Regional Housing Needs Assessment, 2014-2021 - The Southern California Approach -

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

California housing element law requires that the California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) quantify regional housing needs, and the Council of Governments (COG) allocate the region’s share of the statewide need to cities and counties within their region. The regional housing needs assessment (RHNA) allocation process establishes minimum housing development capacity that cities and counties are to make available via their land use powers to accommodate growth within a short-term planning period. RHNA numbers are assigned by four income categories as guideposts for each community to develop a mix of housing types for all economic segments of the population. This paper explores how Southern California Association of Governments (SCAG) developed its 5th cycle RHNA allocation plan, January 1, 2014-October 1, 2021, for 191 cities and 6 counties in the SCAG region. The paper reviews the SCAG approach toward developing the key elements of the RHNA allocation plan: process, methodologies, and social equity policy. The paper identifies three major approaches toward a successful RHNA outcome and discusses the important housing and urban issues for further study in the future.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Ong, Paul, "The State of Southern California’s Housing" UCLA-Ralph&Goldy Lewis Center for Regional Policy Studies 2004

2 Connerly, C.E., "The Prospects for Fair Share Housing Policy in Florida" 1994

3 Levy, D. K., "The Performance of Non-profit Housing Developments in the United States" 16 (16): 595-618, 2001

4 Kono, S., "The Headship Rate Method for Projecting Households, In Family Demography: Methods and Their Application" ClarendonPress 1987

5 Plane, D.A, "The Geographical Analysis of Population with Application to Planning and Business" John Wiley & Sons 1994

6 Hays, R. A., "The Federal Government and Urban Housing" State University of New York Press 1995

7 Center for Transit Oriented Development, "The Afford ability Index ToolBox: New Tool For Measuring The True Afford ability Of Housing Choices, And Other Tools To Promote Afford ability" Southern California Association of Governments 2008

8 Federal Housing Administration, "Techniques of Housing Market Analysis" U.S.Department of Housing and Urban Development

9 Southern California Association of Governments, "State of the Region 2007" Southern California Association of Governments 2007

10 Smith, S. K., "State and Local Population Projections: Methodology and Analysis" Kluwer Academic / Plenum Publishers 2001

11 California Department of Housing and Community Development, "State Housing Element Law" Housing Policy Development Division 2005

12 California Department of Housing and Community Development, "Regional Housing Need Determination" Housing Policy Development Division 2006

13 Mitchell, J., "Regional Fair Share Housing in California" 1994

14 Melendez, E., "Reassessing the Role of Housing in Community-Based Urban Development" 18 (18): 751-783, 2007

15 National Congress for Community Economic Development, "Reaching New Heights" National Congress for Community Economic Development 2005

16 California Department of Housing and Community Development, "Raising the Roof-California Housing Development Projections and Constraints 1997-2020" Housing Policy Development Division 2000

17 Rosenthal, L. A., "Priced High on a Hill : A Study of Housing Afford ability in San Francisco" National Association of Realtors, National Center for Real Estate Research 2003

18 Nelson, Arthur C., "Planner’s Estimating Guide Projecting Land-Use and Facility Needs" Planners Press, American Planning Association 2004

19 National Low Income Housing Coalition, "Out of Reach 2007-2008" National Low Income Housing Coalition 2008

20 Los Angeles Unified School District, "New Release: State Releases Graduation Rates for 2006-2007"

21 Warner, K., "New Approaches to the Housing Element: Case Studies from California, Nevada and Washington State" 1997

22 Walker, C., "National Support for Local System Change: The Effect of the National Community Development Initiative on Community Development Systems" The Urban Institute 2002

23 Carreras, J., "Modification of Optimal Vacancy Model" Southern California Association of Governments 1993

24 Florida Department of Community Affairs, "Model Housing Element" State of Florida 1987

25 Housing Division, "Memo : Housing Report-2000 Commission" State of Oregon 1985

26 California Budget Project (CBP), "Locked Out 2004: California's Affordable Housing Crisis" CBP 2004

27 Johnson, H., "In Short Supply? Cycles and Trends in California Housing" Public Policy Institute of California 2004

28 Baer, W. C., "Housing in an Internationalizing Region: Housing Stock Dynamics in Southern California and the Dilemmas of Fair Share" 4 : 337-349, 1986

29 Southern California Association of Governments, "Housing Southern Californians." Southern California Association of Governments 1999

30 Landis, J. D., "Housing Planning and Policy, In The Practice of Local Government Planning" International City and County Management Association 2000

31 Mayer, N., "Housing Partnerships: the Work of Large-Scale Regional Nonprofits in Affordable Housing" Housing Partnership Network 2007

32 Myers, D., "Housing Market Trends and Future Needs" Southern California Association of Governments 1993

33 Lopez-Aqueres, W., "Housing California’s Latino Population in the 21st Century: The Challenge Ahead" Tomas Rivera Policy Institute 2002

34 Kim, H., "Household Projections in the Republic of Korea .Research-Based Training Programme"

35 Fulton, W. and Shigley, P., "Guide to California Planning" Solano Press Book 2005

36 Ascher, W., "Forecasting : An Appraisal for Policy-Makers and Planners" Johns Hopkins University Press 1978

37 Southern California Association of Governments, "Final 2008 Regional Transportation Plan : Making the Connections" Southern California Association of Governments 2008

38 Myers, D., "Estimation of Housing Needs amid Population Growth and Change" 13 (13): 567-596, 2002

39 Office of Planning and Research, "Economic Practices Manual" State of California 1978

40 New Jersey Department of Community Affairs, "Draft State of New Jersey Comprehensive Housing Afford ability Strategy(CHAS)" State of New Jersey 1991

41 California Department of Housing and Community Development, "Developing A Regional Housing Needs Plan" Housing Policy Development Division 1988

42 Curtin, D. J., "Curtin’s California Land Use and Planning Law" Solano Press Books 2006

43 Erickson, D. J., "Caring Capitalism: How Housing Advocates Joined Government and the Private Sectorto Create New Low-Income Housing Policy, 1968-1993" Institute of Business and Economic Research, University of California 2004

44 Lewis, P. G., "Can State Review of Local Planning Increase Housing Production?" 16 (16): 173-200, 2005

45 California Department of Housing and Community Development, "California’s Housing Markets 1990-97" Housing Policy Development Division 1999

46 Baer, W. C., "California's Fair-Share Housing 1967—2004: The Planning Approach" 7 (7): 48-71, 2008

47 Southern California Association of Non-Profit Housing (SCANPH), "Affordable Housing 101: Why do we need affordable housing?" SCANPH 2005

48 Carreras, J., "Addressing Regional Housing Needs: Overview of RHNA Methodology, Requirements, and Policy Decisions" Southern California Association of Governments 2007

49 Singler, B. S., "A Systematic Approach to Housing Market Analysis, In Readings in Market Research for Real Estate" American Institute of Real Estate Appraisers 1985

50 Coy, P., "A Growing Tide of Risky Mortgages"

51 Southern California Association of Governments, "2012-2035RTP / SCS" Southern California Association of Governments 2012

52 Southern California Association of Governments, "2008-09 Your Guide to SCAG" Southern California Association of Governments 2008

53 Southern California Association of Governments, "2007 Integrated Growth Forecast Process and Final Allocation Methodology for Regional Housing Needs Allocation(RHNA), Approved by the Regional Council" Southern California Association of Governments 2007