지방행정체제개편에 관한 이론적 검토 = A Review on the Theories of Restructuring Local Government System

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper addresses to review theories related to restructuring of local government system focused on the criteria for reorganization and optimal government size, conflicting views on consolidation, and alternatives of the consolidation. The results are: 1) the criteria for reorganization are often conflict each other and optimal government size is various according to governmental functions, 2) reformers propose large local government through consolidation while public choice scholars are against the consolidation, 3) there are many alternatives for solving regional problem besides consolidation. Based on the review, this paper diagnoses that the current drive for restructuring local government system in Korea is biased too much toward the district consolidation which is very difficult to implement and costly.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 박기춘, "한국 지방행정체제 개편의 방향과 전략" (주)새로운 사람들 2010

2 박연호, "프랑스 행정의 이해" 박영사 1997

3 이승종, "지방행정체제개편론" 법문사 2009

4 김석태, "지방행정체제 개편안에 대한 비판적 고찰 -적정구역과 구역문제 해결단계의 관점에서-" 한국정부학회 21 (21): 331-353, 2009

5 최창호, "지방행정구역론" 법문사 1981

6 김석태, "지방정부체제에 대한 공공선택론적 견해에 대한 재조명 : 신거버넌스와 관련하여" 한국지방정부학회 11 (11): 7-23, 2007

7 이달곤, "지방정부론" 법문사 2004

8 Leemans, A.F., "지방정부개혁론" 법문사 1978

9 안성호, "지방자치체제 개편과 자치단위의 규모" 지방자치학회 2009

10 유재원, "지방자치 계층구조 및 행정구역 개편에 관한 소고 - 광역자치단체를 중심으로" 66 (66): 119-137, 2002

11 유재원, "시군통합의 효과에 대한 경험적 분석: 단절적 시계열모형(ARIMA)의 적용" 한국행정학회 43 (43): 285-306, 2009

12 유재원, "시군통합의 추진동력과 정책대안" 한국행정학회 44 (44): 179-202, 2010

13 박승주, "마지막 남은 개혁 2001" (주)교보문고 1999

14 Ostrom, Elina, "Unlocking Public Entrepreneurship and Public Economies" EDGI and UNU-WIDER 2005

15 Miller, David Y., "The Regional Governance of Metropolitan Area" Westview Press 2002

16 Olson, Mancur, "The Principle of Fiscal Equivalence: The Division of Responsibilities among Different Levels of Government" 479-487, 1969

17 Oates, Wallace E., "The Political Economy of Fiscal Federalism" Lexington Books 1977

18 Ostrom, Vincent, "The Organization of Government in Metropolitan Areas: A Theoretical Inquiry" 55 : 831-842, 1961

19 Sancton, Andrew, "The Governance of Metropolitan Areas in Canada" 25 : 317-327, 2005

20 Oakerson, Ronald J., "The Governance Effect of Metropolitan Reform: A Theoretical Inquiry" 2002

21 Hughes Herbert H., "The Evolutionary Consolidation Model. in: Forms of Local Government: A Handbook on City, County and Regional Options" McFarland & Company, Inc 272-279, 1999

22 Hirsh, W., "The Economics of State and Local Government" MacGraw-Hill 1968

23 Dahl, Robert A., "The City in the Future of Democracy" 61 (61): 953-970, 1967

24 Fisher, Ronald C., "State and Local Public Finance" Scott, Foresman and Co 1996

25 Keating, Michael, "Size, Efficiency and Democracy: Consolidation, Fragmentation and Public Choice. in: Theories of Urban Politics" Sage publications 1995

26 Dahl, Robert A., "Size and Democracy" Stanford University Press 1973

27 Andrews, Rhys, "Population Size and Local Authority Performance. Final Research Report" Center for Local & Regional Government Research, Cardiff University 2006

28 Savitch, H.V., "Paths to New Regionalism" 32 (32): 158-168, 2000

29 Ostrom, Elina, "Metropolitan Reform: Propositions Derived from Two Traditions" 53 : 474-493, 1972

30 Phares, Donald, "Metropolitan Government without Metropolitan Government" Ashgate 2004

31 Stephens, G. Ross, "Metropolitan Government and Governance" Oxford University Press 2000

32 Sancton, Andrew, "Merge Mania. in: The Assault on Local Government" McGill-Queens University Press 2000

33 Bailey, Stephen J., "Local Government Economics. in: Principle and Practice" MacMillan 1999

34 Bish, Robert L., "Local Government Amalgamations. in: Discredited Nineteenth-Century Ideals Alive in the Twenty-First" C. D. Howe Institute Commentary 150-, 2001

35 "Kubler, Daniel and Hubert Heinelt.(2002). An Analytical Framework for Democratic Metropolitan Governance. Working paper. 30th ECPR Joint Sessions of Workshop, Turin, (March, 2002)"

36 Newton, N., "Is Small Really Do Beautiful? Is Big Really So Ugly? Size, Effectiveness, and Democracy in Local Government" 30 (30): 190-206, 1982

37 Lyons, W. E., "Governmental Fragmentation Versus Consolidation: Five Public-Choice Myths about How to Create Informed, Involved, and Happy Citizens" 533-543, 1989

38 Walker, David, "From Metropolitan Cooperation to Governance. in: Forms of Local Government: A Handbook on City, County and Regional Options" McFarland & Company, Inc 151-158, 1999

39 Grosskoff, Shawna, "Economies of Scope in the Provision of Local Public Services" 43 (43): 61-74, 1990

40 Leland, Suzanne M., "City-County Consolidation. in: Promise Made, Promise Kept?" Georgetown University Press 2010

41 Pierce, Neal, "Citistate. in: How Urban America Can Prosper in a Competitive World" Seven Locks Press 1993

42 Leland, Suzanne M., "Case Studies of City-County Consolidation" Sharpe 2004

43 Bish, Robert L., "Accommodating Multiple Boundaries for Local Service: Britich Columbia's Local Governance System" Indiana University 2002

44 Tiebout, Charles, "A Pure Theory of Local Expenditure" 64 : 416-435, 1956

45 Ostrom, Elinor, "A Behavioral Approach to the Rational Choice Theory of Collective Action： Presidential Address, American Political Science Association" 92 (92): 1-22, 1998

46 행정안전부, "2009년도 행정구역 요람" 행정안전부 2009