We need to understand students' proportional reasoning capability before we can teach more effectively the concept of functions to them as the seventh revised curriculum defines a function as a dependence relation that students experience in daily liv...
We need to understand students' proportional reasoning capability before we can teach more effectively the concept of functions to them as the seventh revised curriculum defines a function as a dependence relation that students experience in daily lives such as direct and inverse proportions. Therefore in this study, we investigate student's ideas about proportions formed before they begin to learn about functions, by analyzing the strategies they employ to solve problems related with proportions and by finding any relation between the students' ideas and approaches about proportions and their understanding of the notion of functions as a regular relation such as direct and inverse proportions.
The purpose of this study is thus to point out what to consider when we teach functions as dependence relations by understanding students' different ideas about functions depending on their different approaches to proportions. For this purpose, we present the following three research problems.
1. What strategies do the middle-grade students, who already learned ratio and proportions in the elementary schools, employ to solve proportion-related problems?
2. How the strategies that they employ to solve proportion-related problems are related with their understanding of functions?
3. What difficulties the students experience depending on their different strategies in solving proportion-related problems?
For this research problem, we needed first to stud middle-grade students' strategies in solving proportion-related problems before they learn about functions and direct and inverse proportions but learned simple equations. So 71 students in two classes were tested with an examination about proportions, and then, after learning functions, they were tested with another examination about proportions and an examination about functions. Based on the result about the previous examination, the students are classfied into three groups, and we investigated the differences in their ideas about functions in the three groups. Afterwards, 3-4 students were selected from each group, and the total of 10 students were interviewed individually to further investigate the differences in their understanding of the concept of functions.
A result on this study shows that the students who used `multiplication strategy' and `ratio strategy' in the previous examination on proportions tend to use `ratio strategy' and `equation strategy' after they learned functions. This need to be studied further because this may be due to the curriculum revision. The result that the students solved the inverse proportion problems more correctly by the `ratio strategy' rather than by the `equation strategy' shows that it is more useful to employ `equation strategy' when teaching functions with inverse proportions. The three groups classified according to the proportion strategies shows differences in perceiving the two variables involved in the proportion relation, and also in the formed notions of functions. These results imply that in teaching about functions with direct and inverse proportion relations, we need to take account of the characteristics of the different strategies formed in students. Moreover, a student may understand the definition of functions as proportion relations better if the teacher uses different strategies depending on each individual students' strategies.
However this study is limited because we generalized the tendencies shown in a small group of students and omitted the proportion level examination for precise analysis. Hence we propose a quantity study with a larger group of students, and a quality study probing more deeply with a few students with specific solution strategies.