바르가논쟁의 재고, 1941-1949

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This article is an attempt to reassess the so-called Varga controversy that took place in the Soviet academia in the postwar period through newly available Russian archival documents. From 1947 to 1949, Evgenii Varga, a top Soviet economist and Stalin's economic advisor, was subject to extensive criticism for his "revisionist" ideas on postwar Western economy expressed in the 1946 book entitled Changes in the Economy of Capitalism as a Result of the Second World War. Subsequently, his prominent institute, the Institute of World Economy and World Politics, was disbanded and its authoritative journal ceased to be published. The Controversy has been an important subject for Soviet historians and the Cold War experts as it was believed to reflect Stalin's new course in the impending Cold War. More specifically, the fall of Varga and his institute, according to the previous studies, demonstrates the dictator's ideological hysteria against the Soviet intellectuals and his hard line policy towards the Western world.
Based on previously inaccessible archival materials, the article attempts to revise the previous studies' account by placing the Controversy in a longer time-frame and a broader context. A marked attack on Varga and his institute already existed in early 1941, six years before the Cold War started, and just reemerged in 1943 and 1947. They had not stemmed from clear-cut ideological and theoretical difference between orthodox Leninism and revisionism, but from complicated factors reflecting the context of the Soviet politics, culture and society. The fall of Varga and his institute was not directly connected to their economic theory, which had never been questioned by Stalin. The real source for their fall lay in the nationalistic/chauvinistic sentiments of Andrei Zhdanov and his followers in the Party leadership who had been seriously bothered by the fact that the institute was filled with the old, foreign and Jewish scholars. For the Zhdanovites, these academicians did not deserve to undertake the key tasks for the party-state as they were politically unreliable and not capable of promoting Russian values.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Ⅰ. 서론
• Ⅱ. 1947년 이전
• Ⅲ. 1947
• Ⅳ. 1947년 이후
• Ⅴ. 결론
• [참고문헌]
• [Abstract]

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Kojevnikov, "“Games of Stalinist Democracy: Ideological Discussions in Soviet Sciences, 1947-52,” in Stalinism: New Directions" Routledg 2000

2 Печатнов, "Трумен: СССР и США в 1940-х гг"

3 Костырченко, "Тайная политика Сталина: Власть и антисемит-изм"

4 Маневич, "Сталинизм и политическая экономика"

5 "Советско-Американские отношенения, 1945-1948"

6 Нежинский, "Советская внешная политика в годы “холодной войны” (1945-1985)"

7 Варга, Е., "Изменения в ёкономике капитализма в итоге второй мировой войны"

8 Черкасов, "ИМЕМО: Портрет на фоне ерохи"

9 Варга, Е., "Вскрыть через 25 лет"

10 "Война и инфлация: Записка академика И. А. Трахтенверга. 1947 г."

11 Вознесенский, "Военная экономика СССР в период отечественной войны"

12 Каплан, "Важнейшие совытия международной жизни и деятельности Института мирового хозяйства и мировой политика"

13 Академия наук в решениях политвюро ЦК РКП(б), "БКП(б) – КПСС, 1922-1991"

14 "Unpublished Ph.D Dissertation of UC Berkeley"

15 de Coppet, "Understanding Rituals" Routledge 1992

16 Barghoorn, "The Varga Discussion and Its Significance in American Slavic and East European Review 7" Cambridge University Press 1948

17 Hough, "The Struggle for the Third World : Soviet Debates and American Options"

18 Axelrod, "The Soviet Union and the Bretton Woods: A Re-Examination of Soviet Post-War Intentions, Slovo 8, no. 1"

19 Pollock, "The Politics of Knowledge: Party Ideology and Soviet Science, 1945-1953"

20 Boterbloem, "The Life and Times of Andrei Zhdanov, 1896-1948" McGill-Queen’s University Press 2004

21 Wohlforth, "The Elusive Balance: Power and Perceptions during the Cold War" Cornell University Press 1993

22 Roberts, "Stalin’s Wars: From World War to Cold War, 1939-1953" Yale University Press 2006

23 Taubman, "Stalin’s American Policy: From Entente to Détente to Cold War" W. W. Norton & Company 1982

24 Roh, "Stalin's Think Tank: The Varga Institute and the Making of the Stalinist Idea of World Economy and Politics, 1927-1953"

25 Getty, "Stalin as Prime Minister: Power and the Politburo,” in Stalin: A New History" Cambridge University Press 2005

26 Leo Gruliow, "Soviet Views on the Post-war World Economy: An Official Critique of Eugene Varga’s 'Changes in the Economy of Capitalism Resulting from the Second World War,'" Public Affairs Press 1948

27 Marantz, "Soviet Foreign Policy Factionalism under Stalin? A Case Study of the Inevitability of War Controversy"

28 Getty, "Samokritika Rituals in the Stalinist Central. Committee, 1933–1938"

29 Unfried, "Rituale von Konfession und Selbstkritik: Bilder vom stalinistischen Kader"

30 Hahn, "Postwar Soviet Politics : The Fall of Zhdanov and the Defeat of Moderation, 1946-1953" Cornell University Press 1982

31 Duda, "Jenö Varga und die Geschichte des Instituts für Weltwirtschaft und Weltpolitik in Moskau 1921-1970"

32 Ra’anan, "International Policy Formation in the USSR: Factional “Debates” during the Zhdanovschina" Archon Books 1983

33 Griffiths, "Images, Politics and Learning in Soviet Behavior toward the United States"

34 Day, "Cold War Capitalism: The View from Moscow, 1945-1975" M. E. Sharpe 1995

35 Gorlizki, "Cold Peace: Stalin and the Soviet Ruling Circle, 1945–1953" Oxford University Press 2004

36 Haslam, ""The Making of Foreign Policy under Stalin,” in Empire and Society : New Approaches to Russian Histor"