새로운 受援國(recepient states) 모델과 북한 = The New Recipient States Model and North Korea

국문 초록 (Abstract)

취약국가(fragile states)란 용어는 2001년 9.11 테러사건을 기점으로 주목을 받기 시작한 것이다. 미국중심의 기존 국제질서에 새로운 과제와 파문을 일으켰던 9.11 테러사건은 이후 테러리즘의 온상으로서의 취약국가를 어떻게 포위하고 다룰 것인가하는 문제를 국가안보 내지 국제안보문제 차원에서 취급하게 하였으며, 이 문제는 비핵확산문제, 군비통제문제, 테러리즘 근절문제 등과 결부되고 내적으로는 군사적 개입문제와 인도주의적 문제 등이 복잡하게 연계되게 하였다. 이런 점에서 9. 11 테러사건은 기존 국제경제론에서 주로 광범위하게 사용되던 최빈개도국(Least Developed Countries)의 카테고리를 좀 더 국제정치론 쪽으로 경도된 취약국가론의 카테고리로 이동시키게 했으며, 이제 취약국가론은 21세기 새로운 국제질서와 안보환경을 아우르는 핵심적 주제로 부각되었다고 해도 과언이 아니다.
본 논문은 우선 국제개발기구 등에서 통용되는 ‘취약국가’의 모델을 분석하여 북한을 국제개발협력적 차원의 수원국으로서의 지위를 타진해본다. 대체로 국제사회에서 통용되는 개발협력적 모델은 UN, OECD/DAC, 세계은행 등의 모형을 기준으로 하고 있으나, 이들은 북한 등과 같이 개발협력의 능력은 있으나, 여러 가지 이유에서 의지가 미흡한 국가들을 포괄하는 모델로서는 취약하였다. 이런 점에서 본 논문은 이들을 포괄할 수 있는 새로운 모형을 제시하였으며, 향후 북한이 국제개발협력적 수원국으로서의 지위를 얻기위한 방안과 관련하여 남북협력기금의 ODA 규범 준용과 함께 새로운 한국형 ODA의 모형을 제안하고 있다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The events of September 11, 2001 taught us that fragile states, like Afghanistan, can pose as great a danger to our worldwide security as strong states. Poverty may not turn people intoterrorists, but poverty, weak institutions and corruption can make fragile states vulnerable to terrorist networks and cycle of mediocre. As result of that, nowadays the term of ‘fragile state’is more useful concept that it of ‘Least Developed Countries’ in world politics.
Nowadays international official development assistance institutions such as, the World Bank Groups, OECD/DAC, UN, and Asian Development Bank are trying to recipient states with grants or confessional funds for development assistance. Nevertheless, such assistance targeted at national development is being hindered for various reasons. North Korea, has difficulties in accessing these grant funds due to problems in the provision of standards. Can North Korea has the status as fragile state which has been recognized as recipient state nowadays?
This study compared various different models with the World Bank or OECD/DAC models. It focused on some difficult partnership states such as in North Korea, Myanmar and Zimbabwe. This model may enable the transfer of ODA funds to difficult partnership states by using the ODA tool.
This thesis recommends that because North Korea is a sort of ‘difficult partnership states’, South Korea must not close thechannel for North Korea according to OECD/DAC tips. Maintaining channel can help North Korea not to slide into deadlock and system breakdown. And this thesis also recommends a new paradigm for helping North Korea. That is the way to utilize the Cooperative Mutual Fund for South and North Korea considering with ODA of OECD.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• 국문요약
• I. 서 론
• Ⅱ.기존의 수원국 모델과 취약국가
• Ⅲ.취약국가 유형에 따른 개발지원전략과 북한
• Ⅴ.결론 및 제언
• 참고문헌
• Abstrac

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 조 민, "한반도 평화체제 구축방향: 평화 프로세스 in: 2.13 합의와 한반도 평화체제 구축"

2 전승훈, "우리나라 무상원조 사업의 중장기 정책 및 전략" 한국국제협력단(KOICA) 보고서 2006

3 장형수, "북한의 테러지원국 해제문제와 국제금융기구 in: 한국개발연구원(편)" 2008

4 장형수, "북한과 국제금융기구: 이슈와 대응 in: 수은북한경제"

5 이조원, "북한개발협력의 과제 연구: 국제적 차원의 개발협력 준용을 중심으로" (17) : 2007

6 이재룡, "북한개발자금 조달과 국제금융기구의 역할"

7 장형수, "북한 개발 지원을 위한 국제협력 방향 : 재원조달 방안을 중심으로" 통일연구원 17 (17): 315-338, 2008

8 이조원, "북한 ODA의 실현가능성과 조건 in: 북한 ODA(공적개발원조) 그것은 가능한가?" 중앙대 민족통일연구소 2008

9 국무총리 국무조정실, "국제개발협력 개선방안"

10 박형중, "구호와 개발 그리고 원조" 해남 2007

11 CIA, "World Factbook"

12 World bank, "World Development Report, 2006: Equity and Development Overview" International Bank for Reconstruction and Development/World Bank

13 World Bank IEG, "World Bank IEG,2006,"2006 Annual Report on Operations Evaluation".Available at"

14 OECD, "Working for Development in Difficult Partnerships"

15 United Kingdom, "Why We Need to Work More Effectively in Fragile States" DFID

16 Rajan, Raghuram G, "What Undermines Aid's Impact on Growth" International Monetary Fund

17 Patrick, Stewart, "Weak States and Global Threats: Fack or Fiction?" 29 (29): 2006

18 USAID, "U.S. Foreign Aid: Meeting the Challenges of the Twenty -first Century" USAID

19 BMZ- Federal Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Development, "Transforming Fragile States- Examples of Practical Experience"

20 Gros, Jean - Germain, "Towards a Taxonomy of Failed States in the New World Order: Decaying Somalia, Liberia, Rwanda and Haiti" 17 (17): 1998

21 Central Intelligence Agency, "The World Factbook 2007"

22 World bank, "The World Bank Group"

23 Sachs, Jeffrey D, "The Strategic Significance of Global Inequality" Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, Environmental Change and Security

24 Rotberg, Robert I, "The New Nature of Nation-State Failure" 25 (25): 2002

25 Saikal, Amin, "The Dimensions of State Disruption". From Civil Strife to Civil Society: Civil and Military Responsibilities in Disrupted States" United Nations University Press 2002

26 Spanger, Hans-Joachim, "The Ambiguous Lessons of State Failure" 2001

27 Goldstone, Jack A, "State Failure Task Force Report: Phase III Findings" Science Applications International Corporation

28 Esty, Eaniel C, "State Failure Task Force Report: Phase II Findings. McLean" Science Applications International Corporation.

29 Hentz, James J, "State Collapse and Regional Contagion in Sub-Saharan Africa Lessons for Zimbabwe" 32 (32): 2004

30 Haas, Richard N, "Sovereignty: Existing Rights, Evolving Responsibilities" Department of State

31 Krasner, "Sharing Sovereignty: New Institutions for Collapsed and Failing States" 29 (29): 2004

32 Helman, Gerald B., "Saving Failed State" 89 : 1992

33 Herbst, Jeffrey, "Responding to state Failure in Africa" 21 (21): 1996

34 UN, "Report of the International Conference on Finacing for Development" 2002

35 Brinkerhoff Defick W, "Reestablishing security, rebuilding effectiveness, and reconstituting legitimacy in Governance in Post Conflict Society: Rebuilding fragile states" Routledge 2007

36 Francois, M, "Promoting Stability and Development in Fragile and Failed States" 24 (24): 2006

37 OECD/DAC, "Principles for Good International Engagement in Fragile States and Situations"

38 Becker, Jasper, "Preface: Rogue state in Rogue Regime: Kim Jong Il and the looming threat of North Korea"

39 OECD/DAC, "Poverty Reduction"

40 OECD, "Poor Performers: Basic Approaches for Supporting Development in Difficult Partnerships"

41 Chauvet, "Policy Turnarounds in Failing States"

42 OECD, "Paris Declaration on Aid Effectiveness: Ownership, Harmonization, Alignment, Results and Mutual Accountability"

43 Bolton, John R., "Nuclear Weapons and Rogue states: Challenge and Response"

44 World bank, "Low-Income Countries Under Stress: Update" World Bank

45 Zartman, I. William, "Introduction: Posing the Problem of State Collapse" Lynne Rienner 1995

46 Klotzel, Kurt, "International Strategies in Fragile States: Expanding the Toolbox?" Centre for Applied Policy Research

47 Ellis, Stephen, "How to Rebuild Africa" 84 (84): 2005

48 OECD, "Harmonizing Doner Practices for Effective Aid Delivery"

49 Sekhri, Neelam, "From Funding to Action: Strengthening Healthcare Systems in Sub-Saharan Africa" Center for Public-Private Partnership, Global health Initiative, World Economic Forum

50 Valaskakis, Kimon, "From 'Westphaila' to 'Seattle': Long-Term Trends in Global Governance" Expo 2000 2000

51 World bank, "Fragile States: The LICUS Initiative" World Bank

52 Torres, "Fragile States: Defining Difficult Environments for Poverty Reduction in Poverty Reduction in Difficult Environments Working Paper 1" Department for International Development

53 USAID(United State Agency for International Development), "Fragile States Indicators: A Supplement to the Country Analytical Template" USAID

54 USAID, "Fragile State Strategy" USAID

55 Chomsky, Noam, "Failed States: The Abuse of Power and the Assault on Democracy" Metropolitan Books 2006

56 Rotberg, Robert I, "Failed States, Collapsed States, Weak States: Causes and Indicators in State Failure and State Weakness in a Time of Terror" 2003

57 Horowitz, Donald, "Ethnic Groups in Conflict, Berkley" University of California Press 1985

58 World Bank IEG, "Engaging with Fragile States: An IEG Review of World Bank Support to Low Income Countries Under Stress" World Bank 2006

59 Crocker, "Engaging Failed States" 82 (82): 2003

60 Hamilton, Bob, "Efficiency and Distributional Implications of Global Restrictions on Labor Mobility: Calculations and Policy Implications" 14 (14): 1984

61 Birdsall, Nancy, "Economic Approaches to Population Growth in Handbook of Development Economics" Elsevier 1998

62 Takeyh, Ray, "Do Terrorist Networks Need a Home?" 25 (25): 2002

63 Chauvet, Lisa, "Development Effectiveness in Fragile States: Spillovers and Turnarounds" Centre for the Study of African Economies in Oxford University. Mimeo 2004

64 OECD, "Development Cooperation in Difficult Partnerships"

65 Picciotto, Robert, "Development Cooperation and Performance Evaluation: The Monterrey Challenge" World Bank 2002

66 Singh, Nirvikar, "Cultural Conflict in India: Punjab and Kashmir in The Myth of Ethnic Conflict" University of California Press 1999

67 Stedman, Stephen, "Conflict and Conciliation in Sub-Saharan Africa in The international Dimensions of Internal Conflict" MIT Press 1998

68 Krasner, Stephen D, "Compromising Westphalia" 20 (20): 1995

69 World bank, "Composite Governance Indicator 2005" World Bank 2005

70 Gurr, Ted Robert, "Civil Conflict in the 1960s: A Reciprocal Theoretical System with Parameter Estimates" 6 (6): 1998

71 Radelet, Steven, "Challenging Foreign Aid: A policy maker's Guide to the Millenium Challenge Account" Center for Global Development 2002

72 Easterly, William, "Can Foreign Aid Buy Growth?" 17 (17): 2003

73 Carment, David, "Assessing State Failure: Implications for Theory and Policy" 24 (24): 2003

74 Berry, Chris, "Approaches to Improving the Delivery of Social Services in Difficult Environments" Department for International Development

75 Wise William M, "American Perspectives on the Threat Posed by Weak and Failing Asian States" Paper presented at the U.S.-China Conference on Areas of Instability and Emerging Threats

76 Leader, Nicholas, "Aid Instrument in Fragile States" 2005

77 Radelet, Steven, "Aid Effectiveness and the Millennium Development Goals" 2004

78 OECD, "Accelerating Pro-Poor Growth through Support for Private Sector Development: An Analytical Framework"

79 Sorensen, Georg, "A State Is Not a State: Types of Statehood and Patterns of Conflict after the Cold War" United Nations University Press 1999

80 Kaplan, Seth D, "2008, Fixing Fragile States"