물질문화의 고고학적 이해와 미술사 = Archaeological Understanding of Material Culture and Art History

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This article attempts to examine various archaeological approaches hitherto developed for a better interpretation of material culture with reviewing the main paradigm shifts in archaeology, for example, Antiqurianism, Culture-Historical approach, Processual approach, Post-Processual approach. In particular, it is discussed that material culture could be understood as playing an active role in diverse social change rather than a mere record to reflect the past human behaviour, which has been suggested in recent post-processual approaches. Concomitantly, it is explored to how archaeology could suggest a new perspective on the research of the past and the present material culture, based upon a close investigation on various theoretical views with their limits. For example, Marxism and its influence enable us to understand any social change in reference to ideology, power, and hegemony. It is, however, suspicious that there is any essential reality masked by ideology in material culture. It is also stressed that structuralism provides us with a platform to grasp the meaning of material culture and related social action. In spite of its huge impact on archaeological interpretation, it is unlikely that some of the main methodological premise such as binary opposition and arbitrariness should be adopted into the interpretation very carefully. As a result, it is emphasized that archaeology could contribute to a new and better understanding of material culture by way of frequent interchange with other disciplines such as philosophy, sociology and art history as well as systemisation and sophistication of the existing approaches. In addition, classification system of material culture including typology and style is critically reviewed, focusing on how it could be grasped in life world of the period. It is also argued that as an alternative, material culture needs to be comprehended in terms of category and categorisation.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이남인, "현상학과 해석학" 서울대학교 출판부 2004

2 권택영, "도난당한 편지에 대한 세미나 in: 자크 라캉: 욕망이론" 문예출판사 96-134, 1993

3 김종일, "고고학적 범주화의 철학적 탐구" 서울경기고고학회 7 (7): 51-68, 2008

4 김종일, "고고학의 철학적 토대" 한국고고학회 52 : 5-33, 2004

5 김종일, "경관고고학의 이론적 특징과 적용 가능성" 한국고고학회 (58) : 110-145, 2006

6 Kim, Jong-Il, "ormation and Change in Individual Identity between the Bell Beaker Culture and the Early Bronze Age in Bavaria" Archaeopress 2005

7 Thomas, Julian, "Time, Culture & Identity" Routledge 1996

8 Hodder, Ian, "Theory and Practice in Archaeology" Routledge 1992

9 Ingold, Tim, "The Perception of the Environment" Routledge 2000

10 Sackett, James R., "The Meaning of Style: a General Model" 42 : 369-380, 1977

11 Kehoe, Alice Beck, "The Land of Prehistory" Routledge 1998

12 Hodder, Ian, "The Domestication of Europe" Blackwell 1990

13 Giddens, Anthony, "The Constitution of Society: outline of the theory of Structuration" Polity Press 1984

14 Gräslund, Bo., "The Birth of Prehistoric Chronology" Cambridge University Press 1987

15 Hegmon, Michelle, "Technologies, Style, and Social Practice: Archaeological Approaches in: The Archaeology of Social Boundaries" Smithsonian Institution Press 264-279, 1998

16 Wobst, H. Martin, "Stylistic behaviour and information exchange in: in For the Director: Research Essays in Honor of James B. Griffin" 61 : 317-342, 1977

17 Wiessner, Polly, "Style and social information in Kalahari San projectile points" 49 : 253-276, 1983

18 Spaulding, Albert C., "Statistical Techniques for the Discovery of Artefact Types" 18 : 305-313, 1953

19 Shanks, Michael, "Social Theory and Archaeology" Polity 1987

20 Shanks, Michael, "Reconstructing Archaeology" Cambridge University Press 1987

21 Hodder, Ian, "Reading the past" Cambridge University Press 2-, 1991

22 Childe, V. Gordon, "Piecing together" Routledge 1956

23 Bourdieu, Pierre, "Outline of theory of Practice" Cambridge University Press 1977

24 Tilley, Christopher, "Michel Foucault: Towards Archaeology of Archaeology" Blackwell 281-347, 1990

25 Tilley, Christopher, "Metaphor and Material Culture" Blackwell 1999

26 Ford, James A., "In favor of simple typology" 27 : 113-114, 1961

27 Shanks, Michael, "Ideology, Symbolic Power and Ritual Communication: a Reinterpretation of Neolithic Mortuary Practice in: Symbolic and Structural Archaeology" Cambridge University Press 129-154, 1982

28 Dietler, Michael, "Habitus, Techniques, Style in: in The Archaeology of Social Boundaries" Smithsonian Institution Press 232-264, 1998

29 Watson, Patty Jo, "Explanation in Archaeology" Columbia University Press 1971

30 Montelius, Oscar, "Die typologische Methode. Die ältere kulturperioden im Orient und in Europa I" Stockholm 1903

31 Ford, James A., "Comment on A.C. Spaulding, Statistical techniques for the discovery of artefact types" 19 : 390-391, 1954

32 Heidegger, Martin, "Being and Time" Blackwell 1976

33 Jones, Si?n, "Archaeology of Ethnicity" Routledge 1997

34 Adams, W. Y., "Archaeological Typology and Practical Reality" Cambridge University Press 1991

35 Johnson, Mathew, "Archaeological Theory" Archaeological Theory 1999

36 Hegmon, Michelle, "Archaeological Research on style" 21 : 517-536, 1992

37 Sackett, James R., "Approaches to Style in Lithic Archaeology" 1 : 59-112, 1982

38 O’Brien, Michael J., "Applying Evolutionary Archaeology: A Systematic Approach" Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers 2000

39 Binford, Lewis, "An Archaeological Perspective" Seminar Press 1972

40 Lacan, Jacques. E´ crits, "A selection" Routledge

41 Tilley, Christopher, "A Phenomenology of Landscape" Berg 1994

42 Trigger, Bruce, "A History of Archaeological thought" Cambridge University Press 1989