동북아 물류중심항만정책에 대한 프로그램논리모형의 설계 및 분석 = A Design and Analysis of the Program Logic Model for the Logistics-Hub Port Policy in the Northeast Asia

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The logistics-hub port policy focusing on Busan and Gwangyang ports has caused many debates about the feasibility and desirability of the policy. A program logic model was applied in the study to analyse the logistics-hub port policy of the Korean government. The results from applying the program logic model to the policy show that there are policy failures in two aspects.
First, in the policy implementation, 'principle of selection and concentration' was not carried out as scheduled by the government. In implementing the logistics-hub port policy, the share of investments in Busan and Gwangyang ports has been decreasing while those of other ports except Busan and Gwangyang has been increasing. This implies that the policy was equity-oriented which was driven by political forces. And the principle of increasing the budget of ports and railways but decreasing that of roads has been implemented as scheduled. But in terms of the economic feasibility on the principle, there is much doubt about that.
Second, in the policy design, the policy using the same instruments and measures toward Busan and Gwangyang ports seems to be very problematic. Especially, the policy whose goal is making Gwangyang the logistics-hub port in the Northeast Asia has many obstacles in terms of its desirability and feasibility. Developing a redesigned policy including industrial policies has been recommended to make Gwangyang a hub port in the Northeast Asia. Otherwise, the current policy for Gwangyang port needs to be modified.
This study tries to analyse the logical causality among inputs, activities, outputs, intial outcomes, intermediate outcomes, and final outcomes of the logistics-hub port policy. But it doesn't exceed beyond the exploratory study since developing a program logic model with high accuracy and evaluating logical causality of various elements are not so easy. And excluding the external elements-contextual factors and antecedent variables-is the limitation of this study. Therefore, it needs further study using many statistics data and precise econometric analysis.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Abstract
• Ⅰ. 서론
• Ⅱ. 선행연구와 프로그램논리모형
• Ⅲ. 프로그램논리모형의 설계와 분석
• Ⅳ. 결론
• <부록>
• 참고문헌

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 해양수산부, "해양수산백서 2004-2005" 2006

2 진형인, "한반도의 동북아 국제물류 중심화 전략" 한국해운학회 (22) : 1996

3 최석범, "한국의 동북아물류중심지화 전략에 따른 법률적 문제점과 해결방안" 한국해운물류학회 37 : 91-110, 2003

4 최석범, "한국의 동북아 물류중심로드맵 투자우선순위와 개선방안" 한국항만경제학회 20 (20): 187-216, 2004

5 동북아경제중심추진위원회, "참여정부의 국정비전-동북아 경제중심의 비전과 과제"

6 원동욱, "중국의 물류전략과 동북아 물류중심지론의 재검토" 극동문제연구소 21 (21): 157-190, 2005

7 노화준, "정책학 개론(제2전정판)" 박영사 2007

8 노화준, "정책 평가론(제4전정판)" 법문사 2006

9 국회예산정책처, "정부 저출산정책 평가"

10 강종희, "우리나라의 동북아 물류거점화전략과 관세자유지역제도의 발전방향" 한국무역상무학회 16 : 2001

11 이재기, "동북아허브 발전전략에 대한 고찰" 한국항만경제학회 19 (19): 159-175, 2003

12 한재호, "동북아 물류중심국가 실행을 위한 항만물류 경쟁력 확보 방안" 2005

13 박승락, "동북아 물류중심 달성을 위한 우리나라 항만의 배후단지 개발전략" 6 (6): 2005

14 고용기, "동북아 물류거점확보를 통한 신국제물류시스템 구축에 관한 연구: 수리모형 구축과 적용" 한국국제상학회 17 (17): 41-64, 2002

15 이강빈, "동북아 물류거점화를 위한 국제물류 경쟁력 제고방안" 한국국제상학회 17 (17): 2002

16 최석범, "동북아 경제중심추진상의 동북아 물류중심지화정책의 문제점과 개선방안" 한국국제상학회 19 (19): 125-150, 2004

17 남금식, "동북아 경제중심지로서의 우리나라 항만의 대응전략" 19 (19): 2004

18 오용석, "동북아 경제중심 정책의 과제와 전략" 2003

19 정봉민, "남북한 통합물류 체계 구축방안" 2008

20 손정락, "국제경쟁력 확보를 위한 항만개발정책의 방향-동북아 중심항만 경쟁에서의 항만 임계규모 및 환적화물 유치 영향요인 분석" 서울대학교 2008

21 최석범, "국내물류체계와 물류거점 실증분석을 통한 우리나라 동북아물류중심지화전략의 실행방안에 관한 연구" 한국무역학회 29 (29): 243-270, 2004

22 Poister, Theodore, "Measuring Performance in Public and Nonprofit Organization" Jossey-Bass 2003

23 Majone,Giandomenico, "Evidence, argument, and persuasion in the policy process" Yale University Press 1989

24 Jung,Bong Min, "Concentration and Hub Strategy of Container Ports" 2003