당파적 뉴스에 관한 제삼자 지각의 세 주요 결정 요인 = 뉴스의 바람직성에 대한 평가, 자신-타인 간 정치지식 지각격차, 자신-타인 간 비판적 이해능력 지각격차

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Previous studies highlighted social desirability of the message, social distance, ego-involvement, and social categorization as main determinants of the third-person perception about news. However, the variance explained by those variables was 14% of TPP at best. The present study proposed three main determinants of TPP: individual’s evaluation about message desirability, self-other perceptual gap in the level of knowledge about the issue, and self-other perceptual gap in critical information literacy. This study tested the effect of those three variables on the third-person perception about partisan news effect. The results of a nationwide online survey (N = 500) showed significant effects of those suggested three variables and the variance explained by those three variables was 19% for TPP in terms of general others and 26% for TPP in terms of conservative others. Theoretical implications about findings including the effect of self-other perceptual gap in critical information literacy were discussed.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 강명구, "한국 저널리즘 이론 : 뉴스, 담론" 나남 1994

2 정성은, "지지후보 우세 여부에 따른 선거 여론조사 보도의 영향력 지각 변화: 2012년 한국 대통령선거 상황을 이용한 실험 연구" 한국언론학회 58 (58): 365-395, 2014

3 정성은, "제삼자 지각 가설의 재구성: 메시지 강도, 관련 지식 보유 정도, 기존 태도를 중심으로" 한국언론학회 56 (56): 322-349, 2012

4 곽정원, "정치 팟캐스트의 제삼자 지각 영향 요인에 관한 연구 : 팟캐스트〈나는 꼼수다>의 영향력 지각을 중심으로" 한국언론학회 57 (57): 138-162, 2013

5 유홍식, "인터넷게임에 대한 제3자 편향적 지각과 규제 태도에 미치는 영향에 관한 연구" 한국지역언론학회 11 (11): 333-364, 2011

6 김옥태, "언론의 신종플루 보도가 대학생의예방위생 행동에 미치는 영향: 제3자 효과를 중심으로" 한국언론학회 54 (54): 344-367, 2010

7 유홍식, "악성 댓글에 대한 제3자 효과 연구" 한국방송학회 24 (24): 238-278, 2010

8 정다은, "설득 캠페인 효과 지각에서의 편향: 캠페인의 실제 효과와 지각된 효과 간 차이에 관한 연구" 한국언론학회 59 (59): 187-220, 2015

9 허유진, "미디어 메시지 효과 지각의 정확성 검증: 여론조사결과 보도로 인한 실제 태도변화와 지각된 태도변화의 비교" 한국언론학회 60 (60): 238-265, 2016

10 김정윤, "미디어 리터러시의 자본화: 미디어 리터러시의 개념 확장과 측정문항의 구성을 중심으로" 한국방송학회 32 (32): 5-32, 2018

11 오마이뉴스, "문재인, 이산가족상봉 우선권 받으려 나이 속였다?"

12 통일 뉴스, "문재인 후보, 2004년 이산가족상봉 특혜(?)"

13 김필재, "문재인 수석, 51세를 74세로 올려, 이산가족(이모) 상봉!"

14 Lambe, J. L., "Understanding third-person perception processes : Predicting perceived impact on self and others for multiple expressive contexts" 55 : 277-291, 2005

15 Sun, Y., "Understanding the third-person perception : Evidence from a meta-analysis" 58 : 280-300, 2008

16 Meirick, P. C., "Topic-relevant reference groups and dimensions of dimensions of distance : Political advertising and first and third-person effect" 54 : 234-255, 2004

17 Salwen, M. B., "Third-person perception of television violence : The role of self-perceived knowledge" 3 : 211-236, 2001

18 Price, V., "Third-person effects of news coverage : Orientations toward media" 74 : 525-540, 1997

19 Lo, V. H., "Third-person effect, gender, and pornography on the lnternet" 46 : 13-33, 2002

20 Zhang, L., "Third-person effect and gender in online gaming" 18 : 1-7, 2013

21 Lee, B., "Third-person effect and Internet pornography : The influence of collectivism and Internet self-efficacy" 55 : 292-310, 2005

22 Rucinski, D., "The ‘other’ as the vulnerable voter : A study of the third-person effect in the 1988 US presidential campaign" 2 : 345-368, 1990

23 Davison, W. P., "The third-person effect in communication" 4 : 1-15, 1983

24 Salwen, M. B., "The third-person effect : Perception of the media’s influence and immoral consequences" 26 : 523-549, 1999

25 Perloff, R. M., "The third-person effect : A critical review and synthesis" 1 : 353-378, 1999

26 Paul, B., "The third person effect : A meta-analysis of the perceptual hypothesis" 3 : 57-85, 2000

27 Innes, J. M., "The public's view of the impact of the mass media : A test of the"third person"effect" 18 : 457-463, 1988

28 Friestad, M., "The persuasion knowledge model : How people cope with persuasion attempts" 21 : 1-31, 1994

29 Duck, J. M., "The perceived influence of AIDS advertising : Third-person effects in the context of positive media content" 17 : 305-325, 1995

30 Brosius, H. B., "The causes of third-person effects : Unrealistic optimism, impersonal impact, or generalized negative attitudes towards media influence?" 8 : 142-162, 1996

31 Gunther, A. C., "The SAGE handbook of public opinion research" Sage 184-191, 2008

32 DellaVigna, S., "The Fox News effect : Media bias and voting" 122 : 1187-1234, 2007

33 EAVI, "Testing and refining criteria to assess media literacy levels in Europe (Final report)" European Commission 2011

34 Shah, D. V., "Susceptibility and severity : Perceptual dimensions underlying the third-person effect" 26 : 240-267, 1999

35 McLeod, D. M., "Support for censorship of violent and misogynic rap lyrics : An analysis of the third-person effect" 24 : 153-174, 1997

36 Hoffner, C., "Support for censorship of television violence : The role of the third-person effect and news exposure" 26 : 726-742, 1999

37 Hitchon, J. C., "Should women emote? Perceptual bias and opinion change in response to political ads for candidates of different genders" 14 : 49-69, 1997

38 Driscoll P. D., "Self-perceived knowledge of the O. J. Simpson trial : Third-person perception and perceptions of guilt" 74 : 541-556, 1997

39 Andsager, J. L., "Self versus others: Media, messages, and the third-person effect" Lawrence Erlbaum 2007

40 Douglas, K. M., "Right about others, wrong about ourselves? Actual and perceived self-other differences in resistance to persuasion" 43 : 585-603, 2004

41 Meirick, P. C., "Rethinking the target corollary : The effects of social distance, perceived exposure, and perceived predispositions on first-person and third-person perceptions" 32 : 822-843, 2005

42 Eveland Jr, W. P., "Rethinking the social distance corollary : Perceived likelihood of exposure and the third-person perception" 26 : 275-302, 1999

43 Lasorsa, D. L., "Real and perceived effects of “Amerika.”" 66 : 373-378, 1989

44 Boyle, M. P., "Preexisting factors or media effect? Understanding the third-person perception" 21 : 230-246, 2013

45 Hofstetter, C. R., "Political talk radio, situational involvement, and political mobilization" 79 : 273-286, 1998

46 Stroud, N. J., "Polarization and partisan selective exposure" 60 : 556-576, 2010

47 Miller, G. R., "Persuasion: New directions in theory and research" Sage 11-28, 1980

48 Salwen, M. B., "Perceptions of media influence and support for censorship : The third-person effect in the 1996 presidential election" 25 : 259-285, 1998

49 Gunther, A. C., "Perceived persuasive effects of product commercials and public service announcements : Third-person effects in new domains" 19 : 574-596, 1992

50 Cohen, J., "Perceived impact of defamation : An experiment on third-person effects" 52 : 161-173, 1988

51 Gunther, A. C., "Overrating the x-rating : The third-person perception and support for censorship of pornography" 45 : 27-38, 1995

52 Westerståhl, J., "Objective news reporting : General premises" 10 : 403-424, 1983

53 Shen, L, "Not all perceptual gaps were created equal:Explicating the third-person perception (TPP) as a cognitive fallacy" 2018

54 Taber, C. S., "Motivated skepticism in the evaluation of political beliefs" 50 : 755-769, 2006

55 Meirick, P. C., "Media schemas, perceived effects, and person perceptions" 83 : 632-649, 2006

56 Perloff, R. M., "Media effects: Advances in theory and research" Routledge 252-268, 2009

57 Price, V., "Measuring third-person effect of news : The impact of question order, contrast and knowledge" 8 : 120-141, 1996

58 Willnat, L., "Mass media and political outspokenness in Hong Kong : Linking the third-person effect and the spiral of silence" 8 : 187-212, 1996

59 Hollander, N. C., "Love in a time of hate: Liberation psychology in Latin America" Rutgers University Press 1997

60 Simmons, M. H., "Librarians as disciplinary discourse mediators : Using genre theory to move toward critical information literacy" 5 : 297-311, 2005

61 Chung, S., "Is the third-person effect real? A critical examination of rationales, testing methods, and previous findings of the third-person effect on censorship attitudes" 42 : 312-337, 2016

62 Atwood, L., "Illusions of media power : The third-person effect" 71 : 269-281, 1994

63 Halliday, D., "Fundamentals of physics" Wiley 1974

64 Rojas, J., "For the good of others : Censorship and the third-person effect" 8 : 163-186, 1996

65 Perloff, R. M., "Ego-involvement and the third person effect of televised news coverage" 16 : 236-262, 1989

66 Tiedge, J. T., "Discrepancy between perceived first-person and perceived third-person mass media effects" 68 : 141-154, 1991

67 Elmborg, J., "Critical information literacy : Implications for instructional practice" 32 : 192-199, 2006

68 Nir, L., "Campaign mixed-message flows and timing of vote decision" 20 : 326-346, 2008

69 Stroud, I., "Boundary representation modelling techniques" Springer Science & Business Media 2006

70 Gunther, A. C., "Biased optimism and third-person effect" 70 : 58-67, 1993

71 McLeod, D. M., "Behind the third‐person effect : Differentiating perceptual processes for self and other" 51 : 678-695, 2001

72 McGuire, W. J., "Anticipatory belief lowering following forewarning of a persuasive attack" 2 : 471-479, 1965

73 Chang, C., "Ambivalent versus univalent voters : Perceived media influences and third-person perceptions" 17 : 420-450, 2014

74 Dilliplane, S., "All the news you want to hear : The impact of partisan news exposure on political participation" 75 : 287-316, 2011

75 Reid, S. A., "A self-categorization explanation for the third-person effect" 31 : 129-161, 2005

76 Swanson, T. A., "A radical step : Implementing a critical information literacy model" 4 : 259-273, 2004