The Issue-Attention Cycle and Public Policy in the United States

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Four decades ago, Anthony Downs offered a compelling picture of the public policy issue-attention cycle. This paper offers a systematic test of how well 50 social issues in the United States fit the model over an extended period of time. A total of 29 issues that fit Downs’s model are analyzed in order to test Downs’s theory that an increase in public interest in an issue increases the government’s efforts to address the issue. The results were quite mixed. For 11 issues, there was a positive relationship between the level of media attention and the number of bills passed. This provides partial support for Downs’s theory. Downs postulated that state intervention occurs when there is a high level of public concern. On the other hand, the results also reveal that a large number of policies were implemented when the level of media attention was not at its peak, resulting in either no relationship between attention and legislation or a negative relationship.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Downs, A, "Up and down with ecology—the issue attention cycle" 28 : 38-50, 1972

2 Gitlin, T., "The whole world is watching" University of California Press 1980

3 Hilgartner, S., "The rise and fall of social problems: A public arenas model" 94 (94): 53-78, 1988

4 Jones, B. D., "The politics of attention: How government prioritizes problems" University of Chicago Press 2005

5 Hasan, N. S., "The issue-attention recycle: More ups than downs anticipated" 1989

6 Park, K., "The issue-attention cycle of 100 social issues in Korea" 34 (34): 143-167, 2000

7 Gusfield, J. R., "The culture of public problems" University of Chicago Press 1981

8 Kempe, C. H., "The battered child syndrome" 181 : 17-42, 1962

9 박기묵, "The Life Cycle of Newspaper Coverage of a Public Issue: Candlelight Protests against US Beef Imports in South Korea" 서울대학교행정대학원 27 (27): 41-56, 2012

10 Suits, D. B., "Spline function fitted by standard regression methods" 60 (60): 132-139, 1977

11 Song, K., "Social welfare and policy process" Taeyoung 1994

12 Spector, M., "Social problems: A re-formulation" 21 (21): 145-159, 1973

13 Moyer, D., "Social problems in science and for science" 2 (2): 93-116, 1980

14 Mauss, M. L., "Social problems as social movements" Lippincott 1975

15 Blumer, H., "Social problems as collective behavior" 18 (18): 298-306, 1971

16 Kellow, A., "Promoting elegance in policy theory: Simplifying Lowi’s arenas of power" 16 (16): 713-724, 1988

17 Wilson, J. Q., "Political organization" Basic Books 1973

18 Cobb, R. W., "Participation in American politics: The dynamics of agenda-building" Johns Hopkins University Press 1983

19 Molotch, H., "News as purposive behavior: On the strategic uses of routine events, accidents, and scandals" 39 (39): 101-112, 1974

20 MacKuen, M. J., "More than news" Sage 1981

21 Tuchman, G., "Making news: A study in the construction of reality" Free Press 1978

22 Sabatier, P., "Introduction. Policy change and policy oriented learning: Exploring an advocacy coalition framework" 21 (21): 123-277, 1988

23 Erbring, L., "Front-page news and real-world cues : A new look at agenda-setting by the media" 24 (24): 16-49, 1980

24 Lowi, T. J., "Four systems of policy, politics, and choice" 32 (32): 298-310, 1972

25 Dunlap, R. E., "Environmental problems and protection" 55 : 651-671, 1991

26 Greene, W. H., "Econometric analysis" Macmillan 1990

27 Schudson, M., "Discovering the news: A social history of American newspapers" Basic Books 1978

28 Gans, H. J., "Deciding what’s news" Pantheon 1979

29 정병걸, "BPR과 지식관리의 확산: 누적적 확산 혹은 유행" 한국행정연구원 15 (15): 271-295, 2006

30 Mok, J. W., "An issue attention cycle regarding air pollution" 3 (3): 199-211, 1993

31 Winter, J. P., "Agenda setting for the civil rights issue" 45 (45): 376-383, 1981