Meridian Studies in China: A Systematic Review

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Meridian theory is a major part of Chinese medicine and has guided acupuncture and clinical practice for thousands of years. Meridian theory describes many important concepts about the rules of human body function and regulation, but has comparatively huge differences with the basic concepts of modern medicine. These differences have caused deep concern and attracted attention from scholars, both inside and outside of China. The interest in meridian theory lies in determining the structural nature of meridians. Not only is this information still unclear, it is very difficult to achieve clear results in a short period of time. Despite this, the phenomena of meridians can be used as the entry point for meridian studies.
After many years of effort, although the physical structure of meridians has not been found, the existence of the meridian phenomena has been fully confirmed.
Although there is a lack of morphological evidence for the existence of the meridian,concluding non-existence may be incorrect as morphology techniques develop and structures previously not determined are being found. Since the phenomenon of meridians exists, some biological basis behind its occurrence must be present.
This implies that research on meridians needs to continue as research techniques advance and may eventually reveal the biological basis of the meridian phenomenon.
In the present review, we analyze the history of meridian studies in China.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Zhang WB, "Zhu BJ, et al. An improved Guyton’s method to measure hydraulic conductance and its use in measuring conductance in meridian tissue of animals" 16 : 199-204, 1997

2 Zhang WB, "What is the Meridian" China Publishing House of Science and Technology 1997

3 Zhang WB, "What is Meridian?" Science and Technology Publishing Company 60-, 1997

4 Tian N, "Tissue channel" 13 : 1-3, 2003

5 Zhang WB, "Three main ideas in modern meridian study including a discussion about the mechanism of PSC" 7 : 46-48, 2001

6 Chen YM, "Three dimensional tomogram and scenograph of the migration line of 18F-FDG along meridians" 22 : 603-605, 2002

7 Dimitriadou V, "Theoharides TC. Trigeminal sensory fiber stimulation induces morphological changes reflecting secretion in rat dura mater mast cells" 44 : 97-112, 1991

8 Rozniecki JJ, "Theoharides TC. Morphological and functional demonstration of rat dura mater mast cell-neuron interactions in vitro and in vivo" 849 : 1-15, 1999

9 Zhang WB, "The wave propagation of interstitial fluid pressure along the Ren Mai and the mechanism of acupoint injection" 18 : 60-61, 1998

10 Zhang WB, "The transport of interstitial fluid pressure wave in subcutaneous tissue on and beside the stomach meridian in rats" 14 : 40-43, 1995

11 Zhang WB, "The study on the relationship between the disbalance degree of transcutaneous CO2 emission in points and the diseases" 16 : 21-22, 1996

12 Zhang WB, "The study on the effect of transcutaneous CO2 emission in acupuncture points" 12 : 39-42, 1996

13 Zhang WB, "The study on specificity of transcutaneous CO2 emission in large intestine meridian and stomach meridian" 15 : 625-627, 1995

14 Guo Y, "The study on ions specificity in acupoints" 13 : 37-, 1994

15 Guo Y, "The study on Ca2+ concentration specificity in acupoints in rabbit" 16 : 66-68, 1991

16 Guo Y, "The study on Ca2+ concentration specificity in acupoint in rabbit" 3 : 39-41, 1990

17 Zhang WB, "The study of tissue osmolarity along the meridians in rat" 14 : 68-, 1994

18 Song ZG, "The study of the relationship between Jing and Mai based on modern biology" 4 : 24-25, 1998

19 Wang BX, "The study of the mechanism of PSC" 4 : 48-, 1980

20 Xie YK, "The study of neurological characteristics of meridian and PSC" 25 : 721-731, 1995

21 Shi WC, "The role of substance P and histamine in information transmission along the channels and collaterals" 15 : 33-35, 1995

22 Gong QH, "The relationship of meridians and lymphatic tube" 13 : 35-40, 1979

23 Dang RS, "The relationship between points in Fei meridian and the connec tive tissue" 16 : 30-, 1997

24 Wen S, "The relationship between peripheral nerve network and essence of Jingluo" 23 : 156-160, 1998

25 Xu ZQ, "The nanatomic structure of meridians in Neijing" 11 : 37-39, 1995

26 Lin XZ, "The material base and the soliton model of channels of traditional Chinese medicine" 9 : 55-60, 1990

27 Hu XL, "The main characters of infrared radiant track along meridian courses over human body surface and the condition of its appearance" 20 : 325-328, 2001

28 Deng YP, "The influence of electroacupuncture on the mast cells in the acupoints of the Stomach meridian" 21 : 68-70, 1996

29 Tian N, "The importance of tissue channel on the development of medicine and biology" 16 : 1-3, 2006

30 Wu ZX, "The effects of Hegu acupuncturing and heating on transcutaneous oxygen pressure and subcutaneous microcirculation perfusion along the skin of large intestine channel of Hand-Yangming" 10 : 37-42, 2008

31 Gao S, "The effect of electro-acupuncture on the ultrastructure of mast cells in acupoints" 5 : 40-42, 1981

32 Gurish MF, "The diverse roles of mast cells" 194 : F1-F5, 2001

33 Zhang WB, "The distribution of transcutaneous CO2 emission and correlation with the points along the pericardium meridian" 2 : 197-201, 2009

34 Xue CC, "The cortical and meridian sensations, a suggestion on the use of acupuncture to examine parietal lobe function" 8 : 9-14, 1988

35 Lu LS, "The analysis of meridian essence" 16 : 20-22, 1996

36 Hu XL, "The Soul of Gold Needle — The Study of Meridians" Science and Technology Publishing Company of Hunan 48-, 1997

37 Huang Y, "Study on the meridians and acupoints based on fasciaology, an elicitation of the study on a digital human being" 26 : 785-, 2006

38 Zhang D, "Study on effects of α-receptor blocker on high temperature lines along channels in the cholecystitis model rabbit by infrared thermogram" 21 : 25-, 2002

39 Wang XY, "Study on an ionic mechanism of peripheral acupoint on acupuncture analgesia" 23 : 263-265, 1998

40 Zhang BZ, "Structure and Function of Meridians" Shanxi publishing house of science and technology 1992

41 Guo Y, "Specific distribution of Ca2+ concentration in acupoints of healthy human bodies" 21 : 37-38, 2002

42 Hu XL, "Soul of Golden Needle: The Study of Meridians" Hunan Publishing House of Science and Technology 1997

43 Zhang RJ, "Science of Meridians" Beijing University Press 2003

44 Kim BH, "Sanal theory" 168 : 5-38, 1965

45 Lantz CS, "Role for interleukin-3 in mast-cell and basophil development and in immunity to parasites" 392 : 90-93, 1998

46 Xie HR, "Review of verification study about meridian tridiscuss" 21 : 333-334, 2003

47 Li R, "Research into the meridian essence from the origin of meridian theory" 18 : 619-621, 1998

48 Xie W, "Research into the black box method for meridians and its significance" 18 : 171-174, 2002

49 Tao KZ, "Relationship between some acupuncture points of gall bladder and stomach meridian in crural area and muscle origins and calcium accumulating areas" 16 : 504-506, 1998

50 Tao KZ, "Relationship between some acupuncture points of Gall Bladder and Stomach meridian in crural area and muscle origins and calcium accumulating area" 20 : 504-506, 1998

51 Shen XY, "Relation of acupoints of the stomach channel with structure of connective tissue and accumulation of calcium" 18 : 19-21, 1998

52 Xu ZX, "Present status of the relationship between meridians and connective tissues" 22 : 45-49, 2003

53 Bao SY, "Preliminary study of meridian essence" 27 : 22-24, 2005

54 Mu X, "Physiological study on the relationship between the essence of acupuncture point and the microvasculum" 7 : 41-52, 2001

55 Keller JT, "Peptidergic and serotoninergic innervation of the rat dura mater" 309 : 515-534, 1991

56 Kellner, G, "On the presence of fissures in the corium of human skin" 74 : 330-336, 1966

57 Kellner G, "On a vascularized nerve-ending corpuscle of the Krause end-organ type" 75 : 130-144, 1966

58 Xu JS, "Observation on the infrared radiant track along meridians over body surface in patients with pulmonary diseases" 15 : 18-20, 2005

59 Lin JH, "Observation of mast cells from connective tissue in human acupoint by morphological methods and immunohistochemistry" 9 : 2-6, 1989

60 Zhao Y, "Neurokin A and information transmission along channels" 18 : 149-151, 1997

61 Zhu ZX, "Morphometric observation on the mast cells under the acupuncture meridian lines" 15 : 157-161, 1990

62 Yang YM, "Morphological observation on the effect of acupuncture on mast cells in “ZUSANLI” point" 23 : 298-302, 1984

63 Hu XL, "Modern Research of Meridians in TCM Theory" Publishing house of people’s health 1990

64 Zhang WB, "Meridians and Collaterals are the Water Passages" Publishing House of Military Medicine 2009

65 Chen ZS, "Meridian system, a network of bioelectrical ions channels in the body" 2 : 49-53, 2006

66 Mu X, "Meridian should be the “Ordered Microangium networks”" 4 : 48-51, 1998

67 Liu CZ, "Meridian Medicine: The Decode of Meridians Cipher Code" Dalian Publishing House 2007

68 Galli SJ, "Mast cells in the development of adaptive immune responses" 6 : 135-142, 2005

69 Galli SJ, "Mast cells as sentinels of innate immunity" 11 : 53-59, 1999

70 Malaviya R, "Mast cell modulation of neutrophil influx and bacterial clearance at sites of infection through TNF-alpha" 381 : 77-80, 1996

71 Song JM, "Mast cell and meridian phenomenon" 4 : 59-61, 1977

72 Fei L, "Look into the future and experimental research on the material basis and function of meridian" 43 : 658-672, 1998

73 Zhang WB, "Laser Doppler perfusion imaging for assessment of skin blood perfusion after acupuncture" 20 : 109-118, 2008

74 Li DZ, "Investigation the exist of meridians through 93 cases shin disease. In The Acupuncture-Moxibustion and Acupuncture-Anesthesia" Science Publishing Company 528-532, 1986

75 Zhang RJ, "Investigation of the lower resistance meridian. The distribution of lower resistance meridians in normal individuals" 24 : 135-142, 1978

76 Yang WS, "Investigation of the lower resistance meridian. Speculation on the physiological functions of acupuncture meridians" 44 : 281-288, 2008

77 Yang WS, "Investigation of the lower resistance meridian. Reasoning on the histological basis of acupuncture meridians" 44 : 277-280, 2008

78 Yang WS, "Investigation of the lower resistance meridian I. Method of investigation" 24 : 128-134, 1978

79 Liaoning College of Traditional Chinese Medicine, "Initial observation of mast cell in acupoint" 4 : 26-28, 1980

80 Yu SY, "Inhibiting effects of tianrong acupoint therapy on mast cells of dura mater" 20 : 34-38, 1995

81 Wang PQ, "Infrared imagedisplaying of the fourteen meridian courses" 27 : 260-261, 2002

82 Wang PX, "Inducted PSC by getting quiet" 2 : 277-280, 1978

83 De Jonge F, "In vitro activation of murine DRG neurons by CGRP-mediated mucosal mast cell degranulation" 287 : G178-G191, 2004

84 Yuan L, "Human auto-testing and modulating system, an anatomic basis involved in meridianal system" 21 : 356-359, 2004

85 Frieling T, "Histamine receptors on submucous neurons in guinea pig colon" 264 : G74-G80, 1993

86 Zhu B, "Generating-sensation and propagating-myoelectrical responses along the meridian" 45 : 105-112, 2002

87 Zhang XJ, "Further investigation on the hypothesis of meridian-cortex-viscera interrelationship" 3 : 264-267, 1983

88 Gong QH, "Exploration on meridianal basis of lymphatic meeting under point sanyinjino" 12 : 9-11, 1983

89 Hu XL, "Elicitation of infrared radiant tracks along meridian courses over the human body surface by local heating" 21 : 6-8, 2002

90 Li M, "Effects of electroacupuncture on the number of subcutaneous mast cells in and beside the acupoint and the inflammatory pain focus in the rat" 23 : 597-601, 2003

91 Zong AM, "Effects of electroacupuncture on fascia mast cells in “Zusanli” acupoint area of rabbits" 27 : 226-229, 1992

92 Ding GH, "Dynamic mechanism of interstitial fluid flowing towards a certain direction and the meridian phenomenon in human" 15 : 61-70, 2005

93 Cheng BH, "Dynamic changes of K+, Na+, Ca2+, H+ concentration in points after acupuncture different meridians" 11 : 40-46, 1991

94 Hu XL, "Displaying of meridian courses travelling over human body surface under natural conditions" 18 : 83-89, 1993

95 Zhang D, "Displaying of infrared thermogram of temperature character on meridians" 21 : 63-67, 1996

96 Zhang D, "Displaying infrared thermogram along the meridians with internal organ disease (pericarditis)" 10 : 52-54, 2004

97 Zhang BZ, "Discussion about the skin reaction along the meridians and the morphological and physiological basis of the PSC" 5 : 90-92, 1984

98 Deng QK, "Discrimination of meridian essence, research on meridian essence and its bioequivalence" 21 : 63-72, 2004

99 Chen LW, "Discovery of the neuromastocytic junction on the modeled meridian line in mouse skin. A study by light and electron microscopic immunohistochemistry" 3 : 253-258, 1987

100 Zhang BZ, "Discovery of the neuro-mastocytic junction on the meridian line in human skin. The efferent neuromastocytic junction and the Schwann cells accompanying efferent axons" 1 : 107-110, 1985

101 Zhang BZ, "Discovery of the neuro-mastocytic junction on the meridian line in human skin, efferent neuromastocytic junction" 1 : 47-52, 1985

102 Li DZ, "Discovery of Meridians in TCM Theory" Publishing House of Liberation Army 2003

103 Chen JD, "Discovery of Meridian Essence" Science and Technology Publishing Company of Inner Mongolia 9-, 2002

104 Men JB, "Discovery of Fourteen Meridian Channels Image" Science and Technology Publishing Company 208-, 1998

105 Meng JB, "Discovery of Fourteen Channels image" China Publishing House of Science and Technology 1998

106 Lee BC, "Development of a fluorescence stereomicroscope and observation of Bong-Han corpuscles inside blood vessels" 46 : 330-335, 2008

107 You ZQ, "Detection of the course of the pericardium channel on the human body surface using the location method of blockage of needling effects with pressing" 5 : 281-284, 1999

108 Hu XL, "Current problems awaiting solution in PSC research" 6 : 161-171, 1981

109 Echtenacher B, "Critical protective role of mast cells in a model of acute septic peritonitis" 381 : 75-77, 1996

110 Zhang D, "Comparison of high temperature lines along the meridians by different acupuncture methods" 20 : 29-33, 2000

111 Zhang WB, "Cluster analysis to the correlativity of skin respiration of CO2 on acupoints of twelve meridians on human body" 12 : 259-264, 1997

112 Liu CZ, "Clinical Meridians Phenomenology" Dalian publishing house 1997

113 Liu LY, "Classical Meridian Theory and Modern Meridian Theory" Beijing Medical and Xiehe University Associate Press 1997

114 Zhao JS, "Classical Acupuncture and Moxibuston Theory" Shanghai University of TCM Publishing Company 21-, 2000

115 Zhen LY, "Channels may be functional zones adhering to certain tissues" 20 : 35-36, 2001

116 Zhu ZX, "Biophysics of Acupuncture-Meridians, The verification of the first invention in China" Beijing, Beijing Publishing House 1989

117 Van der Kleij HP, "Bienenstock J. Functional expression of neurokinin 1 receptors on mast cells induced by IL-4 and stem cell factor" 171 : 2074-2079, 2003

118 Arizono N, "Anatomical variation in mast cell nerve associations in the rat small intestine, heart, lung, and skin. Similarities of distances between neural processes and mast cells, eosinophils, or plasma cells in the jejunal lamina propria" 62 : 626-634, 1990

119 Li RW, "Analysis of the linear migration of the radionucleotide along meridians in perfused extremities of monkey" 17 : 67-70, 1992

120 Guo MX, "Advances in research on substance basis of meridian, propagated sensation along meridian and mechanisms of meridian actions" 8 : 5353-5355, 2004

121 Anonymous, "About the meridian system, from the People’s Daily (Dec. 14th, 1963)" 7 : 2-22, 1964

122 Zhou DX, "A study on the transmission route of three Yin meridian in the foot using 32P radioautography study" 22 : 307-308, 1999

123 Yuan L, "A study on morphological basis of Chinese acupuncture and moxibustion from digital human body" 35 : 337-343, 2004

124 Cheng HS, "A study on abnormal distribution of some elements at meridian acupoints by PIXE" 22 : 494-499, 1999

125 Meng JB, "A study of the migration channels along 12 meridians in healthy volunteers imaged by gamma camera with isotope" 14 : 1-6, 1989

126 Zhang WB, "A simulating study of biophysical features along meridians on a gel model" 18 : 357-361, 2001

127 Chen EY, "A relationship between connective tissue and accumulation of calcium with points on the GB channel below the head" 17 : 36-38, 1998

128 He YJ, "A primary study on meridian-stretching of injected FDG using PET MPI tool" 22 : 145-146, 2002

129 Hu JM, "A preliminary analysis of research on acupuncture-moxibustion and meridians abroad in recent 40 years" 21 : 753-757, 2001

130 Zhang WB, "A method to continuously measure hydraulic resistance of subcutis and the study of low hydraulic resistance points" 14 : 373-378, 1998

131 Wei-Bo Zhang, "A Discovery of Low Hydraulic Resistance Channel Along Meridians" 세계약침학회 1 (1): 20-28, 2008