동일 기능 · 동일 리스크 · 동일 규제 적용에 대한 논리적 결함: 핀테크와 금융기관의 리스크 비교를 중심으로 = Logical Flaws in Applying the Same Business, Same Risks, Same Rules: Focusing on Comparing Risks Between Fintech and Financial Institutions

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study quantitatively compares and analyzes the financial risks between fintech companies and traditional financial institutions to examine the validity of the “same function, same risk, same regulation” principle and to discuss regulatory equity. The analysis revealed that major commercial banks exhibit higher credit risk, market risk, and operational risk compared to internet-only banks based on fintech, indicating that all key financial risks are more pronounced in commercial banks. Additionally, among non-core financial risks, liquidity risk, reputation risk, legal risk, and systemic risk were also found to be higher in commercial banks than in internet-only banks. However, in the case of concentration risk, internet- only banks showed higher levels than commercial banks. These findings suggest that it is not appropriate to apply uniform regulations to all financial institutions and highlight the necessity for differentiated regulatory approaches that reflect the unique characteristics of fintech companies. This research provides clear evidence for the regulatory equity debate between fintech and traditional financial institutions and could contribute to policymakers in establishing a more balanced regulatory framework.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 권용재 ; 전봉걸 ; 정승환, "핀테크의 시스템리스크에 대한 기여도: CoVaR를 이용한접근" 10 (10): 1-28, 2023

2 이준희 ; 송준혁, "핀테크 등장이 은행 및 저축은행 산업에 미치는 영향 분석" 22 (22): 271-282, 2022

3 전주용 ; 여은정, "인터넷전문은행 도입이 국내 은행산업에 미치는 영향: 산업조직론적 관점에서의 분석" 29 (29): 199-234, 2015

4 오상승 ; 손경국 ; 조근태, "빅테크 예탁금 보호 모델에 관한 연구" 14 (14): 271-292, 2022

5 Lin, E. M., "Systemic risk, financial markets, and performance of financial institutions" 262 : 579-603, 2018

6 Girardi, G., "Systemic risk measurement : Multivariate GARCH estimation of CoVaR" 37 (37): 3169-3180, 2013

7 Reboredo, J. C., "Systemic risk in European sovereign debt markets : A CoVaR-copula approach" 51 : 214-244, 2015

8 Das, S. R., "Systemic Risk and International Portfolio Choice" 59 (59): 2809-2834, 2004

9 Karimalis, E. N., "Measuring systemic risk in the European banking sector : a copula CoVaR approach" 24 (24): 944-975, 2018

10 Demir, A., "Fintech, financial inclusion and income inequality : a quantile regression approach" 28 (28): 86-107, 2022

11 Franco, L., "Does Fintech contribute to systemic risk? Evidence from the US and Europe" 2020

12 Adrian, Tobias, "CoVaR" 106 (106): 1705-1741, 2016

13 Adrian, T., "CoVaR" 2011

14 Bejar, P., "Can fintech foster competition in the banking system in Latin America and the Caribbean?" 3 (3): 100061-, 2022