Systematic Review of Sustainable Knowledge Transfer Process in Government-Industry-Academia Consortium

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The purpose of this case study is to understand the sustainability practices of knowledge transfer process at the Malaysian government-industry-academia consortium. At this stage in the research, the R&D consortium is defined as an established entity by two or more organizations that pool resources and shared decision making for cooperative research and development activities. In attempts to understand the formation, outcomes and sustainability of the sustainable knowledge transfer process, this paper conducted a systematic literature review based on Gough, Oliver and Thomas systematic reviews protocol. From the review, the data were enriched and enhanced with a better understanding of sustainable knowledge transfer process. The systematic review resulted in identifying six factors including internal and external perspectives. However, key sustainability factors are not only directly influencing KTP, and the consortium, but are also mediated by other organisational variables.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Branstetter, L.G., "When do research consortia work well and why? evidence from Japanese panel data" 92 (92): 143-159, 2002

2 Starik, M., "Weaving an integrated web: multilevel and multisystem perspectives of ecologically sustainable organizations" 20 (20): 908-935, 1995

3 Ankrah, S., "Universities-industry collaboration: A systematic review" 31 (31): 387-408, 2015

4 Akobeng, A.K., "Understanding Systematic Reviews and Meta-analysis" 90 : 845-848, 2005

5 Lin, R.J., "Turning knowledge management into innovation in the high-tech industry" 112 (112): 42-63, 2012

6 Ranga, M., "Triple helix systems: An analytical framework for innovation policy and practice in the knowledge society" 27 : 237-262, 2013

7 Hagedoorn, J., "Trends and patterns in strategic technology partnering since the early seventies" 11 (11): 601-616, 1996

8 Wood, D.J., "Towards a comprehensive theory of collaboration" 27 (27): 139-162, 1991

9 Du Plessis, M., "The role of knowledge management in innovation" 11 (11): 20-29, 2007

10 Shrivastava, P., "The role of corporations in achieving ecological sustainability" 20 (20): 936-960, 1995

11 Eisenhardt, K.M., "The resource-based view of strategic alliance formation: strategic and social effects in entrepreneurial firms" 7 (7): 136-150, 1996

12 Lin, Z., "The performance consequences of ambidexterity in strategic alliance formations: Empirical investigation and computational theorizing" 53 (53): 1645-1658, 2007

13 Mathews, J.A., "The origins and dynamics of Taiwan's R&D consortia" 31 (31): 633-651, 2002

14 Jovane, F., "The incoming global technological and industrial revolution towards competitive, sustainable manufacturing" 57 (57): 641-659, 2008

15 Kaufmann, J., "The impact of structural prescriptions on joint venture survival" 21 (21): 43-60, 2006

16 Dodgson, M., "The evolving nature of research consortia in East Asia, Innovation: Management" 8 (8): 84-101, 2006

17 Koza, M.P., "The co-evolution of strategic alliances" 9 (9): 255-264, 1998

18 O'Reilly, C.A., "The ambidextrous organization" 74-81, 2004

19 Savitz, A.W., "The Triple Bottom Line" Jossey-Bass 2006

20 Erlich, P.R., "The Population Explosion" Touchstone 1991

21 Powell, W., "The Oxford Handbook of Innovation" Oxford University Press 56-85, 2005

22 Duncan, R.B., "The Management of the Organisation, (1)" North-Holland 167-188, 1976

23 Burns, T., "The Management of Innovation" Tavistock 1961

24 Koza, M.P., "The Coevolution of Network Alliances: A longitudinal analysis of an international professional service network" 10 (10): 638-653, 1999

25 Siggelkow, N., "Temporarily divide to conquer: centralized, decentralized, and reintegrated organizational approach to exploration and adaptation" 14 (14): 650-669, 2003

26 Ambrosio, E.M., "Technology management and transfer of technology" 10 (10): 665-675, 1995

27 Novak, L., "Technology Transfer in Consortia and Strategic Alliances" Rownman and Littlefield Publisher, Inc 1992

28 McGowan, J., "Systematic reviews need systematic searchers" 93 (93): 74-80, 2005

29 Zelaya-Zamora, J., "Synthesizing seeming incompatibilities to foster knowledge creation and innovation" 17 (17): 106-122, 2013

30 Sikdar, S.K., "Sustainable development and sustainability metrics" 49 (49): 1928-1932, 2003

31 Hill, M.R., "Sustainability, greenhouse gas emissions, and international operations management" 21 (21): 1503-1520, 2001

32 Floyd, S., "Strategizing throughout the organisation: Managing role conflict in strategic renewal" 25 (25): 154-177, 2000

33 Kennedy, A., "Strategic partnerships and the internationalisation process of software SMEs" 3 (3): 259-273, 2009

34 Nielsen, B.B., "Strategic fit, contractual, and procedural governance in alliances" 63 (63): 682-689, 2010

35 Todeva, E., "Strategic alliances and models of collaboration" 43 (43): 123-148, 2005

36 Mowery, D.C., "Strategic alliances and interfirm knowledge transfer" 17 : 77-91, 1996

37 Roelofsen, A., "Stakeholder interaction within research consortia on emerging technologies: Learning how and what?" 40 (40): 341-354, 2011

38 Vedovello, C., "Science parks and university-industry interaction: geographical proximity between the agents as a driving force" 17 (17): 491-531, 1997

39 Mothe, C., "Resource creation and partnership in R&D consortia" 12 (12): 113-138, 2001

40 Hagedoorn, J., "Research partnerships" 29 (29): 567-586, 2000

41 Fiorino, D., "Regulatory policy and the consensus trap: An agency perspective" 19 : 64-76, 1997

42 Spangenberg, J.H., "Reconciling sustainability and growth: criteria, indicators, policies" 12 (12): 74-86, 2004

43 Argyres, N.S., "R&D, organisation structure, and the development of corporate technological knowledge" 25 (25): 929-958, 2004

44 Aldrich, H.E., "R&D consortia in the United States and Japan" 24 (24): 301-316, 1995

45 Whitley, R., "Project-based firms: New organisational form or variations on a theme?" 15 : 77-99, 2006

46 Boot, M.W.M, "Professional assistance in implementing school health policies" 110 (110): 294-308, 2010

47 Parkhe, A., "Partner nationality and the structure-performance relationship in strategic alliances" 4 (4): 301-324, 1993

48 World Commission on Environment and Development, "Our Common Future" Oxford University Press 1987

49 Rhea, J., "New directions for industrial R&D Consortia" 34 (34): 16-26, 1991

50 Schnaars, S., "Megamistakes: Forecasting and the Myth of Rapid Technological Change" The Free Press 1989

51 Autio, E., "Measurement and evaluation of technology transfer: review of technology transfer mechanisms and indicators" 10 (10): 643-664, 1995

52 Sarkis, J., "Manufacturing’s role in corporate environmental sustainability" 21 (21): 666-686, 2001

53 Koza, M.P., "Managing partnerships and strategic alliances: raising the odds of success" 18 (18): 146-151, 2000

54 Buchel, B., "Managing partner relations in joint ventures" 44 (44): 91-95, 2003

55 Shu, C. L., "Managerial ties and firm innovation: Is knowledge creation a missing link?" 29 (29): 125-143, 2012

56 Stead, E., "Management for a Small Planet: Strategic Decision Making and the Environment" SAGE 1996

57 Cusurnano, M.A., "Linking international technology transfer with strategy and management: a literature commentary" 23 (23): 195-215, 1994

58 Iacono, M. P., "Knowledge creation and inter-organisational relationships: the development of innovation in the railway industry" 16 (16): 604-616, 2012

59 Scheirer, M.A., "Is sustainability possible? A review and commentary on empirical studies of program sustainability" 26 (26): 320-347, 2005

60 Baum, J.A.C., "Institutional linkages and organizational mortality" 36 (36): 2187-2218, 1991

61 Mitchell, W., "Incumbents’ use of pre-entry alliances before expansion into new technical subfields of an industry" 18 (18): 347-372, 1992

62 Rothaermel, F.T., "Incumbent's advantage through exploiting complementary assets Via Interfirm cooperation" 22 (22): 687-699, 2001

63 Goncz, E., "Increasing the rate of sustainable change: a call for a redefinition of the concept and the model for its implementation" 15 (15): 525-537, 2007

64 Boot, M.W.M., "Implementation of school health promotion: consequences for professional assistance" 112 (112): 436-447, 2012

65 Zhou, K.Z., "How knowledge affects radical innovation: knowledge base, market knowledge acquisition, and internal knowledge sharing" 33 (33): 1090-1102, 2012

66 Villani, E., "How intermediary organizations facilitate university-industry technology transfer: A proximity approach" 114 : 86-102, 2017

67 Dixon-Woods, M., "How can systematic reviews incorporate qualitative research? A critical perspective" 6 : 27-44, 2006

68 Sakakibara, M., "Formation of R&D consortia: industry and company effects" 23 (23): 1033-1050, 2002

69 Eisner, A.B., "Formation conditions, innovation, and learning in R&D consortia" 47 (47): 851-871, 2009

70 Doz, Y. L., "Formation Processes of R&D Consortia: Which Path to Take? Where Does It Lead?" 21 (21): 239-266, 2000

71 Lal, R., "Food Security and Environmental Quality in the Developing World" CRC Press 2002

72 Lind, F., "Exploring university-industry collaboration in research centres" 16 (16): 70-91, 2013

73 Kamps, X., "Exploring standards consortium survival in high tech industries: The effects of commitment and internal competition" 52 : 105-113, 2016

74 Szulanski, G., "Exploring internal stickiness: impediments to the transfer of best practice within the firm" 17 : 27-43, 1996

75 He, Z.L., "Exploration vs exploitation: an empirical test of the ambidexterity hypothesis" 15 (15): 481-494, 2004

76 Rothaermel, F.T., "Exploration and exploitation alliances in biotechnology: a system of new product development" 25 (25): 201-221, 2004

77 Darroch, J., "Examining the link between knowledge management practices and types of innovation" 3 (3): 210-222, 2002

78 Gresov, C., "Equifinality: Functional equivalence in organisation design" 22 : 403-428, 1997

79 Ahuja, G., "Entrepreneurship in the large corporation: a longitudinal study of how established firms create breakthrough inventions" 22 (22): 521-543, 2001

80 Spaeth, S., "Enabling knowledge creation through outsiders: towards a push model of open innovation" 52 (52): 411-431, 2010

81 Jennings, P.D., "Ecologically sustainable organisations: an institutional approach" 20 (20): 1015-1052, 1995

82 Whiteman, G., "Ecological embeddedness" 43 (43): 1265-1282, 2000

83 Azagra-Caroa, J.M, "Dynamic interactions between university-industry knowledge transfer channels: A case study of the most highly cited academic patent" 46 : 463-474, 2017

84 Boland, A., "Doing a systematic review: a student's guide" SAGE Publications 2008

85 Nawaz, W., "Development of a systematic framework for sustainability management of organizations" 171 : 1255-1274, 2018

86 Al-Ali, S., "Developing countries and technology transfer" 10 (10): 704-713, 1995

87 Pinto, P. E., "DRUID Society Conference: Innovation, Strategy, and Structure"

88 Mothe, C., "Creating competencies through collaboration: The case of EUREKA R&D consortia" 18 (18): 590-604, 2000

89 Spence, M., "Cost reduction, competition, and industry performance" 52 (52): 101-121, 1984

90 Leonard-Barton, D., "Core capabilities and core rigidities: A paradox in managing new product development" 13 : 111-125, 1992

91 Hill, C., "Cooperation, opportunism, and the invisible hand" 15 (15): 500-514, 1990

92 Alic, J.A., "Cooperation in R&D" 10 (10): 319-332, 1990

93 Schiele, H., "Consortium benchmarking: collaborative academic-practitioner case study research" 64 (64): 1137-1145, 2011

94 Porter, M.E., "Competitive Strategy" Free Press 1980

95 Jansen, J.J.P., "Combining competence building and leveraging: Managing paradoxes in ambidextrous organisations" 10 : 99-119, 2008

96 Miotti, L., "Co-operative R&D: why and with whom? An integrated framework of analysis" 32 (32): 1481-1499, 2003

97 World Bank, "Clusters for Competitiveness, A Practical Guide and Policy mplications for Developing Cluster Initiatives"

98 Porter, M.E., "Clusters and the new economics of competition" 77-90, 1998

99 Miles, R.E., "Causes of failure in network organizations" 34 (34): 53-72, 1992

100 Elkington, J., "Cannibals with Forks: The Triple Bottom Line of the 21st Century" New Society Publishers 1998

101 Rao, S.Y., "C5 model for the consortium management: SWOT analysis" 38 (38): 248-262, 2017

102 Srinivasa Rao, Y., "C5 model for the consortium management: SWOT analysis" 38 (38): 248-262, 2017

103 Rosenkopf, L., "Beyond local search: boundary-spanning, exploration, and impact in the optical disk industry" 22 (22): 287-306, 2001

104 Lavie, D., "Balancing exploration and exploitation in alliance formation" 49 (49): 797-818, 2006

105 Shan, W., "An empirical analysis of organisational strategies by entrepreneurial high-technology firms" 11 (11): 129-139, 1990

106 Gough, D., "An Introduction to Sytematic Reviews" SAGE Publications 2012

107 Tushman, M., "Ambidextrous organizations: managing evolutionary and revolutionary change" 38 (38): 1996

108 Gulati, R., "Alliances and networks" 19 (19): 293-317, 1998

109 Daily, B.F., "Achieving sustainability through attention to human resource factors in environmental management" 21 (21): 1539-1552, 2001

110 Hart, S.L., "A natural-resource-based view of the firm" 20 (20): 986-1014, 1995

111 Carter, C.R., "A framework of sustainable supply chain management: moving toward new theory" 38 (38): 360-387, 2008

112 Copani, G., "A Structured Methodology for Business Network Design"