례연구" 박영사 330-, 1979

2 "판례연구의 중점변천" 1974.3.4/11.

3 "판례연구의 목적 민사판례연구" 박영사 370-, 1979

4 "판례연구와 법학교육 민사판례연구" 박영사 1979

5 "판례법의 법원성" 박영사 1-26, 1996

6 "판결서 글쓰기에 관한 몇 가지 생각들" 14 : 372-411, 2005

7 "법획득방법의 기본구조에서 본 법학과 법실무" 법문사 263-277, 2001

8 "민사판례연구" 대법원ㆍ대법원판결 박영사 391-, 1979

9 "민사판결서의 간이화" 법문사 277-279, 1999

10 "대법원전원합의체재판에 있어서의 의견의 표시 사실심과 법률심" 한국사법행정학회 680-, 1994

11 "民法硏究 Handbook" 有斐閣 2000.

12 "Legal Institutions and the Sources of Law" Springer 2005.

13 "Interpreting Precedents" Ashgate 1997.

14 "Einfhrung in das juristische Denken" 1977.