The Impact of Rural Votes in Foreign Policies: The FTA Policies under the DPJ Government in Japan

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The recent trend of bilateral free trade agreements (FTAs) has pressured the governments of many countries to make such arrangements with their trade partners. Since its foundation in 1998, the Democratic Party of Japan (DPJ) has advocated free trade policies, partly because the party was an urban-based party. Thus, many expected that, when the DPJ assumed power in 2009, it would implement free trade policies as it had promised in the past. However, the DPJ government failed to deliver on its promise after spending three and a half years in office. It contrasts sharply with the Korean government under the leadership of Lee Myung-bak, which managed to conclude FTAs with its major trade partners, including the United States and the European Union. Both governments' free trade policies faced strong opposition from the agricultural industry, as farmers in Japan and Korea lacked international competitiveness. What explains the reasons why the Japanese government has been struggling to implement its free trade policies, while its Korean counterpart succeeded in signing a number of FTAs? Focusing primarily on the case of Japan and using the Korean case as reference, this study tries to provide an explanation for this puzzle by analyzing the impact of rural votes in the policy-making process.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Yamada, M., "Yunyū Shokuhin Ni Nihon Wa Tsubusareru" Seihodo 2003

2 Yaguchi, Y., "WTO Taiseika No Nihon Nōgyō" Nihon Keizai Ryoronsha 2002

3 Goudo, Y., "The puzzle of small farming in Japan" 1-34, 2007

4 Pekkanen, S., "The politics of Japan’s WTO strategies" 48 (48): 135-147, 2004

5 Yoshimatsu, H., "The politics of Japan’s Free Trade Agreement" 36 (36): 479-499, 2006

6 Krauss, E., "The domestic politics of Japan’s regional foreign economic policies, In Trade Policy in the Asia-Pacific" Springer 49-69, 2010

7 Kim, J., "South Korea’s FTA policymaking process: implications for East Asian community" 17 : 61-77, 2011

8 The Democratic Party of Japan, "Seiken Seisaku Iinkai Teigen [Policy Council proposals]"

9 Lee, T., "Retaining the quota system in the South Korean rice market" 39 (39): 440-462, 2009

10 The Democratic Party of Japan, "Priority policies in the nationwide local election"

11 Yoshimatsu, H., "Political leaders’ preferences and trade policy: comparing FTA politics in Japan and South Korea" 4 (4): 193-212, 2012

12 Saito, J., "Onkoshugi To Bōeki Jiyūka: Kome Hogo Nōsei No Nikkan Hikaku" 28 (28): 114-134, 2012

13 Yamashita, K., "Nōkyō no Taizai" Takarajimasha 2009

14 Honma, M., "Nōka no Shotokuhoshō Minaoshiwo [The income supporting system for farmers needs to be revised]"

15 Takayasu, Y., "Nōgyō Higai Ha Kicchiri Hoshō, Seron Taiō Wa Kanpekidatta FTA Taisaku" 2010

16 Honma, M., "Nihon Nōgyō No Kokusaika To Seiji: Nōkyō No Henkaku" 2004

17 Goudo, Y., "Nihon No Shoku to Nō: Kiki No Honshitsu" NTT Shuppan 2006

18 The Japanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs, "Nihon Keizai Shimbun Sha-CSIS Kyōsai Symposium Niokeru Maehara Gaimu Daijin Kōen"

19 The Democratic Party of Japan, "Minshutō Seisakushū: Watashitachi no Mezasu Shakai [DPJ policies: our ideal society]"

20 Miura, H., "Minshutō Seikenni Okeru Kokunai SesakuIshi Kettei Shisutemu" 18 : 235-252, 2012

21 Sasada, H., "Minshutō Seiken ni Okeru FTA Seisaku, In Naze Regionalism Nanoka" Nakanishiya Shuppan 215-242, 2013

22 Hamamoto, S., "Minshutō Ni Okeru Yakushoku Haibun No Seidoka, In Minshuto no Soshiki to Seisaku" Toyo Keizai Shinpo Sha 29-69, 2011

23 Karikomi, S., "Kankoku No FTA Senryaku"

24 Karikomi, S., "Kankoku No FTA Senryaku" 2 : 23-42, 2012

25 Asaba, Y., "Kankoku No Daitōryōsei, In Ajia Ni Okeru Daitōryōsei No Hikakuseiji" Mineruva Shobō 39-59, 2010

26 Sasada, H., "Japan’s new agricultural trade policy and electoral reform: “Agricultural policy in an offensive posture [seme no nōsei]" 9 (9): 121-144, 2008

27 Yoshimatsu, H., "Japan’s Keidanren and free trade agreements" 45 (45): 258-278, 2005

28 Yoshimatsu, H., "Japan’s FTA strategy toward highly developing countries: comparing Australia’s and Switzerland’s experiences 2000–09" 50 (50): 1058-1081, 2010

29 Krauss, E., "Japan’s Democracy: How Much Change" Foreign Policy Association 1995

30 Mulgan, A. G., "Japan’s Agricultural Policy Regime" Routledge 2008

31 The Japanese Ministry of Agriculture, "Heisei21-nen Jigyō Nendo Sōgō Nōkyō Tōkei Hyō"

32 The Japanese Ministry of Internal Affairs Statistics Bureau, "Heisei 24-nen Nihon Tokei Nenkan, In The Japan Statistical Yearbook 2012" 2012

33 Honma, M., "Gendai Nihon Nōgyō No Seisakukatei" Keio University Press 2010

34 Park, S., "Forming a cross-regional partnership: the South Korea-Chile FTA and its implications" 80 (80): 259-278, 2007

35 The Japan External Trade Organization (JETRO), "FTA/EPA: Sekai no Genjō"

36 Yusaku Horiuchi, "Cultivating Rice and Votes: The Institutional Origins of Agricultural Protectionism in Japan" 동아시아연구원 10 (10): 425-452, 2010

37 Solis, M., "Can FTAs deliver market labialization in Japan? A study on domestic political determinants" 17 (17): 209-237, 2010

38 Choi, B., "Asymmetry in Japan and Korea’s agricultural liberalization in FTA: Domestic trade governance perspective" 24 (24): 505-527, 2011

39 The Japanese Ministry of Foreign Affairs, "A pamphlet: EPA/FTA"

40 Tanaka, A., "2009-nen Naze Seikenkōtai Dattanoka" Keiso Shobo 2009