중기와 후기 듀이에서 반성적 사고의 일관성 = Consistency of Reflective Thinking in Dewey’s Middle and Later Works

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The purpose of this paper is to justify that ‘reflective thinking’ in Dewey’s philosophy continued until his later years. Of course, it cannot be denied that “Qualitative Thought”(1930) provided considerable insight to researchers in philosophy and the philosophy of education. Dewey’s approach emphasizes the “immediate presence of quality,” which is the background, starting point, and regulative principle of thinking. As such, qualitative thinking must have deepened his concept of thinking.
However, technical terms such as qualitative thought are not emphasized nor appeared in Dewey’s later works. This is primarily because qualitative thought was, above all, one stage or aspect included within reflective thought. And, Dewey’s reflective thinking signifies the establishment of beliefs grounded through conscious and voluntary effort or better way of thinking. In other words, we should not make the category mistake of understanding reflective thinking as ‘reflection’ in our everyday language.
Furthermore, another reason why ‘qualitative thought’ is not emphasized in later works is that the paper “Qualitative thought”(1930) may have been raised not primarily to deepen the details of reflective thought but also in the discourse dimension related to logic.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Dewey, John, "하우 위 싱크 : 과학적 사고의 방법과 교육" 학이시습 2011

2 이돈희, "질성적 사고와 교육적 경험" 학지사 2020

3 권영민, "인간의 자아는 어떻게 형성되는가 : 듀이의 자아개념과 질성적 사고 개념을 중심으로" 한국교육학회 56 (56): 25-45, 2018

4 박철홍, "듀이의 경험개념에 비추어 본 사고의 성격 : 이성적 사고와 질성적 사고의 통합적 작용" 한국교육철학학회 33 (33): 79-104, 2011

5 Dewey, John, "경험과 자연" 계명대학교출판부 1982

6 이돈희, "質性的 思考의 敎育的 價値" 한국교육학회 30 (30): 33-41, 1992

7 Dewey, John, "確實性의 探求" 백록 1992

8 Dewey, John, "思考하는 方法" 法文社 1979

9 Lipman, Matthew, "Thinking in Education" Cambridge University Press 1991

10 Dewey, John, "The Middle Works of John Dewey , 1899–1924, edited by Jo Ann Boydston, 15 vols" Southern Illinois University 1976

11 Dewey, John, "The Later Works of John Dewey , 1925–1953, edited by Jo Ann Boydston, 17 vols" Southern Illinois University 1981

12 Ryle, Gilbert, "The Concept of Mind" Barnes & Noble, Inc 1970

13 Shea, William M., "Qualitative Wholes: Aesthetic and Religious Experience in the Work of John Dewey" 60 (60): 32-50, 1980

14 Dewey, John., "Qualitative Thought" 243-262, 1930

15 Dewey, John, "Logic: The Theory of Inquiry" 1938

16 Pappas, Gregory Fernando, "John Dewey’s Radical Logic: The Function of the Qualitative in Thinking" 52 (52): 435-468, 2016

17 Johnston, James Scott, "John Dewey’s Later Logical Theory" SUNY Press 2021

18 Brigham, Don L., "Dewey’s Qualitative Thought as Exemplary Art Education" 42 (42): 14-22, 1989

19 MacKenzie, Matthew, "Dewey, Enactivism, and the Qualitative Dimension" 31 : 21-36, 2016