Since the establishment of the Korean National Police Agency, the centralized national police system has been consistently maintained. It can be acknowledged that this system has contributed to the efficient and effective management of special interna...
Since the establishment of the Korean National Police Agency, the centralized national police system has been consistently maintained. It can be acknowledged that this system has contributed to the efficient and effective management of special internal security issues as well as the unstable political and social circumstances that are the by-product of a nation divided between south and north with diametrically opposed political philosophies. However, it must be admitted that not enough attention has been given to serving the overall needs of the general public, particularly in safeguarding the life and property of the public. Consequently, the true function of the police force has become distorted and a target of disdain and distrust from the public.
Much of this is the result of an overburdened National Police which has been encumbered with myriad functions that should be administered by other local governmental agencies. In order to rectify these dire situations and strengthen public-oriented service, a systematic apparatus which ensures the political neutrality and autonomy of the police is required. The formation of a police commission and the decentralization of the police system had been proposed repeatedly whenever any change in governmental organization or any political upheaval has occurred. However, many attempts to carry them out have fallen short because of conflicting interests of political parties exercising government power and the indifference of the public.
The current statute governing the police is the Police Law 1991, which aims to democratize the police administration to enable it to carry out its businesses more effectively, and contains plans to make the National Police Agency structurally independent from the Ministry of Government Administration and Home Affairs and set up a Police Commission. However, as this law is only a compromise which paved the way for the adoption of a sort of commission system to the National Police, the original intent of the legislation has faded. That is, while the objective and role of an Autonomous Police Commission system has been established, its authority to function effectively is without any real teeth. So the Police Commission established by law functions as an ineffective commission which has not met the genuine aim to set up a truly effectual police commission. Therefore, the police ideology of ensuring democracy, political autonomy and positive service to the public is not being properly served. Moreover, it would be no exaggeration to say that most problems in the current Police Commission are derived from institutional weakness.
Over ten years has passed since the current Police Commission system was implemented. On the basis of analyzed results on the administration at present, this paper has pinned reform-required areas down from the viewpoints of system, functions and operations.
Firstly, in the area of the system, it is asserted that the Police Commission be neutralized politically to be in accord with its foundational objective. This methodology strives to improve the democracy of the police administration and therefore raise the position of the Police Commission. The administration will thus evolve into a representative system which is able to control and regulate the police forces. Furthermore, its control should be shifted up from the Minister of Government Adminstration and Home Affairs to the Prime Minister.
Secondly, in the area of functions, the sphere of the Police Commission's duties should be set up clearly to prevent the National Police Agency from making a decision on its own accord, and also performing business functions before administration. The function of collecting public opinions, such as a public forum, should also be strengthened to advance the credibility of decision making of the Police Commission of which representation is weak. It is additionally suggested that since the Personnel Hearing Law is carried out, the Appointment Encore Right of the Police Commission to Police Commissioner should be made more substantial and the regulation function of the Police Commission should be made stronger. This will block human rights abuse or corruption in police enforcement and provide an Internal Affairs Intervention Right, a Civilian Complaint Dealing Right, and a function of controling of Civilian Inspection Teams given to the Police Commission to be able to practically regulate and control the police forces.
Lastly, in the area of operations, to vitalize the Police Commission more, its budget should be adjusted to a more realistic level and an Assistant Officers system should be established.
On the other hand, the police commission system originates from the concept of the autonomous police system, and it must be admitted that the Korean National Police Commission is fundamentally limited in its ability to advance itself into a progressive entity because an autonomous police system has not been introduced to the Korean Police Force.
As police functions become increasingly diversified, it is necessary for the Korean police force to be decentralized to carry out police duties suitable to the current times of localization. Efforts to respond to this tendency was visualized after the so-called Government of Citizens was inaugurated in 1998. Therefore, the Korean National Police Agency installed the Committee for Institution Reform, and the revised Police Law was drafted in line with previous studies on adopting an autonomous police system. In this draft, the Korean Police forces were divided into the National Police and Local Autonomous Police. The National Police Commission, representing the Korean National Police Agency, was placed under the authority of the Prime Minister who administers and regulates the police forces. On the other hand, the police forces in major metropolitan cities and provinces, adopted the Greater City and Province Police Commissions to administer and regulate the police forces. It should be mentioned that problems and reform points indicated in this paper were also included in the draft.
However, the revised draft was nullified for the same reasons as mentioned above. On the occasion of the so-called Participation Government's inauguration in 2003, the decentralization of the police forces was realistically adopted as a subject of reform, and its institutionalization may be materialized in the near future. Therefore, it is expected that the future model of a Police Commission suggested in this paper under a decentralized police system may be a kind of an alternative.
First, a rational decentralization of the police forces is needed to be carried out. To ensure the efficiency and professionalism as well as democracy and dedication to service in police activities, the harmonious administration of the police forces between the central and provincial governments should also be instituted. Furthermore, a police system integrated between a National Police and an Autonomous Police should be introduced as an institutional foundation to perform police duties. In view of situation of our nation, such as the division of the South and North and the necessity of delivering wide-ranging police services, it is relevant that a National Police force be put in charge of the national sphere while Local Autonomous Police forces are installed to handle police duties of the local autonomous governments.
Second, taking this opportunity, the National Police should be reformed. To secure the political neutrality of the police and to make the police administration more equitable, a National Police Commission, possessing relative independence, should also be installed under the authority of the Prime Minister. This would enable the supervision of the National Police Agency while Greater City and Province Police Commissions supervise the police forces in the metropolitan, greater cities and provinces.
Third, it is expected that reform measures suggested in this paper will finally be materialized with the decentralization of the police forces, so that a Police Commission will realistically ensure the political independence and democracy of the police. In particular, its right of personnel management and its internal regulations should be strengthened, in order to allow the Police Commission to fully prosecute its management functions effectively.