'새 관점의 바울 연구' 다시 보기

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

What should we think about The New Perspective on Paul (NPP), one of the hottest issues in recent Pauline studies? This article provides a critical analysis of the NPP by studying both its contributions and problems focusing on the works of EP Sanders, James Dunn and Tom Wright, who are currently the most outstanding advocates of the NPP.
Although the article recognizes that the NPP has provided some new insights on the role of the covenant and the law within Second Temple Judaism (STJ), as well as on the social (horizontal) meaning of the righteousness (of God) in the Pauline epistles, it basically focuses on both the problems and weaknesses of the NPP by arguing against three problems and weaknesses of the NPP on STJ and Paul as follows:
Firstly, the NPP's identification of STJ as 'covenantal nomism', the so called Archimedean point of the NPP, is one-sided, because more recent investigations of the STJ show that both covenantal nomism and legalism coexist within the STJ, especially in eschatological teachings.
Secondly, the NPP's identification of Paul's teaching of 'justification by faith' as a circumstantial doctrine is one-sided, because 'justification by faith' belongs to the core teaching of Paul's gospel.
Thirdly, the NPP's identification of 'works of the law' as a national identity of Jews is one-sided, because Paul uses 'works of the law' as the antithesis to 'justification by faith' in terms of a system whereby the final salvation is guaranteed through good works demanded by the entire law.
Hence, the article concludes that the NPP misunderstands and misrepresents not only STJ but also Paul.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 최갑종, "바울연구 2" 크리스천문서선교회 52-, 1997

2 김세윤, "바울 복음의 기원" 엠마오 444-475, 1994

3 박정수, "기독교 신학의 뿌리: 유대교 사상의 형성과 신약성서 배경사" 대한기독교서회 2008

4 J.C.R. de Roo, "‘Works of the Law' at Qumran and in Paul" Sheffield Phoenix 2007

5 Timo Laato, "‘God's Righteousness'-Once Again in: The Nordic Paul. Finnish Approaches to Pauline Theology" T & T Clark 63-, 2008

6 Dunn, Romans, "ixv; The Theology of Paul the Apostle" Eerdmans 335-340, 1998

7 Martin Luther,"Lectures on Galatians", "in Luther's Works,(ed.Jaroslav Pelikan,St.Louis:Concordia" 33 1963

8 Dunn, "Yet Once More-‘The Works of the Law'" 46 : 99-117, 1992

9 Simon J. Gathercole, "Where is Boasting? Early Jewish Soteriology and Paul's Response in Romans 1-5" Eerdmans 41-, 2002

10 Michael F. Bird, "When the Dust Finally Settles: Coming to a Post-New Perspective Perspective" 2 (2): 60-, 2005

11 N.T. Wright, "What Saint Paul Really Said" Eerdmans 32-, 1997

12 T. Eskola, "Theodicy and Predestination in Pauline Soteriology" Mohr 56-, 1998

13 C.E.B. Cranfield, "The Works of the Law in the Epistle to the Romans" 43 : 89-101, 1991

14 Jacob Neusner, "The Use of Later Rabbinic Evidence for the Study of Paul in: Approaches to Ancient Judaism" Scholars Press 43-63, 1980

15 Charles L. Quarles, "The Soteriology of R. Akiba and E.P. Sanders' Paul and Palestinian Judaism" 42 : 185-, 1996

16 Michael F. Bird, "The Saving Righteousness of God: Studies on Paul, Justification, and the New Perspective" Paternoster 2007

17 Dunn, "The Paul Page. An Evening Conversation on Paul with James D.G. Dunn and N.T. Wright"

18 J.G. Machen, "The Origin of Paul's Religion" Hodder and Stoughton 278-, 1921

19 James H. Charlesworth, "The Old Testament Pseudepigrapha, 2" Doubleday 660-, 1985

20 F. David Farnell, "The New Perspective on Paul: Its Basic Tenets, History, and Presupposition" 16 (16): 195-, 2005

21 Ben Witherington, "The New Perspective on Paul and the Law-Reviewed"

22 James D.G. Dunn, "The New Perspective on Paul" Eerdmans 99-120, 2008

23 Graham Stanton, "The Law of Moses and the Law of Christ in: Paul and the Mosaic Law" Mohr 106-, 1996

24 N.T. Wright, "The Climax of the Covenant" Fortress 139-, 1992

25 K. Stendahl, "The Apostle Paul and the Introspective Conscience of the West" 199-215, 1963

26 John Calvin, "Romans and Thessalonian" Eerdmans 27-28, 1960

27 James D.G. Dunn, "Romans 1-8" Word 1988

28 Westerholm, "Paul’s Anthropological ‘Pessimism’ in its Jewish Context"

29 C.K. Barrett, "Paul: An Introduction to His Thought" Westminster 78-, 1994

30 E.P. Sanders, "Paul: A Very Short Introduction" Oxford University Press 53-58, 1991

31 M. Abegg, "Paul, ‘Works of the Law' and MMT" 20 : 52-55, 1994

32 A. Andrew Das, "Paul, the Law, and the Covenant" Hendrickson 16-, 2001

33 Sanders, "Paul, the Law and the Jewish People" Fortress 17-64, 1983

34 Das, "Paul, the Law and Covenant; F. Avemarie, Tora und Leben: Untersuchungen zur Heilsbedeu- tung der Tora in der fru¨hen rabbinischen Literatur" Mohr 1996

35 J.A. Fitzmyer, "Paul's Jewish Background and the Debate of the Law in: According to Paul: Studies in the Theology of the Apostle" Paulist 18-35, 1993

36 Donfrid, "Paul and the Revisionist: Did Luther Really Get it All Wrong" 46 : 37-, 2007

37 Seyoon Kim, "Paul and the New Perspective. Second Thoughts on the Origin of Paul's Gospel" Eerdmans 3-, 2002

38 Robert B. Sloan, "Paul and the Law" 33 : 44-45, 1991

39 C.K. Barrett, "Paul and the Introspective Conscience in: The Bible, the Reformation and the Church. Essays in Honor of James Atkinson" JSOT Press 48-, 1995

40 E.P. Sanders, "Paul and Palestinian Judaism: A Comparison of Pattern of Religion" Fortress Press 1977

41 T. Laato, "Paul and Judaism: An Anthropological Approach" Scholars Press 60-, 1995

42 Martin Luther, "Lectures on Romans" Concordia 9-, 1972

43 Mark A. Seifrid, "Justification by Faith. The Origin and Development of a Central Pauline Them" E.J. Brill 100-, 1992

44 D.A. Carson, "Justification and Variegated Nomism" Baker Academic 2001

45 Overman, "Judaism" 3 : 1038-,

46 E.P. Sanders, "Judaic Law from Jesus to the Mishnah: A Systematic Reply to Professor" Scholars 1993

47 C.F.D. Moule, "Jesus, Judaism, and Paul in: Tradition and Interpretation in the New Testament: Essays in Honor of E. Earle Ellis for His 60th Birthday" J.C.B. Mohr 48-49, 1987

48 T.L. Donaldson, "Israelite, Convert, Apostle to the Gentiles: The Origin of Paul's Gentile Mission in: The Road from Damascus: The Impact of Paul's Conversion on His Life, Thought, and Ministry" Eerdmans 62-84, 1997

49 Judaism, "In the First Centuries of the Christian Era: The Age of Tannaim" Hendrickson 1997

50 "Holy Bible with the Apocrypha" Oxford University Press 86-, 1989

51 Robert L. Thomas, "Hermeneutics of the New Perspective on Paul" 16 (16): 301-, 2005

52 Peter Enns, "Expansions of Scripture in: Justification and Variegated Nomism: The Complexities of Second Temple Judaism" Mohr 97-98, 2001

53 J. Roloff, "Die lutherische Rechtfertigungslehre und ihre biblische Grundlage in: Fru¨hjudentum und Neues Testament im Horizont Biblischer Theologie" Mohr 275-300, 2003

54 George Foot Moore, "Christian Writers on Judaism" 14 : 197-254, 1921

55 John Calvin, "Calvin's Commentaries: Romans" Eerdmans 8-, 1965

56 R. Alan Streett, "An Interview with Martin Hengel" 2 (2): 14-, 2005

57 Mark M. Mattison, "A Summary of the New Perspective on Paul"