국가 정체성과 애국심의 관계: 동․서양 5개국 특성 비교 = A Study on the Relations of National Identity and Patriotism: Comparison of Oriental and Western 5 Countries' Characteristics

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study aims to explore the relationship of national identity and patriotism that are recognized as two aspects of national identification. On the basis of Rothi and his fellows' claims(2005) that national identification can be more enhanced through a combination of national identity and patriotism, we set up combined model including all types of national identity and patriotism to examine the specific relationships of these two concepts. In addition, unlike previous Western-oriented studies, this study focuses to discover characteristics of the oriental nations compared to western countries regarding the relationships of national identity and patriotism. Based on the 2003 ISSP data, this research finds following results. ① On the level of national identity, there is a difference from oriental nations and western countries. Oriental nations have more strong ethnic identity than civic national identity, whereas western countries have more strong civic identity than ethnic identity. ② On the level of patriotism, oriental nations differ from western countries. Oriental nations have more strong blind patriotism than constructive patriotism, whereas western countries have more strong constructive patriotism than blind patriotism. However America has high patriotism of all types ③ National identity has a positive impact on the patriotism. But there are big differences from oriental nations and western countries in the degree of impact. In the oriental nations, ethnic identity has more positive impact to the all types of patriotism than civic identity. But contrast to these, the western countries have that civic identity is more positive affect to the all types patriotism than ethnic identity. ④ Ethnic identity is more positive affect to the blind patriotism than that of civic identity in the all sample countries. ⑤ Impact of national identity to the constructive patriotism differs from oriental nations and western countries. As a general discussion of the previous studies, civic identity has more positive influence to the constructive patriotism than ethnic identity in the western countries. But contrast to these, the oriental nations have that ethnic identity is more positive affect to the constructive patriotism than civic identity. Based on these results, this research discusses to the causes the differences between east and western countries and future challenges.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구는 국가 동질감의 내용적/관계적 개념을 구성하는 국가 정체성과 애국심이 어떤인과성을 갖는지를 밝히는데 목적을 두었다. 유사한 속성에도 불구하고 각기 구분되어 연구되고 있는 이들의 결합을 통해 국가 동질감의 의미가 보다 완전하게 파악될 수 있다는Rothi 등(2005)의 주장에 따라 국가 정체성과 애국심을 동시에 고려한 통합모형을 설정하였다. 또한 서구 위주의 기존연구만으로는 이들의 일반화된 관계 파악에 한계가 있다는 시각에서 동․서양 비교 연구를 시도해 보았다. 국제사회조사(ISSP)의 조사자료를 토대로 한동․서양 5개국 비교연구 분석 결과는 다음과 같다. ① 국가 정체성 수준에 있어 동․서양 국가간 차이를 보인다. 한국과 일본은 종족적 정체성이 높고, 서구 국가는 시민적 정체성이 보다 높다. ② 애국심 수준에 있어서도 동․서양 국가간 차이를 보인다. 한국과 일본은 맹목적 애국심이 건설적 애국심보다 높고, 서구 국가는 시민적 애국심이 맹목적 애국심보다 높다. 단, 미국은 모든 유형의 애국심이 높게 나타난다. ③ 국가 정체성은 애국심에 긍정적 영향을 미친다. 단, 영향 정도에 있어서는 동․서양 국가간 차이를 보인다. 동양 국가는 종족적 정체성의 영향이 크고, 서양 국가에서는 시민적 정체성이 보다 큰 영향을 미친다. ④ 맹목적 애국심에 대한 국가 정체성의 영향력은 종족적 정체성이 시민적 정체성보다 모든 국가에서 크게 나타난다. ⑤ 건설적 애국심 대한 국가 정체성의 영향력은 동․서양 국가간 차이를 보인다. 서양 국가에서는 기존연구의 일반적 논의처럼 시민적 정체성의 영향력이 보다 크나, 한국과 일본은 종족적 정체성이 시민적 정체성보다 오히려 더 큰 영향을 미친다. 이러한 결과를 토대로 동․서양 국가간 차이발생 원인과 향후 과제에 대해 논의하였다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Raijman, R, "What does a Nation Owe Non-Citizens? National Attachments, Perception of Threat and Attitudes towards Granting Citizenship Rights in a Comparative Perspective" 49 (49): 195-220, 2008

2 Zubrzycki, G, "We, the Polish Nation", Ethnic and Civic Visions of Nationhood in Postcommunist Constitutional Devates" 30 (30): 629-668, 2001

3 Fukuyama, F, "Trust : Social Virtues and the Creation of Prosperity" Free Press 1995

4 Castles, S, "The age of Migration. International Population Movements in the Modern World" Palgrave Macmillan 2003

5 Taifel, H, "The Social Identity Theory of Intergroup Behavior, In Psychology of Intergroup Relations" Chicago; Nelson-Hall 7-24, 1986

6 Kuzio, T, "The Myth of the Civic State. A Critical Survey of Kohn's Framework for Understanding Nationalism" 25 (25): 20-39, 2002

7 Spry, C, "The Influence of Blind and Constructive patriotism on Attitudes toward Multiculturalism and Immigration" 59 (59): 151-158, 2007

8 Tolsma, J, "The Impact of Neighborhood and Municipality Characterics on Social Cohesion in the Netherlqands" 44 : 286-313, 2009

9 Kohn, H, "The Idea of Nationalism. A Study in Its Origin and Background" Macmillan 1944

10 Roshwald. A, "The Endurance of Nationalism: Ancient Roots and Modern Dilemmas" Cambridge University Press 2006

11 Bjorklund, F, "The East European Ethnic Nation: Myth or Reality?" 45 (45): 93-21, 2006

12 Tilly, J.R, "The Decline of British National Pride"

13 Hero, R. E, "Social Capital and Racial Inequality in America" 1 : 113-122, 2003

14 Kymlicka, W, "Politics in the Vernacular: Nationalism, Multiculturalism, and Citizenship" Oxford University Press 2001

15 Palumbo. A, "Patriotism and Pluralism: Identification and Compliance in the Post-National Polity" 2 (2): 321-348, 2009

16 Alesina, A, "Participation in Heterogeneous Communications" 115 : 847-894, 2000

17 Schatz, R. T, "On the Varieties of National Attachment: Blind versus Constructive Patriotism" 20 (20): 151-174, 1999

18 Billig, M, "Nationalism as an International Ideology: Imagining the Nation, Others and the World of Nations, In Changing European Identities: Social Pychological Analyses of Social Cchange" Butterworth-Heinemann 181-194, 1996

19 Reeskens, T, "Nationalism and the Cohesive Society: A Multilevel Analysis of the Interplay Among Diversity, National Identity, and Social Capital Across 27 European Societies" 46 (46): 153-181, 2013

20 Gaber. R, "National Identy and Democratic Consolidation in Central and Eastern Europe" 36 (36): 35-69, 2006

21 Blank, T, "National Identity in a United Germany: Nationalism or Patriotism? An Empirical Test with Representative Data" 20 (20): 289-312, 2003

22 Byrne, "National Identity and Attitudes Toward Immigrants in a Multicreedal America" 39 (39): 485-514, 2011

23 Smith, A. D, "National Identity" Penguin 1991

24 Hjerm, M, "National Identities, National Pride and Xenophobia: A Comparison of Four Western Countries" 335-347, 1998

25 Rothi, D. M, "National Attachment and Patriotism in a European Nation: A British Study" 26 (26): 135-155, 2005

26 Pollmann. A, "National Attachment among Berlin and London Head Teachers: The Explanatory Impact of National Identity, National Pride and Supranational Attachment?" 34 (34): 45-53, 2008

27 Lai, M. H, "Motivation as Mediator Between National Identity and Intention to Volunteer" 2012

28 Davidov. E, "Measurement Equivalence of Nationalism and Constructive Patriotism in ISSP: 34 Countries in a Comparative Perspective" 17 : 64-82, 2009

29 Jones, F. L, "Individual and Societal Bases of National Identity. A Comparative Multi-level Analysis" 17 (17): 103-118, 2001

30 Anderson, B, "Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origins and Spread of Nationalism" Verso 1983

31 Ariely. G, "Globalisation and Decline of National Identity? An Exploration across Sixty-three Countries" 18 (18): 461-482, 2012

32 Brubaker. R, "Ethnicity without Group. Related by Sinisa Malesevic" 12 (12): 699-700, 2006

33 Kaufman, E., "Ethnic or Civic Nation? Theorizing the American case" 27 (27): 133-135, 2000

34 Putnam, R. D, "E Pluribus Unum: Doversity and Community in the Twenty-first Century" 30 : 137-174, 2007

35 Kelman, H. C, "Crimes of obedience: Toward a Social Psychology of Authority and Responsibility" Yale University Press 261-306, 1989

36 Meinecke, F, "Cosmopolitanism and the National State. Princeton" Princeton University Press 1970

37 Brubaker. R, "Citizenship and Nationhood in France and Germany" Harvard University Press 1992

38 Miller, D, "Citizenship and National Identity" Polity Press 2000

39 Shulman, S, "Challenging the Civic/Ethnic and West/East Dichotomies in the Study of Nationalism" 35 (35): 554-585, 2002

40 Staub, E, "Blind versus Constructive Patriotism: Moving from Embeddedness in the Group to Critical Loyalty and Action, In Patriotism in the Lives of Individuals and Nations" Nelson-Hall 213-228, 1997

41 Staub, E, "Blind versus Constructive Patriotism: Moving from Embeddedness in the Group to Critical Loyalty and Action, In Patriotism in the Lives of Individuals and Nations" Nelson-Hall 213-228, 1997

42 Reeskens. T, "Beyond the Civic-Ethic Dichotomy: Investigating the Structure of Citizenship Concepts Across Thirty-three Countries" 16 (16): 579-597, 2010

43 Medrano, J. D, "Between Fear and Hope: Globalization and Race in the United States" 33 (33): 451-453, 2004

44 Huddy, L, "American Patriotism, National Identity, and Political Involvement" 51 (51): 63-77, 2007

45 Wrighr. M, "Alternative Measures of American National Identity: Implications for the Civic-Ethnic Distinction" 33 (33): 469-482, 2012