최장집과 에티엔 발리바르 -민주주의의 민주화의 두 방향 = Choi Jangjib and Etienne Balibar: Two Directions in the Democratization of Democracy

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In this paper we try to compare Choi Jangjib``s theory of democracy with Etienne Balibar``s political philosophy of democracy. It``s usually thought that there are hardly any common features between the former who is a liberal theorist and the latter who is a well-known Marxist. But we believe that there are considerable common points between them: the idea of democratization of democracy, the insurrectional origin of democracy, the importance of representation in democracy, emphasis on the conflict in politics, and the stress on the political significance of social citizenship. But, in spite of this commonness, or because of that, there are also some remarkable differences between them which show their different conceptions of democracy. The following five features seem to us especially important: the difference in the conception of democratization of democracy, the exclusions which are proper to modern democracy, difference on the themes of the ideology and the subjectivation, extreme violences in politics, and the relation between the party and the mouvement. We think that these differences in commonness help to understand the difference between two theorists of democracy more precisely, and make possible to think the Korean democracy in another ways.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 진태원, "푸코와 민주주의: 바깥의 정치, 신자유주의, 대항품행" 철학연구소 29 : 153-188, 2012

2 진태원, "폭력과 시민다움" 난장 2012

3 진태원, "정치체에 대한 권리" 후마니타스 2011

4 E. E. 샤츠슈나이더, "절반의 인민주권" 후마니타스 2008

5 Louis Althusser, "재생산에 대하여" 동문선 2007

6 진태원, "우리, 유럽의 시민들?" 후마니타스 2010

7 최장집, "어떤 민주주의인가" 후마니타스 2007

8 진태원, "스피노자와 정치" 이제이북스 2005

9 진태원, "스피노자와 알튀세르에서 이데올로기의 문제 - 상상계라는 쟁점" 서양근대철학회 3 (3): 5-46, 2008

10 최장집, "비동시대성: 정치와 이데올로기, In 알튀세르와 마르크스주의의 전화" 이론 1993

11 최장집, "민중에서 시민으로: 한국 민주주의를 이해하는 하나의 방법" 돌베게 2009

12 최장집, "민주화 이후의 민주주의" 후마니타스 2010

13 최장집, "민주주의의 민주화" 후마니타스 2007

14 최장집, "대중들의 공포. 맑스 전과 후의 정치철학" 도서출판 2007

15 진태원, "관계론, 대중들, 민주주의: 에티엔 발리바르의 스피노자론" 시와 반시사 2010

16 최장집, "The Infinite Contradiction" (81) : 1995

17 최장집, "Race, nation, classe: Les Identités ambiguës" La Découverte 1988

18 최장집, "Philosophy and the Frontiers of the Political : A biographical-theoretical interview with Etienne Balibar" II (II): 2010

19 Fraisse, "Muse de la Raison. Démocratie et exclusion des femmes en France" Gallimard 1995

20 최장집, "Les frontieres de la democratie" Editions la Decouverte 1992

21 Pierre Rosanvallon, "Le Peuple introuvable: Histoire de la représentation démocratique en France" Gallimard 2002

22 최장집, "La proposition de l'egaliberte" PUF 2010

23 최장집, "L'Europe, l'Amerique, la guerre" La Decouverte 2003

24 최장집, "Historical Dilemmas of Democracy and Their Contemporary Relevance for Citizenship" 20 (20): 2008

25 최장집, "Entretien avec Etienne Balibar" (51) : 2010

26 최장집, "Borders, Citizenship, War, Class: A Discussion with Etienne Balibar and Sandro Mezzadra" (58) : 2007

27 Mezzadra, Sandro, "Borders, Citizenship, War, Class : A Discussion with Etienne Balibar and Sandro Mezzadra" (58) : 2007

28 Georges Laveau, "A quoi sert le Parti communiste francais?" Fayard 1981

29 Albert O, "A Propensity to Self-Subversion" Harvard University Press 1998