임상분야와 임상경력에 따른 임상추론의 인지적 방식에 관한 선행 연구 = A Pilot Study on Cognitive Styles in Clinical Reasoning Based on Clinical Specialty and Experience by Korean Physical Therapists

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Purpose: This study examined whether there are differences in cognitive styles between orthopedic and neurological physical therapists, and whether these differences change with clinical experience in clinical reasoning. Methods: A survey study was conducted on 88 orthopedic and neurologic physical therapists working in South Korea. The survey items used by May and Dennis (1991) were translated, and only those items related to data-gathering and information-processing were used. Results: The cognitive style was similar in the orthopedic and neurologic physical therapists, but the clinical experience affected the cognitive styles of clinical reasoning. Physical therapists with more than 60 months clinical experience responded most positively to the preceptive and systematic styles in clinical reasoning. Conclusion: These results suggest that physical therapy education should provide physical therapy students with a clinical reasoning process related specifically to a particular clinical field.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 송민영, "한국 물리치료 정의에 관한 고찰" 대한물리의학회 5 (5): 133-141, 2010

2 심재훈, "물리치료사의 직무만족에 영향을 미치는 요인" 대한물리치료학회 23 (23): 67-75, 2011

3 Jensen GM, "The novice versus the experienced clinician : insights into the work of the physical therapist" 70 (70): 314-323, 1990

4 World Confederation of Physical Therapy, "The World Con federation for Physical Therapy: Description of Physical Therapy"

5 Riolo L, "Skill differences in novice and expert clinicians in neurologic physical therapy" 20 (20): 60-63, 1996

6 Wainwright SF, "Novice and experienced physical therapist clinicians: a comparison of how reflection is used to inform the clinical decision-making process" 90 (90): 75-88, 2010

7 Elstein AS, "Medical problem solving: an analysis of clinical reasonin" Harvard University Press 273-302, 1978

8 Ryu YU, "Medical and Narrative Use of Physical Therapy Knowledge in Clinical Reasoning by Korean Physical Therapists" SOC PHYSICAL THERAPY SCIENCE 23 (23): 251-254, 2011

9 Rivett DA, "Hypothesis generation in the clinical reasoning behavior of manual therapists" 11 (11): 40-45, 1997

10 Jensen GM, "Expert practice in physical therapy" 80 (80): 28-43, 2000

11 May BJ, "Expert decision making in physical therapy--a survey of practitioners" 71 (71): 190-202, 1991

12 May BJ, "Developing competence in problem solving. A behavioral model." 60 (60): 1140-1145, 1980

13 Payne JW, "Contingent decision behavior" 92 : 382-402, 1982

14 Edwards I, "Clinical reasoning strategies in physical therapy" 84 (84): 312-330, 2004

15 Payton OD, "Clinical reasoning process in physical therapy" 65 (65): 924-928, 1985

16 Jones MA., "Clinical reasoning in manual therapy" 72 (72): 875-884, 1992

17 이인희, "Clinical Decision Making Development of Clinical Physical Therapists under the Fee for Service and the Prescription of Physician" 대한물리치료학회 24 (24): 171-180, 2012

18 Jensen GM, "Attribute dimensions that distinguish master and novice physical therapy clinicians in orthopedic settings" 72 (72): 711-722, 1992