사도세자에 대한 정신의학적 고찰 : 사도세자, 양극성 장애 환자인가 당쟁의 희생양인가 = A Psychiatric Approach to Prince Sado : A Bipolar Disorder Sufferer or a Victim of Party Strife

국문 초록 (Abstract)

사도세자의 죽음에 대하여 그가 당쟁의 희생양이었다는견해와 그의 정신병적 증상이 원인이었다는 견해가 있는데,이에 대해서는 여전히 논란이 있다. 본 연구에서는 사도세자에 관한 문헌을 검토하여 사도세자의 정신증상 여부에 대하여 정신의학적으로 고찰해 보았다. 사도세자의 언행에 대해상세히 기술되어 있는 한중록을 중심으로 검토한 결과, 사도세자는 여러 차례의 우울삽화 및 조증삽화를 겪었으며, 기분삽화가 재발과 관해를 반복하는 경과를 보였던 것으로 생각된다. 그의 직계가족을 중심으로 가족들의 정신증상 유무에대하여 조사한 결과 기분장애의 가족력 또한 배제할 수 없었다. 이를 토대로 볼 때 사도세자에게 양극성 장애가 있었을가능성이 높은 것으로 생각된다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Objectives Prince Sado was the tragic royal heir who was sealed in a rice chest and starved to death by his father, King Yeongjo. The question of whether he was a victim of party strife or his death was the result of his psychiatric disorder is still controversial. In this paper, we investigated the question of whether he had suffered from bipolar disorder by reviewing his psychiatric symptoms and family history.
Methods We examined the available literature on Prince Sado and his family, particularly focusing on Hanjungnok (Memoirs of Lady Hyegyeong), written by Prince Sado’s wife.
Results Review of the literature showed that Prince Sado suffered from psychiatric symptoms, including depressed mood, anxiety, suicidal behavior, aggressive behavior, and persecutory delusion from the age of 13 to 27. Many of his symptoms match the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders’ criteria for depressive and manic episodes and it is highly suspected that he had bipolar disorder. He also showed clothing phobia, which can be regarded as an obsessive compulsive symptom. Some of his relatives, King Gyeongjong and Sanggyegun, might have suffered from depressive disorder.
Conclusion The characteristics of his symptoms suggest that Prince Sado might have had bipolar disorder. His mental disorder might explain in part the cause of his death.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Lee DI., "The world dreamed by Prince Sado." Wisdomhouse 53-54, 2011

2 Lee DI., "The world dreamed by Prince Sado" Wisdomhouse 57-67, 2011

3 Lee DI., "The world dreamed by Prince Sado" Wisdomhouse 259-, 2011

4 Lee DI, "The world dreamed by Prince Sado" Wisdomhouse 212-253, 2011

5 Lee DI, "The world dreamed by Prince Sado" Wisdomhouse 45-46, 2011

6 Lee DI., "The world dreamed by Prince Sado" Wisdomhouse 115-, 2011

7 Choe OH, "The Vice and Punishment of Sodoseja" 24 : 109-141, 2001

8 Kim SY, "The Political Situation at the Middle of King Yongjo’s Age and ‘Imohwabeon’." 43 : 57-94, 2002

9 "The Annals of King Yeongjo (Yeongjosillok), vol.99, the 2nd article of (leap month) May 13th of Yeongjo 38th year (1762)"

10 "The Annals of King Yeongjo (Yeongjosillok), vol.78, the 1st article of November 27th of Yeongjo 28th year (1752)"

11 "The Annals of King Yeongjo (Yeongjosillok), vol.67, the 2nd article of June 24th of Yeongjo 24th year (1748)"

12 "The Annals of King Yeongjo (Yeongjosillok), vol. 100, the 2nd article of August 26th of Yeongjo 38th year (1762)"

13 "The Annals of King Sukjong (Sukjongsillok), vol.3, the 2nd article of March 14th of Sukjong 1st year (1675)"

14 "The Annals of King Sukjong (Sukjongsillok), vol.3, the 1st article of April 1st of Sukjong 1st year (1675)"

15 "The Annals of King Sukjong (Sukjongsillok), vol.22, the 2nd article of September 16th of Sukjong 16th year (1690)"

16 "The Annals of King Jeongjo (Jeongjosillok), vol.4, the 2nd article of October 26th of Jeongjo 1st year (1777)"

17 "The Annals of King Jeongjo (Jeongjosillok), vol.23, the 6th article of January 19th of Jeongjo 11th year (1787)"

18 "The Annals of King Injo (Injosillok), vol.42, the 1st article of July 10th of Injo 19th year (1641)"

19 "The Annals of King Gyeongjong (Gyeongjongsillok), vol.12, the 3rd article of May 12th of Gyeongjong 3rd year (1723)"

20 Hales RE, "The American Psychiatric Publishing Textbook of Psychiatry" American Psychiatric Association 331-, 2014

21 Korean Neuropsychiatric Association, "Textbook of neuropsychiatry" 185-, 2005

22 "Seonwongyebodo"

23 Lee BW, "Psychoanalytic Note on the Death of Prince Sado" 15 : 228-238, 2004

24 Lee SG. Dr, "Lee’s ‘King’s Oriental medicine’" Shindonga 454-463, 2013

25 Sadock BJ, "Kaplan and Sadock’s Synopsis of Psychiatry:Behavioral Sciences/Clinical Psychiatry" Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Wolters Kluwer Business 529-, 2007

26 Sadock BJ, "Kaplan and Sadock’s Synopsis of Psychiatry: Behavioral Sciences/Clinical Psychiatry" Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Wolters Kluwer Business 532-, 2007

27 Jeong BS, "Humanities lecture Oriental classics" Book21 149-174, 2013

28 Park YK., "History of Chosun Kings" Woongjinjisikhouse 374-, 2004

29 Park YK, "History of Chosun Kings" Woongjinjisikhouse 368-, 2004

30 Park YK, "History of Chosun Kings" Woongjinjisikhouse 422-, 2004

31 Park YK., "History of Chosun Kings" Woongjinjisikhouse 314-, 2004

32 Park YK, "History of Chosun Kings" Woongjinjisikhouse 403-, 2004

33 Park YK, "History of Chosun Kings" Woongjinjisikhouse 480-, 2004

34 Jeon YJ, "Hangukgojeonmunhakseon II, III" Hongsinmunhwasa 61-146, 2002

35 "Encyclopedia of Korean Culture"

36 "Doopedia [homepage on the internet]"

37 "Doopedia [homepage on the internet]"

38 "Doopedia [homepage on the internet]"

39 "Doopedia"

40 "Doopedia"

41 "Doopedia"

42 Nam ES., "Analysis of Prince Sado’s Family Using Bowen’s Theory-Based on Causes of Prince Sado’s Pathological Problem from ‘The Memoirs of Lady Hye Kyung’-" Sangmyung Univ 2007

43 Nam ES., "Analysis of Prince Sado’s Family Using Bowen’s Theory-Based on Causes of Prince Sado’s Pathological Problem from ‘The Memoirs of Lady Hye Kyung’-" Sangmyung Univ 2007

44 Lee HW, "A Study on the Diseases of King Hyeonjong, Sukjong, Gyeongjong, Yeongjo in the Joseon Dynasty" Dongeui Univ 2005